TfL slammed for £900m Tube upgrade cost overrun

Aaron Morby 2 years ago
Share

The London Assembly has blamed Transport for London for gross mismanagement of a signalling contract with Bombardier setting the Tube modernisation programme back five years.

An investigation into the failed signalling contract said a catalogue of management failings and errors left the District, Circle, Metropolitan, Hammersmith & City line upgrade nearly £900m over budget.

TfL ultimately paid £85m to cancel the contract with Bombardier Transport in 2013, two years after appointment. The report estimates that £67m of the settlement was wasted expenditure.

A culmination of nearly three years’ work scrutinising TfL’s sub-surface upgrade programme, the budget and performance committee report highlights how poor commercial expertise and a lack of IT procurement skills left TfL ill-prepared to appoint a suitable contractor, and vulnerable enough to be duped into a contract which Bombardier was never able to deliver.

The critical report highlights a culture where TfL management was only interested in presenting good news and was in denial about the progress and effectiveness of the programme, allowing it to continue for much longer than it should have.

The committee concluded that neither TfL nor Bombardier’s management teams were up to the task of managing the programme.

John Biggs AM, Chairman of the Budget and Performance Committee, said: “What is most remarkable about this affair is that no-one in TfL has been held to account, and the Mayor, who chairs its board, serenely and indifferently acts as if a £900m increase to the budget isn’t an issue.

“In government, heads – political or official – would roll after such financial mismanagement.  At TfL the key players have been promoted and nobody was to blame. It is a scandal.”

Transport for London’s Signal Failure report

KPMG audit – Lessons learned

TfL’s procurement process was not well thought out. Most significantly, its scoring system for evaluating bids was flawed. This meant that by significantly underbidding its competition on price, Bombardier was almost certain to be taken forward, regardless of how it scored in the technical areas of the evaluation.

Furthermore, TfL seemed to change its procurement process as it went along. If TfL had followed the process as outlined in the tender notice, then neither Bombardier nor the firm that finished second would have made the cut. By the time the field had been narrowed to two bidders, Bombardier was offering a lot more and for a lot less. If Bombardier could deliver what it was offering, then the case for appointing Bombardier was compelling.

Unfortunately, as KPMG noted “the capability of the supplier to deliver these benefits had not been adequately demonstrated or interrogated”. TfL has openly admitted it agreed a “bad contract”. The payment and penalty regimes within the contract were aligned to spend, rather than progress. This meant that in ending the contract, TfL was required to pay Bombardier a sum based on how much it had spent on the programme and not on the value of the work it had produced.

Latest news

Egis takes on M40 upkeep role from Carillion

French giant saves 95 jobs at crashed contractor
10 hours ago

Robertson bolsters north west arm with O’Rourke hires

Peter Grieve joins as north west operations director
13 hours ago

Science Museum seeks builder for vast storage building

Firm to be picked in October for 300,000 sq ft warehouse near Swindon
13 hours ago

Boost your online presence – join the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
2 weeks ago

Insurers slam fire test regime for building materials

"More realistic" lab tests demanded for cladding systems post Grenfell
18 hours ago

£80m twin hotel plan for Manchester Airport

Ibis and Holiday Inn kick-start new £180m Airport City hotel district
18 hours ago

Worker in plunge removing fall arrest bags from school site

Court hears edge protection was not up to industry safety standards
18 hours ago

Mace to start £120m Crossrail office scheme

PLP Architecture reveals latest images of Farringdon scheme
1 day ago

Green light for Liverpool Monarchs Quay scheme

Next phase of King's Dock mixed-use scheme approved
17 hours ago

Accident rates hit record lows for NASC scaffolders

Contractors representing 16,000 scaffolding operatives continue to reduce accidents
18 hours ago

First packages awarded on £28m Milton Keynes office job

Galliford Try gets going on eight-storey complex
1 day ago

Network Rail to build £46m Wigan train depot

Preparation works are getting underway for Ince-in-Makerfield depot
2 days ago

Specialist trade bodies petition No 10 for payment reform

Unprecedented coalition of trade associations urge Prime Minister to act
2 days ago

Construction boss and developer jailed for contracts bribery

Skansen Interiors MD and and DTZ project manager sentenced
2 days ago

Murphy wins Wessex Water Trym Tunnel relief sewer

North Bristol tunnel scheme to start next year
2 days ago

Graphene concrete game-changer for industry

Exeter Uni scientists produce concrete with twice the strength and four times water resistance
2 days ago

Kier lands lead role in £19.4m Glasgow theatre revamp

Work to start in September revamping the Citizens Theatre
2 days ago

Hill boasts record year as partnerships margin hits 3%

Partnership housing drives growth at Hill as pre-tax profit hits £47m
2 days ago

CMS wins £10m glazing deal on BAM’s Atlantic Square job

Major package win on £100m scheme
2 days ago

Contractors fold before £2m site death fines

Judge hands out huge fines but firms are no longer in business
3 days ago

Green light for £350m Leeds South Bank scheme

Preparation works can now start with construction planned to start next year
3 days ago

Mace go-ahead for London £150m Hanover Square scheme

Great Portland Estates JV secures pre-let to start building work on Mayfair scheme
3 days ago

Growth to rebound to 2.7% next year after flat 2018

30% fall in office activity over two years offset by surge in infrastructure
3 days ago

Crystal Palace to start £100m main stand next summer

Iconic main stand plan to go to London mayor to rubber stamp
3 days ago

Builder murdered by colleague on central London site

Murder hunt under way after construction worker bludgeoned by colleague on Hatton Garden roof
5 days ago

Barratt to pay for post Grenfell cladding upgrade on Croydon block

Government urges more house builders to pay for safety work rather than leaseholders
6 days ago

Carillion’s Midlands Pf2 hospital to cost extra £125m

Skanska confirmed for Midlands Metropolitan Hospital as trust waits for Government go-ahead
6 days ago

BAM Nuttall fined £900,000 after painter tears ligament

Court hears how worker plunged through station waiting room roof
6 days ago

Builders told to wait over a year for brick orders

Smaller builders warn of rising materials prices and lead times
6 days ago

14-storey Milton Keynes ‘sun hotel’ approved

Hotel La Tour gets nod for tallest building in Milton Keynes city centre
6 days ago

Contractor services