Hochtief beats £130m Scottish hydro project claim

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

Power company Scottish & Southern Electricity has lost its legal claim for £130m against contractor Hochtief following the collapse of a section of major tunnel at the Glendoe hydroelectric scheme.

Glendoe hydroelectric scheme above Loch Ness required Hochtief to bore 5 miles of tunnel
Glendoe hydroelectric scheme above Loch Ness required Hochtief to bore 5 miles of tunnel

SSE launched legal action to cover the cost of bringing BAM Nuttall in to repair the water tunnel after a bust-up with Hochtief over who would pay for the remedial work.

Hochtief signed a £126m contract back in December 2005 after beating rival bidder Morgan Est to secure the major TBM rock tunnelling project.

The Glendoe hydroelectric scheme above Loch Ness was the biggest one to be built in Scotland for many years and consisted of boring a total of 5 miles of tunnel the diameter of the London Tube.

Hochtief handed over the scheme at the end of 2008 gaining a £2m bonus for achieving early completion, allowing the scheme to begin operating in January 2009.

Seven months later, however, it ceased to generate electricity. SSE discovered that rock material had fallen into the tunnel over several months, leading to an almost complete blockage.

SSE was losing substantial amounts of revenue while the scheme was out of commission. But after four month haggling with Hochtief about who should pay for the works, called in BAM Nuttall.

Remedial works took much longer and cost far more than expected. The scheme did not begin to generate electricity again until August 2012.

Glendoe

The tunnel section that collapsed lay in a geological area known as the Conagleann Fault Zone

SSE sought to recover the £130m costs involved in the remedial works from Hochtief in the Scottish Court of Session. SSE relied on various provisions in the contract to try and establish liability.

In its defence Hochtief contended that it had completed the works in accordance with the contract, and that SSE had assumed the risk of the collapse at takeover.

Lord Woolman said that the collapse had occurred in a part of the tunnel that lay in a geological area known as the Conagleann Fault Zone.

All the engineering geologists had known about the CFZ before construction began. They expected to find poor rock conditions there. In fact they found none. As a result they saw no reason to reinforce the tunnel perimeter in that section. The collapse was caused by insufficient support.

Having heard the evidence from several tunnelling experts, Lord Woolman said: “I am satisfied that Hochtief did exercise reasonable skill and care. SSE’s case depends on the accumulation and interpretation of all the data that has been obtained since the collapse. Put short, it is founded on hindsight.”

He decided that Hochtief was not liable.

Lord Woolman said that the parties had agreed £1m as the ceiling figure for the lost income incurred by SSE, and that he was minded to award that sum. Lord Woolman also said that the cost of the recovery project was in the main reasonable.

A spokesman for the energy company said: “SSE is disappointed with the ruling by the Court of Session on the compensation claim relating to repair work at our Glendoe hydro scheme near Fort Augustus in the Highlands. We will review the decision in more detail and assess our options.”

Latest news

ISG collapse brings down glazing contractor

All staff made redundant at Vitrine Systems Limited
2 days ago

Cost of HS2 bat shed hits £100m

Construction costs revealed for Sheephouse Wood Bat Mitigation Structure
2 days ago

JRL close to deal on sale of stake to Far Eastern buyer

Equity sale plan to strengthen balance sheet and improve liquidity
3 days ago

Groundworks firm Corbyn files administration notice

Court notice lodged by £33m-turnover contractor
3 days ago

Vistry takes another £50m hit on build cost blunders

Second profit warning but problems contained in one division
3 days ago

Watkin Jones go-ahead for Leeds co-living project

Firm will convert former office block Headrow House into 230 homes.
3 days ago

United Utilities hunts for ground investigation specialists

£170m five-year framework deal out to tender
3 days ago

WSP names new chief for UK and Ireland

Paul Reilly promoted to UK president after just over two years at consultant
3 days ago

£125m cash injection for infrastructure at Barking Riverside

Home England funded works to boost 20,000-home development in east London
3 days ago

Subcontractors wanted across the North West

Register now to meet major buyers at Manchester event
3 days ago

Management buyout at joinery specialist TMJ Interiors

Founder James Taylor hands over reins to directors
3 days ago

Guinness Partnership starts race for £1bn housing deal

Housing association to renew preferred firms for 15-year housing retrofit programme
4 days ago

Rockwool plans new factory to ramp up output

Stone wool maker plans second factory in Midlands
4 days ago

McAleer & Rushe wins London City 670-room student job

Dominus confirms builder for 65 Holborn Viaduct
4 days ago

Electrician caught abusing covid loans

Middlesbrough spark subject to seven years of stringent bankruptcy restrictions
4 days ago

Wates hires Bouygues chief as MD for residential arm

Phillippa Prongue will replace Helen Bunch who retires
4 days ago

Civils powers on but house building falters

Buyers report "solid output growth" despite decline from record September
4 days ago

Multiplex tops October contracts league

£300m Glasgow Uni win tops big new orders
5 days ago

Key industry rebar supplier loses fight to stop factory closure

Kent rebar facility supplying 30% of UK rebar set to close
5 days ago

Vital Energi/Hemiko JV to build £1bn heat network for Westminster

Heat captured from the River Thames, Tube and sewers to warm Parliament
5 days ago

Plans in for Birmingham 300-bed student scheme

China Quarter stepped project will rise to 15 storeys
5 days ago

United Living looking to continue expansion

Record results as infrastructure and property spending flows
5 days ago

Paralysed builder stranded on floor for six hours after fall

Court hears how contractor failed to properly plan housing job
5 days ago

Network Rail scales back Liverpool Street station scheme

Architect changed and developer Sellar dropped as £1.5bn original plan scrapped
6 days ago

Muse JVs with pension fund insurer to build 3,000 homes

New Habiko business will build affordable low carbon, rental homes
6 days ago

£1.3bn revamp plan for South London shopping centre

Landsec plans 1,700 homes at Lewisham shopping complex site
6 days ago

Network Plus names new chief executive

Kevin Fowlie steps up to succeed founder Dan Holland
6 days ago

TanRo lands latest Clowes business park

Groundworks due to start in new year at 31-acre Harrier Park site
6 days ago

New consultant buys M&E specialist TACE

Contollo Group has ambitious growth plans over next five years
6 days ago

Skanska signs £197m deal for Mayfair offices job

South Molton job consists of two big office buildings
7 days ago

Contractor services