Fury at low fines in Liverpool crane death case

Aaron Morby 7 years ago
Share

A crane driver and hire firm Bryn Thomas have been fined a total of £7,000 after an overloaded crane toppled and crushed a worker in Liverpool.

Supervisor Mark Thornton, 46, was killed when a six-tonne steel column hit him on a Liverpool building site four years ago.

Thornton was guiding a steel column with a rope when the jibbed Demag AC 150 telescopic mobile crane buckled and toppled over.

The steel beam struck Thornton on the head and shoulders killing him instantly.

The crane driver, crane hire firm and construction firm that employed Thornton were all prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive.

North Wales mobile specialist Bryn Thomas Crane Hire admitted health and safety breaches for failing to ensure that its equipment was in good working order.

Liverpool Crown Court fined the firm £4,500 – a fine ‘significantly reduced’ because the company is in administration.

Judge Nigel Gilmour, QC, said he was unable to impose an appropriate fine of £300,000 on Bryn Thomas Crane Hire because it had now gone into administration with massive debts.

The mobile crane hirer was placed into administration earlier this year, although its assets were bought by a company trading as Bryn Thomas Cranes.

Merseyside crane operator Frederick Scott was fined £2,500 after he admitted to several health and safety breaches including failing to check the weight of the column and that a lift plan had been completed.

The driver, who had only three months experience, also admitted failing to check the crane’s overload alarm was audible and override switches were working, neither of which was the case.

Thornton’s employer and the third defendant Sitewell Construction is to be sentenced at a later date while its financial situation is examined by the court’s forensic accountants.

Thornton’s daughter Cheryl told the Liverpool Daily Post: “No justice was brought whatsoever. It could have been prevented and that is what makes it all the worse – it did not have to happen.

“These companies get a minimal fine and it is all over. It is not over for us. We have to live with this forever.”

Latest news

Crossrail site protest as Balfour lays off 50 sparks

Contractor insists redundancies are unconnected to £5,000-a-head finishing bonus demands
1 day ago

Interserve seals £180m lending deal for extra headroom

Debbie White seals deal for more time to restructure business
5 hours ago

Severfield lands steelwork package for Google HQ

Specialist to start work in June for main contractor Lendlease at King's Cross site
6 hours ago

Kier secures £138m London health deal

Kier P22 work haul soars to £400m
5 hours ago

Scape research reveals need for huge school building push

Procurement body calls for national school building strategy
6 hours ago

Carillion wins another £11.6m rail electrification deal

Network Rail awards station upgrade deal on Glasgow to Edinburgh route
1 day ago

Galliford Try wins £24m M49 junction

Work to start on new junction at Avonmouth in the New Year
6 hours ago

Costain director joins pipe-lining specialist

Tim Bowen takes the helm at Aquam to deliver ambitious expansion plan
1 day ago

Highways England to trial self healing roads

Sunflower oil capsules in asphalt could save £260m a year
1 day ago

Tarmac swaps quarries for Breedon concrete plants

Tarmac offloads four quarries for 27 Breedon ready-mixed concrete plants
1 day ago

Mace wins £140m London School of Economics project

Work to start on Marshall building once McGee completes demolition in the spring
2 days ago

Construction start date for £350m Tower Hamlets site

Planning go-ahead for Galliard Homes and Lindhill at Ailsa Wharf
2 days ago

Specialist Mick George moves into housebuilding

Civils contractor forms joint venture to target housing market
1 day ago

Fusion21 launches £150m sprinkler supplier panel

Local authorities and housing associations call for post-Grenfell preferred supplier list
2 days ago

Ardmore wins £77m Stratford hotel contract

Two-year build programme gets underway at the 18-storey Gantry development
2 days ago

Boost your online presence with the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
1 month ago

Lovell to start £30m Doncaster Lakeside scheme

Eastern division boasts £100m forward order book from string of schemes
1 day ago

Balfour Beatty on track for 2-3% margin by late 2018

Leo Quinn confident of paying down borrowings as they fall due in 2018
2 days ago

Skanska and Multiplex eye £100m City fringe office job

Aldgate Developments prepares to start £100m phase 2 office complex
2 days ago

Speller Metcalfe wins “non-confrontational” £16m contract

Contractor to start revamp of Derby Silk Mill next year using innovative procurement model
2 days ago

Plans for new £80m library at University of Bristol

Design team appointed as construction set to start in summer of 2019
2 days ago

Berkeley director’s wife sells £2.7m shares

Karen Ellis and John Armitt cash in shares as Berkeley soars to record high
2 days ago

Growing Geordie PRS firm plans Brum scheme

All Saints Living plans a string of build to rent projects
2 days ago

February start for £70m Brentford FC stadium

Buckingham Group set to start work on scaled-down Bees ground in West London
3 days ago

Interserve appoints ‘transformation’ director

Sally Cabrini joins board from United Utilities as Interserve set to be streamlined
3 days ago

Race on for £20m Luton Airport multi-storey car park

Bidding opens for a second major airport car park
3 days ago

Developer chosen for trio of Woking towers

Mixed-use specialist Coplan aims to start work on town centre transformation in 2021
3 days ago

Barhale achieves breakthrough on tunnel under the Thames

Civils specialist takes just three weeks to bore 330 metre tunnel for new gas pipes
3 days ago

Construction outlook brightens despite output gloom

HS2 awards see record spike in orders figures during the third quarter
6 days ago

Contractors to benefit from prequal red tape cut

Revamp of PAS 91 will help buyers know more about suppliers
6 days ago

Contractor services