Roofer left paralysed in Wates site fall

Grant Prior 5 years ago
Share

Wates and its roofing subcontractor have been fined after a worker was left paralysed from the waist down when he fell four metres through a hole in a roof at a Swindon building site.

Giovanni Mastrodomenico, 56, from Swindon, fell through a waterproof membrane into the unguarded hole while working at the Marlborough Park development in the town on 31 August 2011.

His employer Tego Roofing Ltd, of Oxford, and principal contractor Wates Construction have been prosecuted following the incident.

Swindon Magistrates’ Court heard that Mastrodomenico was carrying out metalwork prior to the installation of a vent on the roof of the new apartment block. The hole he plunged through was where the vent was to be placed.

He fell four metres onto a concrete floor below, causing permanent injuries that have left him unable to walk and confined to a wheelchair.

An HSE investigation found that scaffolding under the hole inside the building had been removed because it was obstructing an emergency escape route, and that scaffolding planks had subsequently been placed over the hole instead.

But these planks were in turn removed to allow workmen to lay a waterproof membrane over the hole in preparation for the vent to be installed leaving nothing in place to prevent Mastrodomenico’s fall.

The court was told that the risk assessment and method statement for the work was unsuitable and insufficient because it failed to refer to the installation process for the vent.

There was confusion about who the site supervisor was when the incident happened and, although the site manager had seen the roofers working near the hole, he did not stop the work or ensure the scaffolding boards were replaced.

HSE established that Tego Roofing failed to provide adequate supervision or instruction to its employees while working on the roof.

Wates failed to plan, manage and monitor the work and did not ensure there was a risk assessment in place.

Tego Roofing Ltd, of Chalgrove, Oxford, was fined £10,000 and ordered to pay £9,460 in costs after pleading guilty to breaching CDM regulations.

Wates Construction of Leatherhead, Surrey, was fined £18,000 with costs of £11,127 after also pleading guilty to a separate breach of the same regulations.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE Inspector Keiron Jones, said: “Mr Mastrodomenico’s life and that of his family have been completely changed by the management failings on the site.

“Apart from the pain and suffering he has gone through, his employment opportunities are now restricted and he will never be able to walk again.

“Construction companies and their contractors must have proper plans in place to allow their employees to complete the job safely.

“As principal contractor, Wates failed to plan, manage and monitor the work, and ensure there was a risk assessment in place.

“Tego also failed in their duty to provide a risk assessment, ensure there was adequate supervision on-site and make sure there was a safe system of work for the installation of the vent.”

 

Latest news

Carillion liquidator pledges 7-day redundancy service

Government sets up specialist team to process staff
2 days ago

Carillion Aberdeen bypass project team transferred

57 of 63 staff taken on Balfour Beatty and Galliford Try
2 days ago

MPs demand more evidence from Carillion bosses

Directors face further scrutiny over late payment claims
2 days ago

Scaffold clip falls 20 metres hitting passer-by

Victim left with broken nose and damaged skull
2 days ago

Boost your online presence with the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
4 months ago

Contracts up for grabs in Birmingham building boom

Big names want to meet new suppliers: Register now
2 days ago

Nearly 80 housing projects win kick-start funding

£45m cash injection to support building up to 7,280 homes on council-owned land.
2 days ago

Are you the best in construction? – Enter the Enquirer awards now

Enquirer awards are voted for by your staff and supply chain
2 days ago

Robertson wins £19m Belper care home

Work to start in April on Derbyshire care home and library project
3 days ago

London’s biggest Boxpark approved

Capital’s third shopping container mall in Wembley gets green light
2 days ago

Axed Carillion staff slam PwC over redundo claims delay

Worried ex-staff face losing their homes
3 days ago

Tribunal victory “blows a hole” in agency payroll model

Unite vows to step up campaign against bogus self-employment
3 days ago

Procure North West issues £2bn build framework bid alert

Bidding to start next month on Liverpool and Manchester building framework
3 days ago

Cladding firms risk fitting poor ACM in post-Grenfell confusion

UK's biggest cladding distributor pulls all systems failing to reach A2 standard
3 days ago
Vivalda Group plc

Briggs and Forrester bullish about building services market

Specialist set to hit £225m turnover after an award winning year
3 days ago

Canadian firm to buy Carillion UK FM contracts

Serco and BGIS deals to save 4,000 support services staff
3 days ago

Wates residential boss leaves after reshuffle

Joanne Jamieson leaves business and is replaced by Richard Shroll
4 days ago

Groundworker loses leg after being hit by tipper truck

Civils firm MV Kelly fined £500,000 after accident on housing site
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall transport chief joins BAM

Bill Gifford takes on new role as Highways Strategic Director at BAM Nuttall
6 days ago

Galliford Try to raise £150m to cover Aberdeen Bypass

Fund raising for £150m cash commitment to Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route
4 days ago

Bid race for £190m Manchester town hall revamp

Management contractor to be appointed by December for Grade I listed building overhaul
4 days ago

Serco cuts £20m from Carillion health FM deal

Buyer strikes revised deal with liquidator
4 days ago

Network Rail targets 10% savings in £47bn CP6 plan

Decisions on major enhancement projects deferred to focus on delayed projects
5 days ago

Plantworx moves to Peterborough for 2019 show

Indoor and outdoor facilities of East of England Arena will stop show being blighted by bad weather
4 days ago

BAM director joins McLaren to lead public sector push

Keith Rayner joins as contractor looks to win more framework places
5 days ago

Vinci replaces Carillion on £74m Manchester student halls

Fallowfield student village to restart but suffers four-month delay
5 days ago

Construction show calls time on scantily clad stand models

UK Construction Week organisers issue new diversity guidance after showgirls storm
5 days ago

Big four accountants accused of feasting on Carillion

Accountants paid £72m in fees over a decade for Carillion related work
5 days ago

London Mayor approves 21-storey Pocket Living tower

Croydon set for second off-site built residential tower block
5 days ago

McAlpine wants suppliers for £460m Woking scheme

Firms from across south east invited to open day: Register now
5 days ago

Contractor services