Culvert collapses on workers

Grant Prior 12 months ago
Share

Two building firms have been fined after a man was seriously injured when a structure that allows water to flow under roads collapsed on him.

Maidstone Crown Court heard that Kent County Council appointed Enterprise to replace a damaged brick culvert under Tudely Lane Tonbridge.

Enterprise in turn appointed Topbond to do the majority of the work.

A culvert is an embedded structure, usually surround by soil and can be made from steel, brick or reinforced concrete or other material and is used to transport water underground from one side of a road or railway to another.

The HSE prosecuting told the court that on 27 January 2012 water was being pumped out of the work area when three workers including 63-year-old Michael Skitt of Kingsnorth, Ashford, entered the area between two culverts in order to clear a channel for the remaining water to flow toward the pump head.

They had begun to clear loose material, but had not started digging.

Shortly after they entered the area, the old brick culvert collapsed. One man jumped clear, another was hit but managed to release himself, but Skitt was trapped and injured.

Skitt suffered multiple injuries including shoulder blade breaks, an open shin break and a dislocated knee.

Ongoing issues with his foot may see him need further operations. Skitt spent 26 days in hospital and has now had to give up full time work and walks with a stick.

HSE said the stability of the structure was not assessed adequately, nor sufficient planning undertaken to ensure adequate control measures were in place.

Its investigation found that originally the old culvert was to be totally demolished early in the work, when this was changed the implications of uncovering half of the damaged culvert and therefore loading it unevenly and undermining it were not managed.

Although culvert repair/replacement is a relatively unusual construction job, the collapse of excavations and structures is common and the court heard the defendants in the case were made aware of the potential of collapse by the original designers/engineers several times.

The culvert could have been demolished early in the work, failing this, there are a number of commonly used ways to support structures during construction work.

Enterprise (AOL) Ltd of Halley Road, Oxford admitted safety breaches and were fined a total of £90,000 and ordered to pay an additional £22,876 costs.

Topbond PLC, of Sittingbourne, Kent also admitted safety breaches and were also ordered to pay £22,876.60 costs and were fined £70,000.

After the case, HSE inspector Nicola Wellard said: “This is a sad case that has changed at least one man’s life for ever. The culvert was being replaced because it had been damaged previously.

“Just this one piece of information should have been enough to ensure both contractors assessed the stability of the culvert throughout the work and took appropriate measures to ensure people were protected from the risk of collapse.

“These risks are well known and the fact that the two other men escaped without serious injury was just pure luck, this could easily have been a multiple fatality.”

Latest news

B&K wins Altrincham hospital rebuild

Work to start on South Trafford Health & Wellbeing Centre in March
1 min ago

Opinion: Time to call off the QS cash vampires

Industry can do without new breed of aggressive quantity surveyors
3 hours ago

Prime Minister unveils £556m Northern Powerhouse boost

Funding boost for Goole intermodal terminal and Blackpool Winter Gardens extension
3 hours ago

22 Bishopsgate to get fastest lifts in Europe

Otis wins contracts for 30km per hour lifts
2 hours ago

Historic builder wins £15m Brighton Royal Pavilion revamp

First phase of the restoration programme involves the Corn Exchange building
2 hours ago

Wates gets green light for £30m Cumbria campus

Works set to start next month on Whitehaven school complex
3 hours ago

JS Wright lands record M&E package

Specialist to start work on £5m north London deal in April
3 hours ago

Scaffolding giant Palmers back under British ownership

New owner Colin Butt seals post-Brexit deal with German firm Xervon
3 days ago

Subbies under attack from new breed of aggressive QS

Specialists at war with main contractor quantity surveyors
3 days ago

Asbestos analyst fakes air testing certificates

Court hears how safety checks were not carried out properly on Manchester site
3 days ago

Ealing set for first major office scheme in a decade

Demolition work to start in April paving way for £50m building project
3 days ago

Subcontract rating wins Buckingham £37m waterpark

Coventry City Council scores package contractors in picking winning main contract bid
4 days ago

Crossrail in chaos as M&E work ripped out

100 electricians let go at Paddington as installation work grinds to a halt
4 days ago

Barratt finance boss exits after 15 months

Neil Cooper is leaving by mutual consent with immediate effect
3 days ago

Trade body questions future of CITB

Skills body in the firing line as it gears-up for crucial levy vote
4 days ago

Skills cards for fringe trades to be phased out

230,000 Construction Related Occupation cards to become obsolete
4 days ago

Mott MacDonald names new managing director

Mike Haigh rises from graduate to group MD in 35 years at Motts
3 days ago

Betting Spy: Rampant Spurs a big price at Man City

A Tottenham and Everton double pays a healthy looking 7/1
4 days ago

Pod specialist makes appeal to creditors

Modular contractor Aartoft could be heading for CVA
4 days ago

Plans lodged for 19-storey Coventry student block

Developer Crosslane submits 583-bed student accommodation scheme
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins Liverpool Knowledge Quarter work

Liverpool City Council awards two contracts worth £47m on Paddington Village scheme
5 days ago

Van Elle profit dips after Stock Market listing

Fall in specialist piling business profits hits first half performance
4 days ago

Skanska tightens grip on south west highways

Latest £175m Somerset deal follows £245m Devon highways term maintenance agreement
4 days ago

Watkin Jones targets PRS as profits surge

Strong student accommodation pipeline builds platform for growth
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall crowned 2016 contracts champion

Wates, Willmott Dixon and Mace join top 10 firms winning most work last year
5 days ago

Ex-Balfour finance chief to join Mitie after another profit warning

Two-day board meeting at Mitie to review strategy
5 days ago

Lendlease set for landmark £350m Google HQ job

Decision taken on vast King's Cross building contract last Thursday
6 days ago

U+I plans £300m of office refurb work

Developer links up with American firm to target sites in London, Manchester and Dublin
5 days ago

Loxam ups bid for Lavendon to £459m

Belgian and French giants slug it out for control of Leicester-based powered access specialist
5 days ago

Plans in for £40m Aberdeen FC stadium

Dons press ahead with 20,000-seat stadium and football academy plan
5 days ago

Contractor services