TfL slammed for £900m Tube upgrade cost overrun

Aaron Morby 10 months ago
Share

The London Assembly has blamed Transport for London for gross mismanagement of a signalling contract with Bombardier setting the Tube modernisation programme back five years.

Old London Underground signalling box

An investigation into the failed signalling contract said a catalogue of management failings and errors left the District, Circle, Metropolitan, Hammersmith & City line upgrade nearly £900m over budget.

TfL ultimately paid £85m to cancel the contract with Bombardier Transport in 2013, two years after appointment. The report estimates that £67m of the settlement was wasted expenditure.

A culmination of nearly three years’ work scrutinising TfL’s sub-surface upgrade programme, the budget and performance committee report highlights how poor commercial expertise and a lack of IT procurement skills left TfL ill-prepared to appoint a suitable contractor, and vulnerable enough to be duped into a contract which Bombardier was never able to deliver.

The critical report highlights a culture where TfL management was only interested in presenting good news and was in denial about the progress and effectiveness of the programme, allowing it to continue for much longer than it should have.

The committee concluded that neither TfL nor Bombardier’s management teams were up to the task of managing the programme.

John Biggs AM, Chairman of the Budget and Performance Committee, said: “What is most remarkable about this affair is that no-one in TfL has been held to account, and the Mayor, who chairs its board, serenely and indifferently acts as if a £900m increase to the budget isn’t an issue.

“In government, heads – political or official – would roll after such financial mismanagement.  At TfL the key players have been promoted and nobody was to blame. It is a scandal.”

Transport for London’s Signal Failure report

KPMG audit – Lessons learned

TfL’s procurement process was not well thought out. Most significantly, its scoring system for evaluating bids was flawed. This meant that by significantly underbidding its competition on price, Bombardier was almost certain to be taken forward, regardless of how it scored in the technical areas of the evaluation.

Furthermore, TfL seemed to change its procurement process as it went along. If TfL had followed the process as outlined in the tender notice, then neither Bombardier nor the firm that finished second would have made the cut. By the time the field had been narrowed to two bidders, Bombardier was offering a lot more and for a lot less. If Bombardier could deliver what it was offering, then the case for appointing Bombardier was compelling.

Unfortunately, as KPMG noted “the capability of the supplier to deliver these benefits had not been adequately demonstrated or interrogated”. TfL has openly admitted it agreed a “bad contract”. The payment and penalty regimes within the contract were aligned to spend, rather than progress. This meant that in ending the contract, TfL was required to pay Bombardier a sum based on how much it had spent on the programme and not on the value of the work it had produced.

Latest news

Morgan Sindall wins Liverpool Knowledge Quarter work

Liverpool City Council awards two contracts worth £47m on Paddington Village scheme
16 hours ago

Watkin Jones targets PRS as profits surge

Strong student accommodation pipeline builds platform for growth
22 hours ago

Morgan Sindall crowned 2016 contracts champion

Wates, Willmott Dixon and Mace join top 10 firms winning most work last year
23 hours ago

Ex-Balfour finance chief to join Mitie after another profit warning

Two-day board meeting at Mitie to review strategy
23 hours ago

Lendlease set for landmark £350m Google HQ job

Decision taken on vast King's Cross building contract last Thursday
2 days ago

U+I plans £300m of office refurb work

Developer links up with American firm to target sites in London, Manchester and Dublin
22 hours ago

Loxam ups bid for Lavendon to £459m

Belgian and French giants slug it out for control of Leicester-based powered access specialist
22 hours ago

Plans in for £40m Aberdeen FC stadium

Dons press ahead with 20,000-seat stadium and football academy plan
23 hours ago

London Council unveils Wood Green regen plan

Major Wood Green town centre scheme relies on Crossrail 2 reroute
23 hours ago

Laing O’Rourke to be replaced on £80m Whitechapel job

L&Q going back to market for new contractor on mixed-use scheme
2 days ago

Callum Tuckett joins Multiplex

New role for former Laing O'Rourke commercial director
2 days ago

Green light for £300m Luton regen scheme

Leisure and residential scheme to transform former Vauxhall car plant
2 days ago

Kier gears up for £85m Eastbourne mall expansion

Work to get underway on Arndale shopping centre extension
3 days ago

CITB plans levy cut in bid to survive

Training body offers to cut levy from 0.5% to 0.3% of staff wage bill
3 days ago

Wates starts £40m Kilburn housing scheme

Residential arm strengthens housing team as workload rises
3 days ago

£39m Headingley stadium revamp approved

Cricket and rugby stadium revamp needs new funding plan
2 days ago

Video posted online of O’Rourke demolition collapse

Footage shows collapse on Edinburgh job where safety exclusion zone prevented injuries: Watch now
3 days ago

Carillion to start £150m Moda Manchester PRS scheme

Financing deal paves way for NOMA high-rise residential tower
3 days ago

Hall Construction calls in administrators

Administrators seek buyer for 130-year old Hull contractor
6 days ago

Mabey profit soars to £12m after business revamp

Bridge and engineering specialist steps up business investment
3 days ago

All change as Balfour/Vinci HS2 chief joins Murphy

Peter Anderson joins Murphy next month as MD for its southern operations.
6 days ago

Lendlease to start £75m Ashford scheme

Building work to start on town centre cinema and hotel complex
3 days ago

Durham Uni selects £150m contractor panel

Refurbishment and new works panel to also be used by Newcastle University
3 days ago

Cracked beams halt work at Royal Liverpool hospital

Remedial work planned after cracks found in two concrete transfer beams
6 days ago

Balfour piling expert joins Aarsleff

Chris Pantling to lead expansion of sheet piling division
6 days ago

Vinci tipped for £130m Hull Uni student village

Work set to start on first of a dozen student blocks in May
6 days ago

Willmott Dixon set for £28m Aberystwyth Innovation Campus

Innovation and Enterprise Campus will consist of five building elements
6 days ago

Government awards £1.2bn roads funding to councils

Bin lorries to be fitted with hi-tech kit to spot potholes
6 days ago

Hendry review backs £1.3bn Swansea Bay tidal scheme

Tidal lagoon schemes are cost effective rules former energy minister
7 days ago

Carillion lands £49m rail upgrade contract

Contractor to deliver electrification of stretch of line between Edinburgh and Glasgow
6 days ago

Contractor services