Barnes family loses fight for £1.8m over bus station job

Aaron Morby 2 months ago

The family owners of former Bury-based building contractor Thomas Barnes & Sons have lost their fight for compensation from the local council over the Blackburn bus exchange project.

Thomas Barnes administrator Begbies Traynor, backed by the family who are secured creditors, went to court claiming £1.8m from client Blackburn with Darwen Borough Council.

The building firm, which turned over more than £15m, was kicked off the Blackburn bus exchange project in June 2015 mid-way through construction over lack of progress on the complex job.

The administrators claim that failure by the council to make interim payments and the wrongful termination of the contract caused Thomas Barnes to collapse later in 2015.

According to the court papers, directors at Thomas Barnes at the time strongly believed that the problems which led to it being removed from the project were, in very large part, a consequence of failings of Capita, which had been hired by the council to provide a full design and project administration service on the project.

They said: “The claimant’s case is that those within the defendant and Capita who were responsible for this project were very keen to pin the blame for the serious time and cost overruns on the project on someone else and that the defendant’s decision to terminate was both led by Capita and politically motivated to put the blame on the claimant.”

All of this was strongly disputed by the defendant, said Judge Stephen Davies.

The council also argued it was entitled to terminate the contract and was entitled to a counter-claimed £1.9m for the cost of the extra work to complete the bus station.

Judge Stephen Davies accepted that Barnes was entitled to an extension of time which was greater than that allowed for by its client.

But he added that since the end of February 2015 the works had been plagued by delays which were almost entirely Barnes’ own fault and contractual responsibility.

He said any delay related-damages for Barnes fell short of the claim relating to damages arising from the council’s right to terminate the contract under provisions for delay-related breaches.

In a written judgement he said: “It follows that the claimant has no prospect of recovering anything in this litigation, since any entitlement it may establish under a final account analysis would be more than extinguished by the defendant’s right to recover and to set off against such entitlement the net cost of having the contract completed by replacement contractors.”

Latest news

John Lewis £500m funding deal to build 1,000 rental homes

Deal to advance BTR flats at store sites in Bromley, West Ealing and Reading
3 hours ago

Eric Wright wins tricky £52m Liverpool transformation

Contractor working with engineers at Ridge and Partners on "challenging" Stanley Lock Flight site
2 days ago

Investment giant buys Bristol M&E contractor

RDCP Infrastructure acquires Avon Combined Electrical Services
3 days ago

Demolition start for £50m Farnworth town centre rebuild

Caddick Construction is tipped for main works due to start in the spring
3 days ago

L&G Modular strikes deal to build 1,000 affordable homes

Modular homes business teams up with Hampshire's Vivid housing association
3 days ago

Former Erith operations director joins John F Hunt

Scott Exell named new operations director at demolition specialist John F Hunt
3 days ago

Green light for £135m Leeds twin tower resi scheme

Construction to start in New Year on 500 build-to-rent apartments
3 days ago

Mace hits 1m tonnes carbon saving target for clients

Present work pipeline betters 2026 carbon emission saving target
3 days ago

Plans in for £40m surf park at former Kent colliery

Seahive surf lagoon and health resort will be built near Deal
4 days ago

Crushed demolition worker vows to return to industry

Shannon Brasier hoping to return to construction following horror accident
4 days ago

Mount Anvil to start 900-home North London estate rebuild

Planning approval paves way for Barnsbury Estate rebuild in Islington
4 days ago

Green light for major laboratory campus in Cambridge

Developer BioMed to tender first building on 600,000 sq ft lab complex in the New Year
4 days ago

Belfast firm signs the biggest work deal yet under Project Gigabit

Fibrus to hook-up rural Cumbria to lightning-fast broadband under £108m deal
4 days ago

McLaren wins Leeds logistics park contract

Work to start imminently on warehouse complex for Firethorn Trust
4 days ago

Work restarts on £683m waste power plant after site death

Construction suspended for a week of investigations following fatality
4 days ago

Demolition starts on £135m Wigan Galleries scheme

Contractor BCEGI starts work on project to redevelop Wigan town centre
5 days ago

Amey CEO to step down following private equity buyout

Amanda Fisher to leave once business is transferred to new owners
5 days ago

New body set up to vet plant operator card schemes

Contractor trades bodies unite to tackle competency concerns over plant operator skills cards
5 days ago

Kier leads switch to hybrid battery generators

Battery units work alongside smaller generators cutting run times by nearly 60%
5 days ago

Plans in for first Leeds co-living scheme

Watkin Jones submits plan to convert old Direct Line HQ into 230 studio flats
5 days ago

Demolition worker crushed by excavator

Court hears 20-year-old woman was left with "life changing injuries"
5 days ago

Government pays £700m for 50% stake in Sizewell C

New body, Great British Nuclear, will be set up to develop pipeline of nuclear projects
5 days ago

Costain wins Heathrow Airport asset renewal deal

Firm takes early contractor involvement role in Terminal 2 baggage handling upgrade
6 days ago

Worker killed on £683m waste power plant site

Fatal collision involving heavy goods vehicle on giant north London site
6 days ago

HS2 JV shifts four Wembley Stadiums of earth in record time

EKFB team digs and hauls 15 million cu m of muck in 20 months
6 days ago

Milestone wins £300m Wiltshire highways upkeep

Ringway will hand over to Milestone in March next year
6 days ago

Low-risk business model helps Renew post record results

Renew reveals latest acquisition with £15.6m purchase of water specialist Enisca
6 days ago

London Albert Embankment hotel towers approved

Two separate hotels rising to 26 and 29 storeys approved
6 days ago

Keltbray names new director of strategic engineering

Tim Lohmann takes up newly-formed role to drive innovative engineering solutions
6 days ago

Go-ahead for £200m lithium refinery on Teesside

Work to start next year on Europe's first lithium hydroxide processing plant
7 days ago

Contractor services