Opinion: Housebuilders screw subbies to cut costs

Aaron Morby 13 years ago
Share

Boasts by Britain’s house builders about their success in driving down building costs must strike a raw nerve with subcontractors.

Both Taylor Wimpey and Persimmon claim to have driven down costs by 9% and 14% from peak.

Taken at face value, it would seem house builders have delivered in a few tough years what Government and commercial clients have been striving to do for decades.

This would be no mean achievement if these gloriously big savings were achieved through hard graft, efficient work planning, innovative construction and better central buying of materials.

But this isn’t the full story as every trade contractor knows.

Every client has the right to strike a hard-bargain on building work, but the methods used by house builders must be called into question because they make Stalin look even-handed.

One house builder’s tough price negotiation is a trade contractor’s gun to the head.

The housing industry has been often accused of suffering from a short memory, but wasn’t it just over a year ago that subcontractors were handed diktats to slash prices by 5% and 10% or else.

Many of those firms who felt forced to comply are probably no longer around to talk about the experience.

This isn’t good long term business practice, even for hard nosed developers.

Of course, low building costs have given house builders confidence to start up new sites even while the recovery remains fragile. But counting on costs staying low looks optimistic, if not foolhardy.

In mainstream construction, consultants have been telling clients to get a move on with building plans while costs remain ultra competitive. Cost consultants for once have proved the contractors’ ally in this respect.

The tide is turning, mainly because there is better paid, more reliable maintenance work elsewhere. Carillion, which manages to just about scrape a 1% margin on main construction activity, has had enough for one.

It is prepared to see turnover dive to claw back a respectable margin. Others will follow as everybody strives to give clients a reality check.

Latest news

£500m Leeds South Bank scheme gets green light

Leeds City Council approves plan for 1,350 flats in mixed-use South Bank development
1 day ago

Galliford Try takes rebid £150m Carlisle Southern Link Road

Main construction works are due to start on 8km road in June
1 day ago

Arup takes stake in graphene-enhanced concrete venture

New concrete additive Concretene™ promises 30% savings in CO2 emissions
18 hours ago

Winners revealed on £1.42bn materials framework

Thirteen builders merchants land places on huge procurement deal for social landlords
18 hours ago

Travelodge eyes plans for another 300 hotels

Hotel giant writes to local councils offering partnership deals with a £3bn investment target
18 hours ago

Balfour Beatty to invest £60m in pop-up EV chargers

New Urban Fox JV will roll out 35,000 charge points across the UK over the next decade.
2 days ago

Leading Channel Isles builder goes bust

Jersey-based construction firm Camerons placed in liquidation
17 hours ago

HS2 Euston needs full design reset as costs set to double

Spending watchdog warns Euston stop-start delay will simply inflate already ballooning costs
2 days ago

Worker dies on major warehouse site in Stafford

Main contractor Glencar halts work while tragedy is investigated
2 days ago

Sellar switches London flats/hotel plan for 444 student rooms

Southwark's King’s Place scheme will comprise five buildings of up to 11 storeys
2 days ago

Bid race starts for Norfolk £30m Long Stratton Bypass

Council hopes to start work on 3.9km bypass in April 2024
2 days ago

GMI to build first warehouse at £200m Teesside business park

Work to start early next month on first shed at airport business park
2 days ago

Skanska Costain Strabag JV sets up own rebar plant

HS2 team now running on-site manufacturing facility to avoid supply chain issues
2 days ago

Bid rigging: Keltbray to appeal and so could Squibb

Both contractors "disappointed" with level of fines
5 days ago

Ten demolition firms fined £60m for bid rigging

Full details of fines with Erith and Keltbray hardest hit
6 days ago

Retail contractor J M Scully files administration notice

£23m turnover Dorset based contractor lodges court notice
5 days ago

Civils specialist M Lambe delivers record performance

Housing civils specialist seeks to diversify in face of challenging housing market
5 days ago

Willmott Dixon clinches £60m Oxford Brookes University job

Preparation work starts on two new buildings at Headington Hill campus
5 days ago

Ferns seals £50m+ Openreach network services deal

Five-year south west deal to provide civils, poling and complex manhole programme
5 days ago

20 firms win £4.5bn Southern construction framework

A dozen new firms secure spots on fifth generation public sector deal
6 days ago

Call grows for bolder 18m second staircase rule for flats

Architects, surveyors and builders professional trade bodies demand lower height threshold than proposed 30m
6 days ago

GRS Roadstone warns staff following cyber attack

Materials giant sends out letters highlighting the extent of the attack
6 days ago

Inland Homes to suspend shares as results delayed again

Auditors need more time to go through embattled house builder's books
6 days ago

Kier wins £73m Southport events centre job

Local supply chain set to benefit from major new project
6 days ago

Multiplex profit rebounds as margin restored to 2.9%

London tower builder predicts return to revenue growth this year as major schemes advance
6 days ago

Upbeat Vistry to re-open mothballed offsite factory

Former Countryside timber panel factories rebranded Vistry Works in revived drive to deliver 5,000 units a year
7 days ago

Builder crushed and blinded in wall collapse

Property owner in court after barn conversion goes horribly wrong
6 days ago

Keltbray bags £140m haul of energy infrastructure work

Specialist secures trio of power frameworks, two battery storage facilities and an energy from waste package
7 days ago

Government awards £1.8bn for energy retrofit schemes – list

Housing and public building decarbonising funds awards to support 20,000 construction jobs
7 days ago

Landmark London scheme switches from flats to student rooms

Regal London rethinks Old Kent Road scheme with 900 student rooms and 220 affordable homes
7 days ago

Contractor services