Opinion: Aftermath of BSF bombshell

Aaron Morby 15 years ago
Share

Much has been said about the Building Schools for the Future programme in recent days and none of it has been very flattering.

If the BSF bashing commentaries are to be believed it stands as Labour’s biggest error of judgement since weapons of mass destruction.

According to axe-swinging education secretary Michael Gove no school should ever have been built under such a programme in the first place.

He has savaged BSF claiming buildings have had to be knocked down because corridors were too narrow, badly-fitted school doors swung open in strong winds and air conditioning systems failed to work.

The charge is that BSF failed the country because it could not deliver quality buildings.

There may be isolated examples of shortcomings in the build quality, but this sweeping conclusion is utter nonsense.

It is misleading to use a few picky anecdotes to rubbish the real achievements of BSF.

At times it was too bureaucratic, and contractors were frustrated by painfully slow progress at the outset, but wasteful and botched, it was not.

BSF has delivered high quality schools. Modern buildings that are designed and delivered to give future generations the best possible learning environment.

These so-called “botched” schools are fitted with 21st century ICT systems so that kids can get a taste of the speed at which technology and the world is changing around them.

History will judge BSF as a golden age of school building that was too short-lived, not as a complete waste of money.

Was wasteful form filling a good reason to can BSF? Absolutely not.

Whatever we are told, it is clear that BSF has been killed off because of the need to cut spending not because it needed to be done another way.

To argue otherwise is misleading and a slur on the achievements of the programme.

Like all major Government capital spending programmes, BSF was slow to get going but it had clicked into cruise mode when the axe fell.

Now the experience gained through a planned programme of investment will be lost.

Building teams who had built up extensive knowledge about how to deliver schools cost-effectively are being disbanded. Local authority commitment and know-how will also disappear along with precious programme momentum.

The cost of cancelling BSF will not be known for some time, but hundreds of millions of pounds have been wasted.

In its place, the industry is promised a radical review. A board of mainly high street retailers and Sir John Egan will now pronounce on how to do things better.

This exercise in seeking greater value for money looks like playing for time.

The brutal fact is a quality school building programme is being replaced by a lick-of-paint schools policy which has been dreamed up to deal with the deficit crisis not because of the shortcomings of all those who worked hard to deliver BSF.

We can only hope that the son of BSF inherits some of the traits of its predecessor.

Latest news

Goldbeck to build new £50m Cardiff County Hall

German-owned contractor vowing to be a "disrupter in the UK market"
4 hours ago

Laing O’Rourke chairman to step down

Ray O'Rourke to take over chair from Sir John Parker
17 hours ago

Farrans lands Leeds Bradford Airport phase 2 upgrade

Contractor takes follow-on refurb job after terminal extension
11 hours ago

ISG built Bristol housing block to be torn down

Contractor's collapse sinks Bristol flats remediation claim
20 hours ago

RSK revenue nears £2bn as losses soar to £132m

Refinancing last summer puts group on course for more growth this year
20 hours ago

Bridge design wind error adds £20m to construction costs

Completion of £148m Grantham Southern Relief Road delayed by a year
20 hours ago

Rayner pledges extra £350m for social house building

More than 3,000 homes could be built with cash injection
19 hours ago

City’s biggest retrofit tower scheme approved

Triple-fronted 70 Gracechurch Street building will rise to 33 storeys
2 days ago

Defibrillator saves worker’s life on Wates site

Machine operator saved after "dying" for 16 minutes on prison job
2 days ago

Funding deal for £125m Camden Roundhouse scheme

Developer Regal set to start 264-bed student scheme
2 days ago

Balfour leadership rejig to focus on three key growth sectors

Divisional CEO trio take lead roles for energy, defence and transport expansion
2 days ago

ABP bidders day for £150m Humber ports pipeline

Nine projects in the pipeline to support automotive and energy transition schemes
2 days ago

Hinkley Point C to create 3,000 jobs as work ramps up

Fitout surge to swell workforce to 15,000 in next 18 months
2 days ago

Hercules sells suction excavator division for £2.4m

Loss making arm sold by labour hire specialist
2 days ago

Foundations complete at HS2 Old Oak Common station

Station base completed using 76,000 cubic metres of concrete and 17,000 tonnes of reinforced steel
2 days ago

Bids invited for £175m consultancy framework

Fusion21 inviting consultants to join latest four-year deal
2 days ago

Regulator pledges to clear 122 project backlog by April

A third of applications failed to meet required standards says building safety regulator
3 days ago

Government opens bidding for new AI Growth Zones

Interest for sites in Scotland, Wales, the North East and North West
3 days ago

Vistry strikes deal for phase 3 of £1.2bn London estate rebuild

323-homes at giant Clapham Park scheme move to construction
3 days ago

Fire hits £31m student accommodation site

Blaze breaks out on Lancaster job where Bridgestone Construction is main contractor
4 days ago

Green light for £250m Salford data centre

Six acre plot to be transformed at Peel Waters site
3 days ago

Two in race for £269m HS2 people mover deal

Winner expected next year as hunt continues for infrastructure builder
3 days ago

M&E specialist J S Wright files administration notice

Employee-owned Midlands specialist was established 135 years ago
6 days ago

£90m funding release for quartet of road upgrades

Government green lights schemes to improve journey times in Wiltshire, Leeds, Essex and Buckinghamshire.
6 days ago

Another month of repairs at McAlpine problem panel hotel

Road closure causes chaos as wind-hit cladding needs fixing above
6 days ago

Skanska lands design role on £1.25bn steelworks

Skanska team to work alongside main contractor McAlpine on Port Talbot project
7 days ago

Construction boss jailed for double Covid loan claim

Two-and-a-half years for building fraudster
6 days ago

Bleak January for construction buyers

Latest bellwether survey shows output down and costs up
7 days ago

Starmer rips up rules to ease building of nuclear reactors

Industry backs push for small modular reactors to be built where needed
7 days ago

McAlpine tops January work league with steelworks win

Port Talbot steelworks job dominates January orders haul
7 days ago

Contractor services