Crawler crane driver drowns in river

Grant Prior 5 years ago
Share

A crawler crane driver drowned while dredging an icy river in Cambridgeshire when his machine tipped into the frozen water.

The Environment Agency has been ordered to pay more than £220,000 in fines and costs after Cambridge Crown Court heard a catalogue of errors caused the tragedy.

Simon Wenn, 43, from Wisbech, died on 8 December 2010 while working with a colleague on the maintenance of the Counter Drain at Mepal,.

He was operating a crawler crane rigged as a dragline to dredge sediment from the bed of the watercourse between the A142 bridge and Welches Dam.

The water was frozen and the river bank on which the crane was positioned was frosty and wet.

Timber tracking mats were laid to provide better grip and stability for the work to be carried out, and to protect the grassy bank from damage

The court heard that at around 9:30am Wenn was in the process of repositioning one of the tracking mats.

He used the crane to move the mat from behind and swing it to position in front of him.

But as it rotated round and through the water the crane started to slowly slip towards it and then tipped into the watercourse.

Wenn was trapped in the cab of the crane. Emergency services were called and tried to free him, but despite their best efforts both he and the machine continued to sink.

He drowned as freezing water filled the cab and was pronounced dead at 8:19pm.

An HSE investigation found that the crane Wenn was operating had been fitted with a 19 metre boom that exceeded the manufacturer specifications.

These stated that the maximum length of boom the crane should be fitted with was 16 metres when used as a dragline.

HSE also established that the Environment Agency had made an inadequate assessment of the technical requirements at the Mepal site, and of the impact of the cold weather.

The system of work for lifting and positioning the tracking mats was unsafe, and there was a lack of planning and competent site supervision.

The court was told that although Wenn was trained as a dragline operator, he had no prior experience of using a crawler crane for lifting operations.

When he attempted to move the mats, he dragged them through the water rather than lifting them clear.

His death followed a similar incident in Norfolk in 2008 involving a smaller tracked machine operated by Environment Agency employees.

HSE identified that it had failed to act on the findings of its own internal investigation into this incident.

The Environment Agency was fined £200,000 with costs of £28,548 after admitting safety breaches.

After the hearing, HSE inspector Stephen Faulkner said: “Simon Wenn’s tragic death could have been prevented had more thought and rigour been given to planning the dredging work, in order to minimise the risk arising from the use of the dragline to maintain this watercourse.

“The Environment Agency failed to heed warnings and learn lessons from a previous non-fatal, incident where there were similar failures to manage risk.”

The crane was rigged as a dragline

 

Latest plant news

Vp buys Brandon Hire for £41.6m

Major deal in the tool and equipment rental sector
1 week ago

CITB buys plant simulators to fill operator skills gap

Sixteen plant simulators will help to train next generation of operators
3 months ago

Shake-up of plant training system divides industry

Changes by CITB come under fire from contractors and training specialists
4 months ago

Plant operators get in-cab entertainment

Latest Hyundai loader boasts car-style "infotainment" system
5 months ago

JCB launches Hi-Viz dumper

Machinery giant launches new model in a bid to prevent site accidents
5 months ago

VP bullish about construction prospects after record results

Equipment rental specialist enjoys growth across all sectors
5 months ago

Countdown to largest UK plant show

More than 15,000 people set to visit Leicestershire Plantworx show in early-June
6 months ago

Worker killed by reversing telescopic handler

Tragedy on disorganised site with no segregation between vehicles and workers
6 months ago

Speedy bounces back into the black

Turnaround plan lifts plant hirer into £14m profit after £58m loss in 2016
6 months ago

Contractors keen on new site huts from Mobile Mini

Site accommodation specialist invests £1m in new fleet of Groundhog units
7 months ago

Vp swoops on specialist M&E hirer

Jackson Mechanical Services M&E tool hire arm sold for £3.6m
7 months ago

HSS racks-up £17.4m loss as closures continue

Equipment hire specialist optimistic as branch and distribution network streamlined
8 months ago

Banner Plant expands into Leicestershire

Banner Plant swoops on independent rival Premier to strengthen East Midlands offer
8 months ago

Fairfax buys 80 Hitachi 8t diggers

Selby hirer places biggest order in company's history
8 months ago

Company fined £700,000 for MEWP death fall

Washing machine giant fined after 66-year-old contractor dies during factory repair work
8 months ago

A-Plant snaps up Kier’s hoist business

Kier sheds last of plant and equipment interests
9 months ago

Mick George on the hunt for franchised drivers

Contractor looking for drivers to take on franchises at construction haulage arm
10 months ago

Loxam ups bid for Lavendon to £459m

Belgian and French giants slug it out for control of Leicester-based powered access specialist
10 months ago

Plant hirer Hewden crashed owing £240m

Unsecured creditors told there is little prospect of being paid
10 months ago

Plant hire boss jailed after platform collapse kills worker

Court hears how mobile platform boom should have been replaced rather than repaired
10 months ago

127 Hewden cranes on the block

Administrator calls in auctioneers after failure to find a buyer
11 months ago

JCB workforce agrees 2.2% pay rise for 2017

3,200 strong workforce accepts three-year pay deal
11 months ago

Bidding war hots up for control of Lavendon

European giants battle it out for control of UK powered access specialist
11 months ago

Ashbrook Plant Hire saves Hewden workers jobs

Rival hirers make move on collapsed Hewden's depots
11 months ago

Terex sells Coventry dumper factory

French maker Mecalac swoops on backhoe, dumper and roller plant
11 months ago

Ladder fall costs Volvo £900,000

Worker at plant division left in coma
12 months ago

Rental specialist Vp bullish about construction prospects

Equipment hirer posts strong results and predicts even better next time
12 months ago

Rival bidder enters fray for Lavendon

Lomax reveals possible cash offer to trump TVH bid for Lavendon
12 months ago

Laing O’Rourke sells mobile crane fleet

Ainscough to buy Select Plant mobile cranes
12 months ago

HSS warns on profit after efficiency plan delays

Tool hirer says branch streamlining plan taking longer to implement than expected
12 months ago

Contractor services