London roads upkeep JV loses court battle with TfL

Aaron Morby 6 years ago
Share

A joint venture working on road maintenance in central London has lost a High Court battle with Transport for London over work rates.

Colas, VolkerHighways and AECOM got involved in a rates row arguing that strict working time constraints placed on it by TfL delayed and prolonged work requiring extra shifts and added costs.

The CVU joint venture believed there would be a window for night-time noisy works of 4.5 hours between 7.30pm and midnight. In practice this was severely curtailed by permit conditions.

CVU argued it was therefore entitled to claim for the cost impacts of the restriction with revised rates and prices. But TfL maintained that agreed rates and uplifts in the existing agreements covered all limitations or restrictions on working conditions.

CVU announced that it was planning to quit its framework agreement in February, which was due to run to March 2021, but said this was due to removal of Government operating subsidies for road maintenance and not as a result of the rates dispute.

Ringway Jacobs has since taken on work and staff in the central London area where CVU was operating.

Now a High Court judge has ruled that TfL was right to argue that previously agreed rates applied under the London Highways Alliance Contract framework.

Justice O’Farrell said: “CVU makes a valid point that the framework agreement does not contain definitive hours and other conditions in which the works under task orders must be carried out.

“That introduces uncertainty as to the duration, scope and cost of work required. Any requirement by CVU to price such uncertainties would result in uncommercial high rates.

“There is a risk that contractors could include a premium for the risk of uncertain restrictions on working if forced to price them at the outset.”

The judge added: “However, that is balanced by the competitive tendering that applied for the framework agreement, and the volume and spread of works, from those at high risk of imposed restrictions to those at low risk of imposed restrictions. The inbuilt uncertainty introduced risk for both parties that could be assessed and evaluated.

“The purpose for which the schedule of rates was required was to provide consistency and certainty in the pricing of the works. The use of a schedule of rates enabled TfL to evaluate the tenders on a fair and equal basis. The fixing of rates and prices for the framework agreement provides opportunity and risk for both parties.

“If CVU undertakes the work instructed in a shorter duration or at lower cost than anticipated, it will receive a ‘windfall’ and TfL will have ‘overpaid’. If CVU incurs greater costs than anticipated, it will have to bear the loss and TfL will have made a saving.

“It was a matter for each party to assess the risks associated with permits issued and to price those risks accordingly.”

A spokeswoman for CVU said: “CVU would like to reiterate that they are in discussions with TfL to consider stepping down from core work in the central London area.  This action was agreed prior to the result of the recent court case being announced, and is in response to the removal of the government operating subsidy.”

Latest news

Beard expands reach as revenue hits record £179m

Builder start 2024 with healthy head of work
6 hours ago

Race to start for £25m Cardiff twin tower reclad jon

Cardiff council to use SEWCAP to bid Butetown high rise flats revamp
9 hours ago

Gove calls up ‘super-squad’ to clear London planning log-jam

Specialist planning team first to unlock 7,000 homes in Newham and Greenwich
13 hours ago

Permasteelisa in £35m cladding win at St John’s Wood Square

Italian specialist to start work on luxury resi site by the end of this year
15 hours ago

Investor pumps another £30m into low carbon builder

House builder Greencore gets more funding as latest results reveal £4m loss
18 hours ago

800-bed Leeds student and shops scheme approved

Major three-block scheme will replace The Core shopping centre in the city
22 hours ago

Modular homes specialist files administration notice

Lighthouse bosses battle to save the business
23 hours ago

Go-ahead for £175m Birmingham Broad Street tower

Work to start on 47 storey build to rent tower in September
22 hours ago

Erith trading rebounds after lengthy bid-rigging probe

Staff paid £1.5m bonus after year of growth and return to profit
23 hours ago

Balfour and Costain win vast power and carbon capture job

Nine firms to share £4bn Teesside net zero work bonanza
4 days ago

First ‘Great Grid Upgrade’ job goes to MGroup and Murphy

Works to start this summer on £400m Yorkshire GREEN electricity pylon upgrade
4 days ago

London council can no longer police planning applications

Planing row reveals Greenwich officials no longer follow-up to check on developments
4 days ago

Surgo Construction falls into administration

46 jobs lost as historic contractor ceases trading
5 days ago

Mace fresh start date for £90m Natural History Museum hub

Reading project to build store for 28m specimens to start early next year
4 days ago

Competition watchdog probes Barratt Redrow merger

CMA opens investigation into creation of mega house builder
4 days ago

Safety chiefs act to avoid building control crisis

Three-month extension to deadline for professionals to prove their competence
4 days ago

TClarke hits £500m turnover target but profitability slips

Big work-winning year sees order book swell 70% to £943m
4 days ago

Just 10% of £10bn Levelling Up funding spent by councils

Speed of delivering 'shovel-ready' projects fails to meet expectations
4 days ago

Six win £1bn North West & Central railway works deal

Story, Murphy and Amey feature in five-year CP7 framework
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon names new finance chief

James Mackenzie joins from Willmott Dixon's Eco World development JV
4 days ago

Ilke Homes name reappears after £320m collapse

New brand Homespace now owns modular designs after Ilke failure
5 days ago

Second staircase rule costs Vistry £19m

Firm reopens East Midlands timber frame manufacturing plant
5 days ago

Clients urged to get ahead of contractor recovery cycle

T&T says investment decisions must be ‘made not delayed’ for best value
5 days ago

Fife groundworks and plant hirer goes under axing 35 jobs

James Penman (Plant Hire) falls into administration in 50th anniversary year
5 days ago

Smart Motorway Programme Alliance chief to step down

Tony Slater is moving on to take up fresh career challenge
5 days ago

Balfour M25 workers vote for strike in pay row

Maintenance crews to down tools over "meagre" pay offer
6 days ago

Andrew English returns to Skanska as infrastructure boss

Returning director replaces Jonathan Willcock who is off to Costain
6 days ago

Construction back in growth as output rises 1.1% in January

Green shoots of recovery as private housing returns to growth
6 days ago

UK Construction shines in solid year for Balfour Beatty

Operating margin improves to 2.3% at UK construction arm
6 days ago

JJ Rhatigan wins £49m London co-living homes job

Wood Lane project will deliver over 200 flats
6 days ago

Contractor services