Crawler crane driver drowns in river

Grant Prior 4 years ago
Share

A crawler crane driver drowned while dredging an icy river in Cambridgeshire when his machine tipped into the frozen water.

crane-death-190x140-1

The Environment Agency has been ordered to pay more than £220,000 in fines and costs after Cambridge Crown Court heard a catalogue of errors caused the tragedy.

Simon Wenn, 43, from Wisbech, died on 8 December 2010 while working with a colleague on the maintenance of the Counter Drain at Mepal,.

He was operating a crawler crane rigged as a dragline to dredge sediment from the bed of the watercourse between the A142 bridge and Welches Dam.

The water was frozen and the river bank on which the crane was positioned was frosty and wet.

Timber tracking mats were laid to provide better grip and stability for the work to be carried out, and to protect the grassy bank from damage

The court heard that at around 9:30am Wenn was in the process of repositioning one of the tracking mats.

He used the crane to move the mat from behind and swing it to position in front of him.

But as it rotated round and through the water the crane started to slowly slip towards it and then tipped into the watercourse.

Wenn was trapped in the cab of the crane. Emergency services were called and tried to free him, but despite their best efforts both he and the machine continued to sink.

He drowned as freezing water filled the cab and was pronounced dead at 8:19pm.

An HSE investigation found that the crane Wenn was operating had been fitted with a 19 metre boom that exceeded the manufacturer specifications.

These stated that the maximum length of boom the crane should be fitted with was 16 metres when used as a dragline.

HSE also established that the Environment Agency had made an inadequate assessment of the technical requirements at the Mepal site, and of the impact of the cold weather.

The system of work for lifting and positioning the tracking mats was unsafe, and there was a lack of planning and competent site supervision.

The court was told that although Wenn was trained as a dragline operator, he had no prior experience of using a crawler crane for lifting operations.

When he attempted to move the mats, he dragged them through the water rather than lifting them clear.

His death followed a similar incident in Norfolk in 2008 involving a smaller tracked machine operated by Environment Agency employees.

HSE identified that it had failed to act on the findings of its own internal investigation into this incident.

The Environment Agency was fined £200,000 with costs of £28,548 after admitting safety breaches.

After the hearing, HSE inspector Stephen Faulkner said: “Simon Wenn’s tragic death could have been prevented had more thought and rigour been given to planning the dredging work, in order to minimise the risk arising from the use of the dragline to maintain this watercourse.

“The Environment Agency failed to heed warnings and learn lessons from a previous non-fatal, incident where there were similar failures to manage risk.”

The crane was rigged as a dragline

 

Latest plant

Arsonists strike at road works site in Surrey

Vandals burn out an excavator and dumper
2 days ago

Labourer crushed under three tonne road roller

Machine slides down steep bank and pins worker beneath it
3 days ago

Bryn Thomas Cranes opens new Manchester depot

Network expands with investment in Liebherr machines
2 weeks ago

Crane hire worker dies in roof plunge

Roofing firm and plant hirer fined £220,000 following skylight tragedy
4 weeks ago

Plant test cheats website dodges closure threat

CITB chiefs battling to close down site undermining tests for machinery drivers
1 month ago

Groundforce props up growth at Vp

Rental specialist boosts profit margins and predicts further growth in coming year
2 months ago

Leaking mobile crane closes London Blackwall Tunnel

Traffic chaos across South London as contractors battle to resurface damaged road
2 months ago

Steve Corcoran steps down at hirer Ardent

Fast-growing plant hirer starts hunt for new chief executive
2 months ago

Speedy crashes £58m into the red

Management team says Speedy on course for recovery after exceptional costs plunge hirer into loss
2 months ago

Safety warning after runaway rail repair vehicle hits work platforms

Seven workers have lucky escape in Wigan crash on Balfour Beatty Rail job
3 months ago

Flannery boosts fleet with £35m of Cat machines

Hire specialist boosts its hi-tech fleet to support major projects nationwide
3 months ago

Plant test cheats website to be shut down

CITB wins hearing to take control of Romanian based site and close it down
3 months ago

Hird buys first 8t Maeda spider crane

Fast-growing mini crane hirer snaps up first MC-815
3 months ago

H E Services orders 50 new JCB Hydradig excavators

JCB reports huge interest in new 10t wheeled excavator
3 months ago

Cheats buying site plant driving test answers online

Safety fears as website undermines CPCS theory exams
4 months ago

Vp buys spiderlift specialist Higher Access in £4.1m deal

Higher Access will operate alongside Vp's specialist material handling business UK Forks
5 months ago

Hire firm admits charges over Battersea crane collapse

Falcon Crane Hire to be sentenced later this month over tower crane disaster which killed two people
5 months ago

Ardent buys 60 Kubota minis in £100m spending push

Fleet of 1.5t minis represents plant hirers first bulk delivery this year
6 months ago

JCB rolls out new 4-6 tonne midi excavators

Redesigned dig end with longer boom and shorter dipper makes for easier site dump truck loading
6 months ago

Howard Plant Hire shifts up a gear with Volvo deal

Howard Civil Engineering plant hire business expands
6 months ago

Ardent seals 3-year Bovis Homes telehandler deal

At first 30 old Bovis Homes telehandlers will be replaced with new machines
6 months ago

Greg Fitzgerald takes chairman role at telehandler hirer Ardent

Galliford Try non-ex chairman joins Steve Corcoran at UK's largest telehandler hirer
6 months ago

Dumper truck driver breaks back in fall

Worker falls into drainage ditch during road improvements near Cambridge
6 months ago

Chinese plant giant launches $3.3bn bid for Terex

Chinese equipment maker Zoomlion confirms bid for Terex
6 months ago

Mobile crane operators vote to strike over pay

Threat of industry chaos as Ainscough workers plan series of one to three-day stoppages
6 months ago

Hewden ramps up lifting offer to contractors

Hewden boss Adrian Murphy aims to double size of crane hire business
7 months ago

Operator killed after falling under his reversing roller

Untrained operator crushed after falling from loose seat
7 months ago

Kevin Parkes promoted to managing director of Finning UK

Ex-Hewden boss promoted after returning to Finning nearly a year ago
7 months ago

Plant hirer Hawk soars with £8m funding

Hawk takes on former Aggregates Industries boss Bill Bolsover as chairman
7 months ago

A-Plant profits up but capex cut

Hire revenue rises to £131m in first half of the year
8 months ago