M&S hit with £1m asbestos fine for unsafe refurb work

Grant Prior 6 years ago
Share

Marks and Spencer and three of its contractors have been fined a total of £1.15m for putting shoppers and construction workers at risk of asbestos exposure during refurbishment work on two stores in Reading and Bournemouth.

A sentencing hearing at Bournemouth Crown Court today resulted in Marks and Spencer being fined £1m and ordered to pay costs of £600,000.

Styles & Wood was fined £100,000 and ordered to pay costs of £40,000 and Willmott Dixon  was fined £50,000 and ordered to pay costs of £75,000.

Asbestos specialist PA Realisations (formerly Pectel Ltd) is now in administration and was fined a token £200.

Willmott Dixon Construction is applying for permission to appeal against the conviction.

Folowing a prosecution brought by the Health and Safety Executive, Marks and Spencer, Willmott Dixon and PA Realisations were found guilty in July 2011.

Styles & Wood Limited pleaded guilty at an earlier hearing in January 2010.

During the three month trial which ended in July 2011, Winchester Crown Court heard construction workers at the two stores removed asbestos-containing materials that were present in the ceiling tiles and elsewhere.

The court heard that the client, Marks and Spencer plc, did not allocate sufficient time and space for the removal of asbestos-containing materials at the Reading store.

The contractors had to work overnight in enclosures on the shop floor, with the aim of completing small areas of asbestos removal before the shop opened to the public each day.

HSE alleged that Marks and Spencer failed to ensure that work at the Reading store complied with the appropriate minimum standards set out in legislation and approved codes of practice.

The company had produced its own guidance on how asbestos should be removed inside its stores, and the court heard that this guidance was followed by contractors inappropriately during major refurbishment.

The contractor, PA Realisations, failed to reduce to a minimum the spread of asbestos to the Reading shop floor.

Witnesses said that areas cleaned by the company were re-contaminated by air moving through the void between the ceiling tiles and the floor above, and by poor standards of work.

Styles & Wood, the principal contractor at the Reading store, admitted that it should not have permitted a method of asbestos removal which did not allow for adequate sealing of the ceiling void, which resulted in risks to contractors on site.

The principal contractor at the Bournemouth store, Wilmott Dixon, failed to plan, manage and monitor removal of asbestos-containing materials.

It did not prevent the possibility of asbestos being disturbed by its workers in areas that had not been surveyed extensively.

After the sentencing, Richard Boland, HSE’s Southern Head of Operations for Construction, said: “This outcome should act as a wake up call that any refurbishment programmes involving asbestos-containing materials must be properly resourced, both in terms of time and money – no matter what.

“Large retailers and other organisations who carry out major refurbishment works must give contractors enough time and space within the store to carry out the works safely.

“Where this is not done, and construction workers and the public are put at risk, HSE will not hesitate in taking robust enforcement action.”

A Willmott Dixon statement said: “We are disappointed and surprised by today’s verdict – it is the first time in our 160 year history that we have been convicted of a health and safety related offence.

“Health and safety is at the centre of everything Willmott Dixon does, underpinned by rigorous procedures and a ‘safety first’ culture.

“This is further strengthened by having one of the industry’s largest teams of in-house health and safety inspectors, who visit, monitor and assess each project on a regular basis. We are proud of our health and safety record, which we believe is one of the best in the industry.

“We believe we acted appropriately at all times on the project in Bournemouth for Marks and Spencer, which included using an HSE licensed and experienced asbestos removal subcontractor selected from the Marks and Spencer approved list, which we were required to use in sourcing a subcontractor.

“At the time we appointed and used the specialist asbestos removal subcontractor, we had no knowledge of the existing concerns the HSE had about their previous performance. Had we been informed they would not have been engaged.

“Clearly we have to take on board today’s verdict and will see what we can learn from the incident. We are however minded to appeal.”

Latest news

Carillion bankers set up £225m fund to help subcontractors

Task force launched to help stricken supply chain
2 hours ago

CITB calls on contractors to save Carillion apprentices

Skills body could be £3.8m better off following collapse
10 hours ago

Betting Spy: West Ham and Leicester at the double

Hammers can beat Bournemouth despite yet another injury to Andy Carroll
2 hours ago

Barratt London shelves 27-storey Aldgate tower project

Barratt abandons Phase 2 of city fringe tower scheme
1 day ago

Opinion: Carillion legacy must be pay and procurement reform

Carillion car-crash must finally jolt industry and government into action
17 hours ago

Banks pledge not to pull plug on Carillion subcontractors

High street lenders promise raft of measure to help small businesses
1 day ago

NAO challenges value of PFI contracts

Little evidence PFI offers more construction cost certainty or operating efficiency, says watchdog
17 hours ago

Skanska UK on alert as group plans 3,000 job cuts

Skanska Group says UK business focus to switch to core markets
2 days ago

Boost your online presence with the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
3 months ago

Sheffield United submits plan for South Stand

Championship club plans landmark stand raising capacity to 38,000 seats
18 hours ago

Kier fined £100,000 for hospital oil spill

Leak at Dorset hospital site lands contractor in court
18 hours ago

Carillion sites still on hold as hopes rise for services deals

Insolvency Service update gives hope to suppliers
1 day ago

Subcontractors left stranded by Carillion “early payment” system

Millions sitting in controversial system may never reach suppliers
2 days ago

Crunch day for over 8,000 Carillion staff

Carillion went bust with just £29m left and would have been out of cash today
2 days ago

Balfour tipped for Carillion’s Leeds ring road job

£115m East Leeds Orbital Route contract consolation for Balfour after £45m hit
2 days ago

Colmore Tang offers early payment to Carillion subbies

Birmingham contractor to speed-up payments to its suppliers hit by Carillion collapse
2 days ago

Lendlease launches £1.5bn build-to-rent partnership

First £450m tranche invested in private rental build at Elephant & Castle
2 days ago

Government fast-tracks probe into Carillion directors

Business secretary extends investigation into actions of directors and auditors
2 days ago

Race starts for £8.7bn Highways England framework

New approach will allow smaller contractors to take part in regional roads delivery
3 days ago

Supply chain owed £2bn by Carillion

Subcontractors hoping for protection from Project Bank Accounts
3 days ago

Carillion fall-out hits Van Elle and Speedy

Specialist subcontractors start to disclose cost of collapse
3 days ago

Winvic lands Sheffield build-to-rent deal

Construction to start this month on nine-storey block
3 days ago

Willmott Dixon wins second Kent Uni project

Firm to start £13m contract for School of Economic building
3 days ago

Carillion collapse to cost Balfour Beatty £45m

Galliford Try also hit for up to £40m on Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route
4 days ago

Carillion staff and suppliers told to carry on working

Liquidator sets up website offering advice to anyone hit by the collapse
4 days ago

Carillion goes into liquidation

Contractor loses its fight for survival
4 days ago

Construction stops on scores of Carillion projects

Clients in limbo as search starts for new contractors to take on jobs
4 days ago

BAM set for £32m Cornish schools batch

Works starts on first of three community schools
3 days ago

Watkin Jones chief to step down

Mark Watkin Jones announces intention to leave as firm delivers record results
4 days ago

Plan lodged for £35m Aberdeen Uni teaching hub

University plans to start work later this year
4 days ago

Contractor services