Human rights challenge to self employment crackdown

Grant Prior 6 years ago
Share

Recruitment specialists are warning that the recent Government crackdown on false self employment could be a breach of the Human Rights Act.

hmrc-logo-01

Trade body APSCo will write to Whitehall this week warning that legislation introduced last month could leave the Government open to a legal challenge.

The recruitment body fears the changes expose its members to great a risk in the complicated world of construction payroll arrangements.

Samantha Hurley, Head of External Affairs and Compliance at APSCo, said: “We are of course in favour of measures to curb tax avoidance and fully support the efforts of HMRC in its endeavours, but what we cannot support is burdening the recruitment sector with a tax liability over which it has no control without giving some form of statutory defence in the event of the unscrupulous behaviour of intermediaries further down the supply chain.”

“We are certainly not arguing for the removal of the legislation altogether – but what we are asking for is a defence for recruitment firms in the event that they have undertaken reasonable due diligence – a defence which already exists in the Agency Workers Regulations.”

“The legislation does include a defence for recruitment firms against the provision of fraudulent documents by other parties in the supply chain, but we believe that this is a red herring as the reality of this situation is that the onus would be on the intermediary to prove not only that fraud had taken place – but also that there was an intent to defraud.

“We will be writing to The Treasury outlining not only the concerns summarised above but also the fact that not providing for a statutory defence poses a major legal risk for the Government itself – a risk which is entirely unnecessary.

“As we are not asking for a removal of the legislation itself, we very much hope that the Government will see reason and provide the amendment needed to make the legislation reasonable, proportionate and above all legally robust.”

Latest news

Cladding probe after Bolton student block blaze

Latest fire raises more questions over cladding
6 hours ago

London office starts slump by nearly half

Contractors' use of non-UK labour in Capital falls from a third to a quarter of workforce
5 hours ago

Kier suffers shareholder revolt over chief’s pay

Almost 54% of shareholders vote against board pay
2 days ago

Interserve restructure paves way for possible break-up

Chief executive Debbie White to step down by end of December
3 days ago

Kier Chief Operating Officer leaves as cost cuts continue

Claudio Veritiero joins 1,200 staff set to go by next June
3 days ago

Eurovia trials robo-cars to ferry tools to highways sites

Driverless delivery vehicles will also survey road conditions as they go
3 days ago

PDR Construction starts Arco HQ in Hull

£16m project marks major milestone in £80m waterfront regeneration
3 days ago

Crossrail traffic marshall threatens passer-by and kids

Bond Street station subcontractor sacked after confrontation with public
3 days ago

Multiplex Europe chief Ashley Muldoon exits

Muldoon steps down after 22 years in top management shake-up
4 days ago

New-build housing completions top 200,000

Completions rise to the highest level since the 1980’s
4 days ago

Interserve chalks up 15th school project this year

Specialist needs school to be built in Oldham
4 days ago

Styles & Wood chiefs leave the business

CEO Tony Lenehan and finance boss Phil Lanigan depart
4 days ago

Commonwealth Games aquatic centre cost soars by 20%

Wates to start building work in January after £73m budget sign-off next week
4 days ago

New safety template in fight to prevent falls on site

New industry-standard guide launched: Download free now
4 days ago

Plan in for £365m Salford Cotton Quay scheme

Cotton Quays will include 37 and 48-storey buildings
3 days ago

Carillion liquidator to clawback £510m

Financial watchdog to consider whether to take action over conduct of directors in March
5 days ago

Graham wins £26m Poynton relief road

Main works on 3km Cheshire road to start next May
4 days ago

Interserve hires new construction commercial director

Ben Edwards takes up new role after seven years in Middle East
5 days ago

Developer fined £600,000 for white finger outbreak

Groundworkers suffer Hand Arm Vibration Syndrome on Places for People sites
4 days ago

British Land makes £200m profit on luxury Mayfair flats

Developer hails "highly successful" Clarges scheme
5 days ago

Network Rail plans Dragons’ Den to drive SME innovation

Rail infrastructure on track to deliver a third of spending via SMEs by 2022
5 days ago

Balfour tops October contracts league after road win

Morgan Sindall unseats Kier with the highest value of orders over last 12 months
5 days ago

Plans go in for 20-storey Bolton tower

Seddon lined-up as main contractor for major mixed-use scheme
5 days ago

Galliard to start luxury apartments above Crossrail station

Go-ahead for £140m residential scheme above delayed station
6 days ago

Co-op signs new maintenance deal for all stores

Trio of winners for five-year deal covering 3,500 food stores and funeral homes
6 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

Site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
2 years ago

Groundworker engulfed in flames after cable strike

Court hears how contractor failed to identify cables on car park site
5 days ago

More than 200 hotels planned in London

Hotel building boom fuelled by Brexit-related fall in sterling
6 days ago

Oakervee review backs full HS2 project

Leaked report floats idea of re-procuring contracts for best value
6 days ago

Marcus Worthington went down owing £9m to subbies

Supply chain suffers again in latest administration fall-out
6 days ago

Contractor services