NAO challenges value of PFI contracts

Aaron Morby 4 months ago
Share

The Government’s spending watchdog has given its verdict on PFI warning that there is a lack of evidence to show private finance projects offer better value than public procurement.

Carillion's flagship PF2 Midlands Metropolitan hospital where construction is a year behind and cost soared

The NAO warns that taxpayers will shell out nearly £200bn meeting agreed future charges on the existing PFI projects that are commissioned.

It says there is little evidence that PFI even delivers greater certainty of outturn cost during construction and warns that the cost of finance can be 2-3.75% higher than from state borrowing.

The critical report is a blow for the construction industry which enjoyed surging orders in the early years and has delivered 716 PFI/PF2 projects, with a total value of £60bn.

It was written before the collapse of Carillion, which held numerous PFI contracts and has swung the focus onto the value of operation maintenance and cost of construction on flagship projects for Government.

Repayment for these projects cost the taxpayer £10.3bn last year, the report found. Even if no new deals were agreed, the cost of these projects is forecast to reach £200bn by the 2040s, the report says.

The Department for Education, which delivers less risky projects, has found that the financing route has little or no effect on the construction costs of schools being built.

The NAO suggests that the risk of construction cost overruns could also be transferred using a shorter private finance contract that only covers the construction period but this option has never been pursued in the UK.

On claims that PFI bring operational efficiencies, the NAO said its survey of four Government departments last year revealed three considered operational costs were higher under PFI and the other department considered they were the same.

They tended to consider that maintenance standards were higher under PFI.

The NAO also said the Government had appeared to have cooled on PF2 with only six projects reaching financial close since it was launched in 2012.

These are the Priority School Building Programme, which will build 46 schools in five batches, and the Midland Metropolitan Hospital where Carillion was running over a year late on construction.

Despite the Government promising to deliver an expanded pipeline of PF2 there are currently no projects in procurement although Highways England is considering use of PF2 to finance the £1.3bn A303 Stonehenge tunnel and roads and the £1.5 billion approach roads to the Lower Thames Crossing.

“Decisions that have an impact on taxpayer-funded public services for decades need to be thought through,” said Meg Hillier, Chair of the Committee of Public Accounts. “There are lessons to be learnt and these need to be considered in the context of 20 years not just expediency today.”

Latest news

Contractor saved after being sunk by the “Carillion effect”

Directors buy Blue Square Building out of administration saving 100 jobs
3 days ago

Skanska signs £141m landmark Knightsbridge rebuild

Keltbray starts piling work after complex site clearance job
3 days ago

Birmingham puts firms on alert for £2bn framework

Balfour Beatty, Bouygues, Morgan Sindall and Willmott Dixon face fight to renew places
3 days ago

Watkin Jones to start £68m Reading build to rent scheme

M&G and Lochailort forward fund 315-flat Thames Quarter high-rise project
3 days ago

Government to consult on banning combustible cladding

Government bows to pressure from public, industry and MPs
3 days ago

Caddick’s £300m Leeds SOYO scheme approved

Work to start later this year on 515-home New York Square first phase
4 days ago

Unite property director takes helm at Watkin Jones

Richard Simpson to take over from Mark Watkin at the start of 2019
3 days ago

Green light for £56m Warrington private rental scheme

High Street Group prepares to start another PRS scheme in £340m pipeline
3 days ago

ISG wins two Edinburgh hotel builds worth £40m-plus

Hospitality sector expertise books Premier Inn and Yotel projects
3 days ago

Seddon sets up mental health hotline for staff

Tragic suicide of young painter inspires new campaign across the company
4 days ago

Combustible cladding escapes ban in Hackitt Report

Post-Grenfell report calls for CDM-style chain of responsibility policed by new regulatory body
4 days ago

Trio net £1.3bn Clyde submarine base framework

VolkerStevin, Kier Graham Defence and Morgan Sindall secure 10-year work programme
4 days ago

Theresa May pledges £400m to strip Grenfell-type cladding

Government will pay for retrofit work on 158 tower blocks
5 days ago

Retiring Van Elle boss sells shares for £4.8m

Outgoing chief executive Jon Fenton sell 7% stake in AIM-listed piling group
4 days ago

British Land braced for jump in construction costs

Developer expecting build inflation of 3-4% next year
4 days ago

Countryside to open modular panel timber frame factory

Mixed tenure partnerships division now bigger than private house building
4 days ago

North Midland launches development arm

Strong start to year but problem Telecoms division continues to dog results
4 days ago

Global tunnel expert to head HS2 Align JV team

Bouygues, Sir Robert McAlpine, and VolkerFitzpatrick appoint new leader for £965m contract
4 days ago

Scaffolder hit by 500kg bridge panel during demolition

Court hears how victim left with multiple injuries after demolition job went wrong
4 days ago

London Mayor pledges to build 10,000 council houses

New fund set up to kick-start council house building in the capital
5 days ago

Russells wins second office refit at NOMA site

Work starts on Dantzic warehouse conversion to offices in Manchester
4 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the new Enquirer Directory

New site for suppliers and buyers will showcase their products, services and latest stories
3 weeks ago

Carillion’s board savaged for recklessness, hubris and greed

Watchdog MPs single out Richard Adam, Richard Howson and Philip Green
5 days ago

Carillion probe MPs call to break-up hold of Big Four accountants

Pension and Financial Reporting Regulators slammed as too timid in challenging bosses and bean counters
5 days ago

Graham / Hochtief JV set for Brent Cross infrastructure deal

Works will pave the way for £1.4bn shopping centre revamp
5 days ago

Balfour lands £13m Scarborough cliff stabilisation

Work will start at the end of May on cliff behind Scarborough Spa
5 days ago

Carillion’s cradle to grave journey over 19 years

Key events timeline in the rise and fall of Britain second biggest contractor
5 days ago

Plans for £70m women’s football centre and hotel

Football Association Women's Super League 1 club in talks about new home in Cheshire
5 days ago

Wates wins £650m job to start refurb of Parliament

Northern Estate revamp will provide temporary home for MPs during main renovation programme
6 days ago

Kuwaiti firm plans Birmingham’s tallest office tower

Work to start later this year on £140m next phases of Beorma Quarter
6 days ago

Contractor services