Watchdog blasts “rigged” £11m theatre contract

Grant Prior 8 years ago

Spending watchdogs said they have a “strong impression” that the tender race to build Belfast’s £11m Lyric Theatre was “rigged and manipulated.”

A report published by the Public Accounts Committee is highly critical of the bidding process which saw the job awarded to Gilbert Ash.

Ash won the job in 2008 despite its tender originally being the most expensive.

The report reveals that costs pf £413,000 were stripped-out of the winning bid by the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure.

The report states: “The adjustments resulted in the most costly tender submission becoming the most economically advantageous tender, and the contractor was selected as the preferred bidder on that basis.

“Despite stripping out £413,000 from the successful tender, the Department was unable to provide any reason why this amount was later paid in full.”

The Chairperson of the Committee, Michaela Boyle MLA said: “The quality of the rebuilt Lyric Theatre is undisputed; we recognise that it is a highly impressive theatre and that it has deservedly won a number of prestigious awards.

“However, the end does not justify the means. My Committee has found that there were significant departures from good practice in the award of this £11 million contract, and this is completely unacceptable.”

Gilbert Ash told the BBC it had “no control over the adjustment to tender costs made during the procurement process” – a practice it described “as standard in our industry to allow for like-for-like comparison of bids”.

PAC concerns over the contract process:

  • A number of completely unacceptable departures from long-established principles of good practice were made in awarding the Lyric Theatre rebuild contract.
  • A number of unexplained adjustments were made to the tender submissions, and the Department of Finance and Personnel’s Central Procurement Directorate (CPD) confirmed that this is not normal practice;
  • Despite £413,000 being stripped out from one of the tenders, this cost was later paid in full;
  • The private sector consultants who produced the tender evaluation report destroyed the tendering documentation very promptly after the tender evaluation meeting;
  • Proper arrangements were not put in place for either the sponsoring bodies (the Department and the Arts Council) or their technical advisors (CPD) to attend the tender evaluation meeting;
  • The Department, the Arts Council and CPD all received a copy of the tender evaluation report but failed to raise any concerns; and
  • The preferred bidder provided a donation of £150,000 to the Lyric Theatre.
  • Taking all of the points in the round the Committee is left with a very strong impression that the outcome of the tender process was both rigged and manipulated

Latest news

Balfour Beatty UK construction MD to step down

Tom Edgcumbe to depart after just over a year as MD construction services in England and Wales
4 hours ago

Crest Nicholson trebles cladding retrofit provisions to £43m

House builder revises building safety retrofit costs in face of new Government guidance
3 hours ago

BAM bags £110m refurb of iconic Covent Garden tower

Landmark Seifert-designed 15-storey Space House to get two extra floors
17 hours ago

Winvic to start UK’s largest speculative shed

Ellesmere Port warehouse understood to be worth around £80m
4 hours ago

Kier signs deal for £169m Luton hospital revamp

Main construction work to start this month and last until 2024
3 hours ago

Willmott Dixon nabs £30m Kirklees police HQ

Work to start within next few weeks on regional police HQ
11 hours ago

50 firms win £750m decarbonisation framework

Fusion21 framework to target 'whole building' works on homes and schools
4 hours ago

Kier reported to be in talks to buy Tilbury Douglas

Talks reported to be at an advanced stage between both boards
1 day ago

Finance sealed for next-generation London office job

Goldman Sachs takes stake in London Bridge office project
1 day ago

John F Hunt starts giant clean-up on £110m Walsall site

Land remediation work at contaminated site will take two years
1 day ago

Build to rent boom lifts Watkin Jones profit to £52m

Surging build to rent market lifts development pipeline to £1.8 billion
1 day ago

HS2 awards £310m station lifts and escalators deal

TK Elevator signs 160 lifts and 130 escalators deal for four stations
2 days ago

Robot cutter set to revolutionise paving jobs for Eurovia

Automated system will spell end for noisy slab cutting on busy sites
2 days ago

First mass built carbon negative homes get underway

St Modwen first volume developer to build affordable carbon-negative homes
2 days ago

GMI Construction names new CEO

Lee Powell takes helm as CEO at GMI Construction in growth push
2 days ago

514-home London scheme clears final hurdle

Inland Homes declares victory after three-year planning battle over Hillingdon Master Brewer site
2 days ago

Henry Construction wins £30m Clarion housing scheme

Ravensbury estate regeneration in Mitcham is Henry's first project for Clarion
2 days ago

Lovell lands £700m homes deal with Suffolk council

Development joint venture will see at least 2,800 homes built across the county
2 days ago

Ballymore pulls 51-storey tower plan amid fire safety concern

London Fire Brigade raises concern about single staircase and fire strategy
5 days ago

New work surges as materials shortages ease

Mild weather and easing of supply chain bottlenecks lifts new work 5.7%
5 days ago

PDR Construction goes into administration

All staff made redundant as suppliers owed millions
6 days ago

Brick-laying robot gets approval from NHBC

Robot can now be used in construction of new homes covered by NHBC warranty
5 days ago

Temporary visa scheme needed for London sites

Mayor of London demands action over site skills shortages
6 days ago

Construction worker dies after fall from mobile tower

Court hears how tower wasn't configured correctly
6 days ago

Glencar wins £50m Peterborough logistics hub

Works start on trio of sheds at Kingston Park
6 days ago

Green light for £330m Woking high-rise cluster

Work to start on five blocks towards the end of 2022.
6 days ago

Countryside chief executive makes sudden exit

Major shareholder takes seat on board as first quarter trading falls below board expectations
6 days ago

Big names line-up for £2.7bn Birmingham roads deal

Arup, Arcadis, Balfour Beatty, Carnell, Colas, Kier and Tarmac among firms eyeing contract
6 days ago

Galliford Try scoops £56m Milton Keynes PRS job

Building arm will deliver 329 rental flats across four buildings rising up to 11 storeys
7 days ago

Designers shortlisted for £1bn Oxford Innovation district

Oxford Uni and L&G advance £1bn Begbroke science district plan
7 days ago

Contractor services