Culvert collapses on workers

Grant Prior 1 year ago
Share

Two building firms have been fined after a man was seriously injured when a structure that allows water to flow under roads collapsed on him.

Maidstone Crown Court heard that Kent County Council appointed Enterprise to replace a damaged brick culvert under Tudely Lane Tonbridge.

Enterprise in turn appointed Topbond to do the majority of the work.

A culvert is an embedded structure, usually surround by soil and can be made from steel, brick or reinforced concrete or other material and is used to transport water underground from one side of a road or railway to another.

The HSE prosecuting told the court that on 27 January 2012 water was being pumped out of the work area when three workers including 63-year-old Michael Skitt of Kingsnorth, Ashford, entered the area between two culverts in order to clear a channel for the remaining water to flow toward the pump head.

They had begun to clear loose material, but had not started digging.

Shortly after they entered the area, the old brick culvert collapsed. One man jumped clear, another was hit but managed to release himself, but Skitt was trapped and injured.

Skitt suffered multiple injuries including shoulder blade breaks, an open shin break and a dislocated knee.

Ongoing issues with his foot may see him need further operations. Skitt spent 26 days in hospital and has now had to give up full time work and walks with a stick.

HSE said the stability of the structure was not assessed adequately, nor sufficient planning undertaken to ensure adequate control measures were in place.

Its investigation found that originally the old culvert was to be totally demolished early in the work, when this was changed the implications of uncovering half of the damaged culvert and therefore loading it unevenly and undermining it were not managed.

Although culvert repair/replacement is a relatively unusual construction job, the collapse of excavations and structures is common and the court heard the defendants in the case were made aware of the potential of collapse by the original designers/engineers several times.

The culvert could have been demolished early in the work, failing this, there are a number of commonly used ways to support structures during construction work.

Enterprise (AOL) Ltd of Halley Road, Oxford admitted safety breaches and were fined a total of £90,000 and ordered to pay an additional £22,876 costs.

Topbond PLC, of Sittingbourne, Kent also admitted safety breaches and were also ordered to pay £22,876.60 costs and were fined £70,000.

After the case, HSE inspector Nicola Wellard said: “This is a sad case that has changed at least one man’s life for ever. The culvert was being replaced because it had been damaged previously.

“Just this one piece of information should have been enough to ensure both contractors assessed the stability of the culvert throughout the work and took appropriate measures to ensure people were protected from the risk of collapse.

“These risks are well known and the fact that the two other men escaped without serious injury was just pure luck, this could easily have been a multiple fatality.”

Latest news

Alandale Rail bosses jailed for Thameslink corruption

Four men jailed and Alandale Rail fined £25,000 over fraud and bribes at Farringdon station project
14 hours ago

Demolition firms lead way with virtual smart cards

Skills cards can now be stored on smartphones
6 hours ago

Legal row hits stalled £200m Liverpool Chinatown

Council and developer in war of words over flagship scheme
15 hours ago

Skanska confirms £142m Tin Pan Alley contract

Skanska signs off contract for London Giles Circus mixed-use development
15 hours ago

Deal to start £65m Sussex shopping centre

Pre-sale and lease deals trigger Burgess Hill town centre revamp
14 hours ago

Jacobs in merger talks with CH2M

Merger would create global engineering giant to rival AECOM
15 hours ago

Race on for £240m Leicester construction framework

Four-year framework to deliver schools and city centre redevelopment plan
16 hours ago

Final week to vote for best companies in construction

Laing O'Rourke and Cemex are latest sponsors to support the Enquirer awards
15 hours ago

Plans in for £400m Kent housing scheme

Medway's 1,400-home Rochester Riverside plan submitted
3 days ago

Hotel contract row forces Primus into CVA

Contractor set up by former Multiplex boss Martin Tidd faces cash flow crisis
4 days ago

Manchester’s tallest building set for green light

Allied London's most ambitious scheme so far set for approval
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall hunts top talent at virtual jobs fair

Construction & Infrastructure division takes careers event online to boost diversity
4 days ago

Landmark VAT ruling on student rooms projects

Tax tribunal overturns HMRC’s VAT policy on student accommodation
4 days ago

Grenfell cladding fire test verdict due next week

Government slashes estimate of residential blocks at risk from 600 to 208
4 days ago

£100m East Riding prison gets green light

Category C jail to be built next to HMP Full Sutton, near York
4 days ago

GSK scraps £350m Cumbria pharma plan

Pharma giant will invest extra £140m existing facility expansion
4 days ago

Specialists land first trade packages at huge Berkeley site

Main construction starts on 88-acre Southall Waterside site
4 days ago

Electrification plans scrapped on three major rail routes

Contracts worth millions axed as Government switches focus to new train technology
4 days ago

Project delays dent Clugston results

Contractor confident about future prospects following a "challenging" year
4 days ago

UK drags Skanska Europe into £40m loss

Skanska chief aims to cut operational costs and tighten risk management
5 days ago

McLaren set to bag £45m Lakeside extension

Contractor beats off McAlpine, ISG and Sisk to take Essex retail deal
5 days ago

Demand grows for immediate revamp of building regs

Local council chief attacks BRE, contractors and manufacturers for not sharing previous fire test results
5 days ago

Canary Wharf Contractors pays £11,000 tax on £70m profit

Company offsets £13.9m Corporation Tax bill against losses at other group divisions
5 days ago

Mount Anvil plans 1,000 flats in London Royal Docks

Deal with London ExCel centre paves way to build block of apartments
5 days ago

Consultant RLB stages mass raid on Mace managers

Five senior figures jump ship to join rival
5 days ago

Ministers reject client levy option in Farmer Review

Government backs most calls for reform but stops short of 0.5% charge on clients
5 days ago

Construction and fit out boost profits at Morgan Sindall

Contractor bucks recent sector trend by telling City to expect higher than predicted profits
6 days ago

Lendlease ordered to pay £14.8m for city tower falling glass

Cladding contractor to pick up bill after 15-foot glass pane fell from 17th floor
6 days ago

Civil engineers act to avert Grenfell-style disasters

ICE launches review of lessons from tower tragedy to avoid infrastructure failures
6 days ago

Man killed in derelict church collapse

Tragedy at Cardiff site where old church was being demolished
6 days ago

Contractor services