Fury at low fines in Liverpool crane death case

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

A crane driver and hire firm Bryn Thomas have been fined a total of £7,000 after an overloaded crane toppled and crushed a worker in Liverpool.

Supervisor Mark Thornton, 46, was killed when a six-tonne steel column hit him on a Liverpool building site four years ago.

Thornton was guiding a steel column with a rope when the jibbed Demag AC 150 telescopic mobile crane buckled and toppled over.

The steel beam struck Thornton on the head and shoulders killing him instantly.

The crane driver, crane hire firm and construction firm that employed Thornton were all prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive.

North Wales mobile specialist Bryn Thomas Crane Hire admitted health and safety breaches for failing to ensure that its equipment was in good working order.

Liverpool Crown Court fined the firm £4,500 – a fine ‘significantly reduced’ because the company is in administration.

Judge Nigel Gilmour, QC, said he was unable to impose an appropriate fine of £300,000 on Bryn Thomas Crane Hire because it had now gone into administration with massive debts.

The mobile crane hirer was placed into administration earlier this year, although its assets were bought by a company trading as Bryn Thomas Cranes.

Merseyside crane operator Frederick Scott was fined £2,500 after he admitted to several health and safety breaches including failing to check the weight of the column and that a lift plan had been completed.

The driver, who had only three months experience, also admitted failing to check the crane’s overload alarm was audible and override switches were working, neither of which was the case.

Thornton’s employer and the third defendant Sitewell Construction is to be sentenced at a later date while its financial situation is examined by the court’s forensic accountants.

Thornton’s daughter Cheryl told the Liverpool Daily Post: “No justice was brought whatsoever. It could have been prevented and that is what makes it all the worse – it did not have to happen.

“These companies get a minimal fine and it is all over. It is not over for us. We have to live with this forever.”

Latest news

Interserve finance chief quits

Mark Whiteling exits weeks after banks take control in pre-pack deal
7 hours ago

Green light for reworked Paddington Cucumber

Reuben Brothers gain revised planning for landmark west London tower
5 hours ago

Winners unveiled for £400m Dounreay decommissioning

28 firms named on major nuclear framework: Full list of winners
14 hours ago

Guinness plans largest ever homes scheme in Leeds

Plan for over 900 homes at Leeds South Bank site
14 hours ago

Opinion: Lack of talent at the top is hurting construction

Time to promote a new generation of younger directors to end the "over-optimism" bonus culture
14 hours ago

Ex-Crossrail chief Wolstenholme wanted more bonus cash

Project chief challenged decision to deny him extra pay for performance
1 day ago

Waiting over for £340m Belgravia council estate rebuild

Westminster council seeks firm for Ebury Bridge Estate rebuild
14 hours ago

Morrison takes on refurb job from failed contractor

Morrison to complete renovation scheme after original builder went bust
1 day ago

Call-up for £110m Southsea seafront defence job

Portsmouth city council aims to shortlist three firms to bid eight year project
14 hours ago

Eight placed on £200m London Universities framework

Graham, Speller, 8build and Walter Lilly among preferred list
1 day ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
12 months ago

Giant ‘concreteberg’ blocks sewers in Islington

Work starts to chisel out 105 tonne blockage as hunt starts for culprits
2 days ago

Lendlease chief jumps for Crown Estate top job

Dan Labbad to take Crown Estate chief executive role at start of 2020
2 days ago

Race starts for £2bn YORcivil framework places

Eight firms to share £2bn pipeline over four years
2 days ago

Green light for £150m Bolton Church Wharf regen plan

Muse approved to start demolition and work up details of scheme
2 days ago

Wills Bros wins £31.5m Maybole Bypass in Scotland

5.2km bypass on A77 in south west Scotland will employ 165 workers at peak
2 days ago

VINCI starts work on new £100m Birmingham hospital

Contractor gets underway on three-year build programme
6 days ago

Pay row set to escalate on HS2 enabling works site

Dispute set to intensify over rates paid by labour supplier
7 days ago

Four civils firms scoop £2.6bn flood and coastal framework

Kier breaks into Environment Agency preferred contractors list
7 days ago

Costain making engineers redundant at tech centre

Contractor cutting jobs at technology division it bought for £17m in 2016
7 days ago

Dozen firms win £500m City of London deal

Morgan Sindall, Osborne and Speller Metcalfe among winners
7 days ago

New £3m fund to improve construction procurement

Companies invited to bid for cash grants in CITB-led efficiency drive
7 days ago

Green light for vast Nottingham Boots Island scheme

Developer Conygar plans to build a 2m sq ft mixed-use scheme
7 days ago

Goldman Sachs bankrolls Brum’s tallest resi project

Builder Sisk can now start work on 42-storey Broad Street skyscraper
7 days ago

SME contractors agree 2.75% pay deal for workers

Annual pay increase will see hourly craft rates rise to £12.79
1 week ago

Lakehouse subbie goes after Sureserve for cash

Specialist wins adjudication award after contractor goes bust
1 week ago

Firms on alert for M4 Newport £185m enabling works

Bidders day planned ahead of July invitation to tender
1 week ago

Robertson hires Laing O’Rourke infrastructure ops director

Bryan Glass will head Robertson's civil engineering business in Scotland
1 week ago

Wates starts £24m Shoreham flood defence

Enabling works to pave way for 540-home Free Wharf scheme
1 week ago

£400m Eastern Highways Framework up for renewal

Essex County Council to invite bids for third generation framework in June
1 week ago

Contractor services