Opinion: Safety fines are getting out of control

Grant Prior 1 year ago
Share

Galliford Try and Costain were fined £1.4m each this week after a worker lost three toes at a water treatment plant.

An accident like that is obviously horrendous and shouldn’t happen.

But fines being handed out by the courts for safety breaches are accelerating at an alarming rate.

Bigger and bigger penalties are a blunt instrument that do little to improve safety standards.

The fine money is just pumped back into the court system or the public coffers.

It’s all starting to smack more of a revenue raising exercise than a drive to boost site safety.

Why not order offenders to spend more on safety training? Or pay some of a fine to the victims and their families?

The major contractors are prime targets because their large turnovers mean they get hit with the highest fines on the multiplier used by judges.

Profitability may be a better alternative measure in a construction world where large firms exist on wafer-thin margins.


Most of the safety problems lurk at the smaller end of the industry where firms often cease trading rather than face a trial after an accident.

Health and safety is, and should always be, construction’s number one priority.

Most large sites today have world-class standards and the major players do all they can to avoid danger.

If a firm is knowingly putting workers at risk then yes – throw the book at them.

But many site accidents are just that. Companies should be punished when they happen.

But there must be more effective ways than simply hitting them with huge fines.

Latest news

First project approved in £1bn East London estate rebuild

Rainham estate rebuild will kick-start '12 estates' regeneration plan
8 hours ago

J Murphy & Sons restates depth of losses

Pre-tax losses revised from £5.8m to £12.9m
16 hours ago

Crossrail air quality checks give Bond Street site all clear

Contractors carry-out extensive tests after worker and union fears
55 mins ago

Queen’s Speech confirms buildings safety regulator role

Post-Grenfell safety laws promise biggest regulatory reform to construction for 40 years
18 hours ago

Construction output forecast downgraded over HS2 fears

Warehouse construction and renewable energy projects will be bright spots next year
18 hours ago

Javid signs off £350m for Midlands hospital restart

Contract to be signed within weeks with Balfour Beatty
2 days ago

Native Land commits to £1bn London Bankside scheme

McGee wins first office core and basement deal at 1.4m sq ft riverside development
4 days ago

Contest for £500m decarbonisation framework

Fusion 21 launches hunt for heating and renewable specialists
23 hours ago

Kier/Graham JV wins £17m Bassingbourn Barracks job

British Army's Mission Training and Mobilisation Centre is moving to Cambridgeshire
23 hours ago

New A14 bypass to open a year early

Balfour Beatty/Costain/Skanska to open key section of A14 in December
22 hours ago

Cleveland Bridge set to rebound to £50m revenue

Profit more than halved last year to £1.2m after project delays
23 hours ago

£250m funding for museums and cultural projects

York's National Railway Museum wins £18.6m for new gallery space
23 hours ago

Dust blunder during Bond Street air quality checks

Workers evacuated twice as alarm raised over silica dust levels at Crossrail station
4 days ago

Systra UK hires former Galliford Try Infrastructure boss

Nick Salt takes chief executive role at Systra UK
4 days ago

Main contracting lifts Reddington turnover to £539m

Profit rises to £31m despite £7m loss at McMullen Facades
4 days ago

Middlesbrough plans £250m trio of skyscrapers

Mayor unveils ambitious digital city plan for Boho district
4 days ago

Start signed off for £207m Edinburgh tram extension

Enabling work to start next month on extension to Newhaven
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon headlines another major heritage job

£27m revamp will return Stockton-on-Tees' Art Deco Globe Theatre to its former glory
4 days ago

Ardmore snaffles £460m Raffles hotel conversion

Record fixed-price deal to convert historic Whitehall building
6 days ago

Start date for £1.4bn London Gotham City offices

New investor buys stalled 40 Leadenhall Street Mace scheme
5 days ago

Pochin’s collapse hits subcontractors for £9m

Founding family directors Jim and Bob Nicholson injected £1.5m just before collapse
6 days ago

Keltbray rail piling to cut over 30 jobs

Scale-back blamed on lack of CP6 work and project delays
5 days ago

Southern Water re-signs Galliford Try for AMP7

Joint venture share of design and build frameworks worth £240m
5 days ago

U+I reveals green façade Greenwich resi towers plan

Morden Wharf aims to deliver around 1,500 new homes
5 days ago

Arcadis to pinpoint graphene uses in construction

Consultant commissioned to promote use of wonder material in construction
6 days ago

Mace tops September contracts league

Triple tower project win at Nine Elms in London heads major orders last month
6 days ago

Cartel busters launch latest demolition raid

Competition & Markets Authority steps-up probe into industry
6 days ago

Sisk bags £87m phase 2 of Peabody estate rebuild

Around 200 homes to be delivered in next phase of south London estate rebuild
6 days ago

Two directors lead MBO of M&E contractor DES

Sean Egan and Graham Hood buy north west electrical contractor
6 days ago

Wates cleared to start Liverpool cruise liner hotel

Work to start on cruise terminal hotel at Princes Dock early next year
7 days ago

Contractor services