Top consultant tells clients stop using fixed-price contracts

Aaron Morby 3 weeks ago
Share

Consultant Turner & Townsend is urging clients to steer clear of using fixed-price contracts that pass too much risk to contractors as the industry grows more confident about prospects.

The cost consultant warns that project programmes are struggling with labour shortages causing delays, reducing productivity and creating operational bottlenecks.

The capacity crunch is increasingly constrained by the high level of insolvencies in the sector, further compounded by contractors across the industry taking a stand to be more selective in their approach to bidding new work.

In its Autumn market intelligence report, T&T said that while material cost volatility and overall tender price inflation have moderated, programme teams should be wary of asking suppliers to take on significant project risk through fixed-price contracts.

It warns that bids received will be risk-adjusted and more expensive. Also tender would more likely come from firms in greater need of securing turnover than those received for contracts offering a fairer risk allocation.

Martin Sudweeks, UK managing director for cost management at T&T, said they were advising clients to aim for more equitable transfers of risk and encourage the procurement of partners, not just suppliers, to enable better quality bids and enhance the working relationship with the supply chain.

He said the firm was also highlighting the benefits of contracting directly with second tier suppliers to improve visibility and control costs, as well as the importance of incentivisation to boost performance.

Sudweeks said: “It is encouraging to see confidence in the sector beginning to return as we find some relief in the form of lower interest rates and a rise in new orders.

“However, despite the cooling of tendering conditions and general weakness of the construction sector, this is far from a buyer’s market and businesses will need to be careful about how they manage risk to deliver major programmes successfully.

“As we head towards the Chancellor’s budget this Autumn, organisations should be looking to establish sophisticated commercial models that can balance the risk and reward for both the client and suppliers.

“Careful apportioning of risk, while promoting incentivisation and collaboration, will be the keys to success as we deliver the next generation of transformative real estate and infrastructure projects for the country.”

The publication reports more positive business sentiment and holds firm with its tender price inflation forecast, with building and infrastructure landing at 3% and 4.5%, respectively.

Tender price inflation forecast


Latest news

Buckingham supply chain hit soars above £300m

Unpaid bills from unsecured creditors keep mounting
36 mins ago

Winners of £3bn London housing major works deal

Graham, Kier, McLaren, Morgan Sindall, Vinci and Wates win places
5 hours ago

BBC brickies firm went down owing £2m to suppliers

Hodgkinson Builders sold for £95,300 in pre-pack deal
5 hours ago

Network Rail reveals top suppliers spend

BAM leads as biggest civils rail contractor
5 hours ago

Go-ahead for £125m Immingham Ro-Ro terminal

Dragados is lined up to deliver the terminal which includes three new berths
4 hours ago

Renew buys onshore wind firm for £50m

Full Circle deal adds 160 specialist technicians to workforce
4 hours ago

New construction boss for Robertson North East

Neil Kennedy promoted to MD of Gateshead-based regional operation
7 hours ago

Civils work fuels fastest output rise in two-and-a half years

Construction buyers see September surge
3 days ago

Barratt £2.5bn takeover of Redrow clears final hurdle

House building giants merger plan gets go-ahead after competition probe
2 days ago

Renew sells Walter Lilly building arm

100-year-old building business sold to luxury contractor Size
3 days ago

Work to start on Teesside and Merseyside carbon capture schemes

Government commits £22bn funding to world's first industrial-scale carbon capture projects
3 days ago

Flagship £200m London Premier Inn scheme approved

700-bed hotel to be built on the Strand near Trafalgar Square
3 days ago

Kilnbridge appoints new construction director

Former McGee director Darren Wickins joins concrete frame specialist
3 days ago

HS2 trial to replace cement with baked clay

Extra funding for programme to replace cement in concrete with calcined clay
3 days ago

Subcontractors wanted across the South West

Register now for latest Constructionline event in Bristol
3 days ago

Galliford Try profits and revenue surge

Release of delayed building jobs and surging water spend boosts firm
4 days ago

Octavius Infrastructure national expansion push pays off

Revenue leaps 28% to £277m with order book at over £1bn
4 days ago

Skanska staff get access to digital doctors

Contractor launches benefit for staff and their families
4 days ago

Another new name for former Kier Living housing arm

Tilia Homes and Hopkins Homes now known as untypical
4 days ago

Danny Sullivan Group buys M&E recruitment firm

Acquisition boosts presence in infrastructure sector
4 days ago

Sisk in talks to finish ISG’s £200m Teesside vaccine plant

First big job to restart since crash of ISG nearly two weeks ago
5 days ago

Wates snaps up 1,100-staff social housing upgrade contractor

Liberty deal spearheads push into heating and compliance market
6 days ago

Go-ahead for Liverpool film studios and museum jobs

£60m Littlewoods film studio and £58m museum revamp approved
5 days ago

London RC frame specialist goes under

Bela Structures had a 100-strong workforce at peak
4 days ago

VolkerWessels lifted by marine arm’s return to profit

Group operating margin slips to 2.5% in challenging year
6 days ago

United Living appoints Director of Water

Scott Beard joins from Welsh Water where he was head of engineering
5 days ago

HE Simm eyes return to profit after £10m loss

£4m family cash injection helps engineering division rebound
6 days ago

Dragados lands Elephant & Castle tunnel deal

Work to start next year on excavating 135m of new passenger tunnels
6 days ago

Caddick bolsters Midlands construction team

John Currie and Ian Calder to oversee operations in region
6 days ago

Angry staff call for investigation into collapse of ISG

Former staff say business began to unwind two years ago amid management failures
6 days ago

Contractor services