Site manager wins payout over 70-hour weeks

Grant Prior 5 months ago
Share

A site manager at Ogilvie Construction has won a tribunal payout after being forced to work 70-hour weeks.

David Brown raised concerns about his working hours with bosses on several occasions but nothing was done to reduce his time on site.

The firm also claimed to have demoted Brown, of Tullibody, Clackmannanshire, to the position of general foreman in a bid to allay his concerns, but his workload was never reduced despite his pay being cut.

The manager, who had 28 years’ service with the firm, eventually resigned in October 2014 due to his long working hours before taking his case to an employment tribunal claiming constructive dismissal.

Employment judge Paul Cape found in his favour, saying the time he spent at work was “excessive” and awarded him a total of £14,031.

In a written judgment seen by the Herald Scotland , Judge Cape stated: “I conclude that Ogilvie Construction imposed burdens of work on Mr Brown that required that he work excessive hours week in, week out, over an extended period despite his protestations and that so excessive were those burdens that they amounted to a fundamental breach of contract.

“Further that breach was aggravated by the failure to reply in writing to Mr Brown’s emails raising the issue, and by the respondent purporting to restore the claimant to the position and remuneration package of a general foreman whilst doing nothing to match the claimant’s workload to that which could reasonably be required of a general foreman.”

The tribunal heard that between June and October 2014, Brown did no work less than 53 hours a week and worked more than 70 hours in seven of those weeks

During that time, the worker wrote to bosses raising concerns about his hours and asking for a site foreman to be put in place to help with his workload, but he received no reply.

A site foreman was eventually appointed at the site, but Brown continued to have to work excessive hours.

Judge Cape said Ogilvie could not escape the fact that they were well aware of Brown’s hours as his time sheets were seen by his line manager.

He added that, while Brown’s contract required him to work extra hours in order to complete building projects, this “must be qualified by the word ‘reasonably'”.

Ogilvie Construction did not respond to The Herald’s request for a comment.

Latest news

Murphy finance chief becomes new Barhale CEO

Matthew Behan to lead contractor as new corporate structure established to broaden portfolio
3 hours ago

Willmott Dixon abandons sale of support services arm

Contractor decides to keep division after bidders wanted to break-up maintenance operation
6 hours ago

Currie & Brown trumps WSP bid for Sweett Group

WSP raises prospect of a bid war as it tells Sweett shareholders to sit tight
8 hours ago

Suppliers hit as HOC goes into administration

Redundancies at north London firm as subcontractors left in dark
10 hours ago

Student digs developer shrugs off Brexit worries

Empiric confident EU vote will have limited impact on expanding sector
11 hours ago

Brexit leaves Heathrow third runway in the air

Fears grow about the future of major infrastructure projects
11 hours ago

Bid costs dent Hochtief UK profits

Operating margin drops to 0.7% as profit falls 45% to below £1m
10 hours ago

Breakaway trade body formed by rebar producers

Independent rebar producers and suppliers split with BAR
10 hours ago

Sinkhole closes busy stretch of A1

Contractors pumping huge hole with concrete in bid to reopen route
20 hours ago

Lendlease to start £275m Hammersmith scheme

Construction to start next month on major office project
3 days ago

Contractors call for calm as Brexit victory spooks markets

Construction fears over costs, skills and investment as house builder shares crash
3 days ago

Shepherd Group suffers £74m hit from sold building arm

Strong profits at remaining Portakabin business help to cut group loss to £28m
3 days ago

Bidding set to start on £2bn East London cultural quarter

London Legacy Development Corporation set to procure shell and core work
3 days ago

Building worker critical after being crushed by JCB

Digger at Hebburn housing site believed to have reversed into worker
3 days ago

Plant test cheats website dodges closure threat

CITB chiefs battling to close down site undermining tests for machinery drivers
4 days ago

Green light for £18m Midland Metro extension

Preparatory utility diversion works to start immediately
4 days ago

Hill wins approval for £100m east London housing scheme

Work to start on Walthamstow triple towers this autumn
4 days ago

Construction workers win inflation busting pay rise

Deal agreed but unions warn pay agreement is "no longer fit for purpose"
4 days ago

Cameron resigns as exit vote sends markets crashing

New Prime Minister to be elected by October
3 days ago

Costain to use more drones to make sites safer

Unmanned aerial vehicles can take on hazardous tasks
4 days ago

Bowmer & Kirkland profit jumps by almost half

Derbyshire private builder lifts profit to nearly £40m
4 days ago

Plans for £250m Liverpool resi towers trio

Liverpool developer Elliot plans cluster of 34-storey towers
4 days ago

Specialist wins low road tender court hearing

Judge rules against public client who rejected "abnormally low" bid from FP McCann and Balfour Beatty
5 days ago

Yorkshire plumbing contractor sinks

More than 100 jobs cut after firm fails to reach agreement with HMRC over tax arrears
5 days ago

Bid race starts for £20m Luton science block

University of Bedfordshire will appoint a contractor in September
5 days ago

Betting Spy: Roy’s luck set to run out against France

Quarter Finals could be our Waterloo while Croatia are an attractive price to see off Portugal
4 days ago

Wates wants to meet local suppliers

Meet the Buyer event for local firms to be held on the WIrral: Register now
5 days ago

“Pop up” rail depot sends aggies to North West sites

Temporary plant saves thousands of HGV journeys across region
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall reopens Kent precast plant

Plant remobilises after big order for Tube Northern Line Extension tunnel extension rings
5 days ago

Wolverhampton Uni plans to invite bids for £20m project

Construction of School of Architecture and Built Environment to start in March
5 days ago