Opinion: O’Rourke pays unfair price for PAYE workers

Grant Prior 13 years ago

Sympathy would have been in short supply at rival contractors around the country on hearing Laing O’Rourke’s latest results this week.

Britain’s biggest private construction company doesn’t go out of its way to make friends when it comes to doing business.

So rivals could be forgiven a wry smile when news broke of a 15% drop in turnover and more than 3,500 redundancies.

The falling figures signalled an end to years of spectacular growth.

But O’Rourke’s woes are bad news for the whole industry because every contractor experienced similar pain last year – albeit on a smaller scale.

And O’Rourke has also been unfairly punished for employing the vast majority of its workforce rather than hanging on to the self-employment model which the government has been trying to stamp-out for years.

A large directly employed workforce can be an advantage when order books are full.

But O’Rourke, and other firms like Rok who have a lot of PAYE site staff, have found it can be a millstone around your neck during lean times.

The brutal truth is that when work dries-up you either pay people to do nothing or let them go.

O’Rourke rightly received plaudits for its direct employment model. But public bodies still awarded work to contractors who subbed everything out.

The combination of little benefit in boom times and a huge disadvantage in a downturn will kill-off any future hopes of making direct employment the industry’s standard model.

O’Rourke flew the flag for direct employment and it has proved a massive financial problem for them resulting in mass redundancy pay-offs.

The firm invests a fortune in training which makes it even tougher to let well qualified staff go.

A lot of O’Rourke’s unpopularity is down to its success and driving ambition.

The latest bad results may have prompted a few smirks.

But what’s bad for the UK’s largest private contractor is bad for the industry at large and a death knell for changing construction’s working practices.

Latest news

Bouygues/Murphy JV confirmed for £2.3bn Thames tunnel job

BMJV clinches 4.2km Lower Thames Crossing road tunnel job
1 day ago

Berkeley keeping close eye on subbies as market softens

Supply chain insolvency now bigger threat than build cost rises
14 hours ago

Roofing firm fined £881,000 after double fall

Court hears of two falls on sites involving same contractor
1 day ago

Plans in for £450m Coventry city centre regeneration

Work is expected to start next summer on City Centre South scheme
14 hours ago

Galliford Try to upgrade Red Arrows base

Contractor seals quartet of RAF base upgrades
15 hours ago

Strabag tunnel drive in Yorkshire sets new world record

Woodsmith potash mine tunnelling project to be included in Guinness World Records
1 day ago

McLaren and Arlington to develop York Central site

Developer deal signed for one of the UK’s largest city centre regeneration schemes
2 days ago

Watkin Jones plans 36-storey Glasgow tower

The Ard student rooms scheme will be Glasgow's second tallest building
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty on track for solid set of results

Country's largest contractor on course to meet financial targets
2 days ago

Brymor Group Southern heads for CVA

Hampshire builder applies for Company Voluntary Arrangement with its creditors.
2 days ago

Former Costain transport chief joins Aecom

Sue Kershaw takes up US-based vice president job with consultant
2 days ago

Industry’s best construction managers revealed

More than 80 now in the running for delayed awards: Full list
2 days ago

Materials prices plummet as housing demand slumps

Buyers report biggest fall in purchasing costs for 14 years
3 days ago

Welsh contractor Andrew Scott targets £90m turnover

Profit and revenue up at Port Talbot-based civils and building firm
3 days ago

M-AR buyer starts round of redundancies

30 jobs at risk after modular firm bought out of administration
3 days ago

First HS2 viaduct completes deck beam installation

EKFB completes beams for first of project's 50 major viaducts
3 days ago

Fatal accident at Laing O’Rourke Oxford site

Work suspended on site after tragedy
4 days ago

Homes lead the way as Bancon Group boosts turnover

Homes and contracting group looking to further growth in 2024
3 days ago

L&G Modular Homes scheme replaced by traditional build

Wolverhampton council chooses new partner and build method for £150m project
3 days ago

£33m Plymouth city centre homes scheme approved

Spring start for Bath Street scheme in Millbay regeneration area
3 days ago

Balfour renews £330m Lincolnshire highways deal

Firm will use its new operational control hub to promptly address network issues
4 days ago

Three Caledonian Modular-built schools to be demolished

DfE confirms Essex, Somerset and Northampton schools will be bulldozed and rebuilt
4 days ago

Gilbert-Ash takes £30m Tate Liverpool revamp

Work to start in the New Year on remodelling of iconic 1846 warehouse
4 days ago

HS2 Solihull mass transit enabling works out to bid

Bidding for £60m main works to start early next year
4 days ago

Modular health specialist Vanguard rescues M-AR

Deal with administrators sees Vanguard add production capacity with 100,00 sq ft offsite factory
4 days ago

Torsion forms JV to build £90m Leeds resi tower

Construction to start in January on one of Leeds' tallest towers
4 days ago

Approved change to concrete ‘recipe’ to slash carbon emissions

New approved concrete mixes will be able to blend finely ground limestone and fly ash
5 days ago

Network Rail unveils Cardiff South Central masterplan

Plans being drawn up for major housing-led mixed-use scheme
4 days ago

McLaren Living to revamp Watford police station site

Developer to submit plans for a major mixed-use development
4 days ago

National Grid £12.8bn HV civils framework hits market

Firms needed for major power line links and high voltage direct current converter stations
5 days ago

Contractor services