Fury at low fines in Liverpool crane death case

Aaron Morby 7 years ago
Share

A crane driver and hire firm Bryn Thomas have been fined a total of £7,000 after an overloaded crane toppled and crushed a worker in Liverpool.

Supervisor Mark Thornton, 46, was killed when a six-tonne steel column hit him on a Liverpool building site four years ago.

Thornton was guiding a steel column with a rope when the jibbed Demag AC 150 telescopic mobile crane buckled and toppled over.

The steel beam struck Thornton on the head and shoulders killing him instantly.

The crane driver, crane hire firm and construction firm that employed Thornton were all prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive.

North Wales mobile specialist Bryn Thomas Crane Hire admitted health and safety breaches for failing to ensure that its equipment was in good working order.

Liverpool Crown Court fined the firm £4,500 – a fine ‘significantly reduced’ because the company is in administration.

Judge Nigel Gilmour, QC, said he was unable to impose an appropriate fine of £300,000 on Bryn Thomas Crane Hire because it had now gone into administration with massive debts.

The mobile crane hirer was placed into administration earlier this year, although its assets were bought by a company trading as Bryn Thomas Cranes.

Merseyside crane operator Frederick Scott was fined £2,500 after he admitted to several health and safety breaches including failing to check the weight of the column and that a lift plan had been completed.

The driver, who had only three months experience, also admitted failing to check the crane’s overload alarm was audible and override switches were working, neither of which was the case.

Thornton’s employer and the third defendant Sitewell Construction is to be sentenced at a later date while its financial situation is examined by the court’s forensic accountants.

Thornton’s daughter Cheryl told the Liverpool Daily Post: “No justice was brought whatsoever. It could have been prevented and that is what makes it all the worse – it did not have to happen.

“These companies get a minimal fine and it is all over. It is not over for us. We have to live with this forever.”

Latest news

Brighton Uni starts bid race for £20m academic building

Six floor building will be located next to the Preston barracks redevelopment site
39 mins ago

Gary Neville £200m Manchester tower gets the final nod

39-storey Deansgate skyscraper complex will be home to a 5-star hotel, luxury flats and offices
22 hours ago

Thames Tideway TBMs placed for big drive

Tunnelling to start later this year on 12km central section - picture special
21 hours ago

Contractor fined over unsafe fleet of cherry pickers

HSE investigation finds lack of maintenance regime
15 hours ago

Network Rail bans retentions to support supply chain

CP6 overhaul sees switch to project bank accounts with Tier 1 firms told to pay in 28 days
2 days ago

ISG clinches £34m Twickenham campus scheme

Firm to deliver 160,000 sq ft teaching block for Richmond upon Thames College
22 hours ago

HB Reavis raids Argent for major Waterloo scheme boss

Joe Martin joins as UK construction director for 1m sq ft Elizabeth House job
2 days ago

Scotland to require sprinklers in all new social housing

Sprinklers to be compulsory in all social housing of over 10 people
2 days ago

Perfect Circle wins £300m Bristol Uni campus

AECOM, Gleeds and Pick Everard JV signed up for Temple Quarter Enterprise Campus
2 days ago

Single alliance plan for all smart motorways work

Highways England floats radical alliancing plan using three main contractors
2 days ago

Berkeley Group warns profits to drop 30% next year

London house builder's profit hits high water mark of £935m
2 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
2 months ago

£400m north west small projects framework launched

Procure North West (Lite) framework to cover projects up to £1m and M&E work
2 days ago

More than half of construction workers in London from EU

Brexit alarm over Capital's reliance on foreign labour
2 days ago

Severfield margins restored to 8% target

Steelwork contractor's profit rises by nearly 20% to £23.5m
2 days ago

Galliford Try bags £45m Leeds Beckett sports research hub

Demolition to start next month at the Headingley campus
2 days ago

Mears to help homeless in £75m housing deal

Contractor to buy and refurb 365 homes in Waltham Forest
2 days ago

Sellafield teams cut budget overruns in half

Sellafield clean-up facing £900m overspend despite improved delivery
2 days ago

Network Rail starts race for £5bn trio of trackwork deals

The 10-year alliance deals will be let to designer/contractor JVs
3 days ago

Multiplex bags £400m New Scotland Yard redevelopment

Multiplex to start six-tower Westminster Broadway scheme in January
3 days ago

Kier defends fire safety strategy after Glasgow blaze

Contractors had agreed safeguards in place as repair estimates hit £100m
3 days ago

McCarthy & Stone boss to step down after profit warning

Retirement home builder to streamline after poor spring sales
3 days ago

Capita sells Constructionline to private equity giant

Procurement and supply chain specialist sold for £160m
3 days ago

McLaren lands new HQ for consultant Dar Group

John F Hunt to start demolition work in August to make way for new nine-storey scheme
4 days ago

Countryside strikes deal for 5,000 private rental homes

Deal with family private rental specialist allows Countryside to expand its partnerships business
3 days ago

Balfour Beatty fined £500,000 for white finger exposure

Court hears how workers were exposed to hand-arm vibration risk for nine years
4 days ago

On-site training boost to ease skills shortages

New £22m Construction Skills Fund now open for applications
4 days ago

Chandler promoted to Wates board

Wates MD, Paul Chandler, ushers in nearly £3bn of new business
4 days ago

Legal firm moves into cost consultancy

Blake Morgan hires former Aecom director to head project management and cost consultancy
4 days ago

Fire destroys Kier restoration of Glasgow School of Art

Second major blaze in four years reduces £35m of repair work to ashes
6 days ago

Contractor services