Roofer left paralysed in Wates site fall

Grant Prior 6 years ago
Share

Wates and its roofing subcontractor have been fined after a worker was left paralysed from the waist down when he fell four metres through a hole in a roof at a Swindon building site.

Giovanni Mastrodomenico, 56, from Swindon, fell through a waterproof membrane into the unguarded hole while working at the Marlborough Park development in the town on 31 August 2011.

His employer Tego Roofing Ltd, of Oxford, and principal contractor Wates Construction have been prosecuted following the incident.

Swindon Magistrates’ Court heard that Mastrodomenico was carrying out metalwork prior to the installation of a vent on the roof of the new apartment block. The hole he plunged through was where the vent was to be placed.

He fell four metres onto a concrete floor below, causing permanent injuries that have left him unable to walk and confined to a wheelchair.

An HSE investigation found that scaffolding under the hole inside the building had been removed because it was obstructing an emergency escape route, and that scaffolding planks had subsequently been placed over the hole instead.

But these planks were in turn removed to allow workmen to lay a waterproof membrane over the hole in preparation for the vent to be installed leaving nothing in place to prevent Mastrodomenico’s fall.

The court was told that the risk assessment and method statement for the work was unsuitable and insufficient because it failed to refer to the installation process for the vent.

There was confusion about who the site supervisor was when the incident happened and, although the site manager had seen the roofers working near the hole, he did not stop the work or ensure the scaffolding boards were replaced.

HSE established that Tego Roofing failed to provide adequate supervision or instruction to its employees while working on the roof.

Wates failed to plan, manage and monitor the work and did not ensure there was a risk assessment in place.

Tego Roofing Ltd, of Chalgrove, Oxford, was fined £10,000 and ordered to pay £9,460 in costs after pleading guilty to breaching CDM regulations.

Wates Construction of Leatherhead, Surrey, was fined £18,000 with costs of £11,127 after also pleading guilty to a separate breach of the same regulations.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE Inspector Keiron Jones, said: “Mr Mastrodomenico’s life and that of his family have been completely changed by the management failings on the site.

“Apart from the pain and suffering he has gone through, his employment opportunities are now restricted and he will never be able to walk again.

“Construction companies and their contractors must have proper plans in place to allow their employees to complete the job safely.

“As principal contractor, Wates failed to plan, manage and monitor the work, and ensure there was a risk assessment in place.

“Tego also failed in their duty to provide a risk assessment, ensure there was adequate supervision on-site and make sure there was a safe system of work for the installation of the vent.”

 

Latest news

Shaylor owners sold majority stake months before collapse

Deal to set up Employee Ownership Trust funded by bank loan
3 hours ago

Crossrail station boss becomes Balfour aviation chief

Airport expert Steve O'Sullivan continues 39-year rise through ranks at Balfour
6 mins ago

Plans submitted for £2bn Midlands rail upgrade

Next PM urged to back major expansion of Moor Street station, faster services to Nottingham, Leicester, Hereford and Worcester
3 hours ago

Trio to share £1.4bn London highways upkeep

Framework extended from eight to 12 years to allow firms to invest in staff for efficiency gains
3 hours ago

Inland Homes gets green light to start £620m “urban village”

Major mixed-use scheme to be built at Cheshunt in Hertfordshire
3 hours ago

Rydon clinches £30m Bath Uni car R&D facility

Institute for Advanced Automotive Propulsion Systems will research next generation engines
10 hours ago

Size of construction disputes drops by half

Contractors shifting from adjudication towards negotiation to resolve rows
10 hours ago

Funding for £350m Wimbledon stadium and housing scheme

£350m Galliard Homes scheme will include 600 homes and new stadium
1 day ago

HS2 managing director to step down

HS2 starts search for successor to Jim Crawford
19 hours ago

Construction slavery victims exploited on sites across London

28 years in jail for crime gang who kept £1.2m in wages owed to workers
1 day ago

Costain scoops United Utilities’ first asset upkeep deal

Deal to maintain water and waste water treatment assets worth £175m over five years
1 day ago

Sureserve sets aside cash after Lakehouse sale

Provisions of £5.4m contained in latest results
1 day ago

Green light for Scotland’s largest regeneration site

Masterplan for Ravenscraig former steelworks redevelopment approved
1 day ago

Fit-out firm BW hires ISG director for third MD role

Max Steward has taken up third MD role in leadership rejig
1 day ago

Winners named for £700m South Wales Metro ECI deals

Balfour Beatty, Alun Griffiths and Siemens Mobility secure first work packages
2 days ago

Utility contractor Fastflow merges with United Living

Merger of utility group and housing maintenance firm creates £400m revenue business
2 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

Site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
1 year ago

‘Brexodus’ sees site engineer pay rates soar 19%

Salaries surging for site professionals as shortages bite
2 days ago

Welsh contractor Jistcourt goes into administration

Firm goes under just weeks after opening new Bristol office and major contract win
2 days ago

DfE starts bid race for £3bn offsite schools framework

Department for Education will deliver 30 projects a year using MMC
2 days ago

Design unveiled for Commonwealth Games stadium

Birmingham City Council reveals first images of new-look Alexander Stadium
2 days ago

Mayor backs big West London hotel scheme

New landmark Kensington building will deliver 750-bed hotel, 340 serviced flats and 62 affordable homes
2 days ago

Thames tilting bridge shelved over soaring cost

TfL warns bridge linking Canary Wharf to Rotherhithe could have cost £600m
5 days ago

Subcontractors wanted across south east projects

Big names offering work at Newmarket Meet the Buyer event: Register now
2 days ago

Building safety specialist snapped-up for £265m

Banking giant Macquarie Group swoops on Premier Technical Services Group
5 days ago

Balfour Beatty wins £50m Kent substation build

Work to start shortly on high-voltage substation at Littlebrook Power Station
5 days ago

Detailed plans in for £300m Chester shopping scheme

Vinci expected to get go-ahead for enabling works in October
5 days ago

Masterplan for largest area of Ebbsfleet garden city approved

Design codes set out for 4,600-home double village plan
5 days ago

Industry steps-in to save stranded Shaylor trainees

Former rivals pledge to pay university fees for undergrads left with tuition bills by Shaylor
6 days ago

Former Mitie boss joins Thames Tideway board

Baroness Ruby McGregor-Smith joins Super Sewer board as non-exec director
5 days ago

Contractor services