Fresh legal action over axed housing targets

Aaron Morby 16 years ago
Share

Communities secretary Eric Pickles faces two more legal challenges from developers over his controversial decision to scrap regional housing targets.

House builder Catesby Property Group has taken on top legal firm Eversheds to challenge Pickles’ decision to refuse planning permission for a £50m development of 400 homes in Bude, Cornwall.

At the same time, developer Colonnade Land is also taking legal action over a decision to block 326 homes at Rochford in Essex.

Earlier this year Cala Homes led the legal fight back and is due to have its case heard in the High Court on 22 October.

Pickles abolished regional spatial strategies in July, which set out house building targets, arguing the Government was returning planning powers to local communities.

Since then councils have turned down countless planning applications to build homes.

Last week a survey by the National Housing Federation found that since the move by Pickles, 1,300 planned homes have been scrapped everyday.

The NHF predicts local authorities could eventually ditch up to 300,000 planned homes across the country

The crisis has prompted the house builders to challenge Pickles on several fronts.

Cala Homes and Colonade Land claim that Pickles acted unlawfully because scrapping the strategies required primary legislation and transitional arrangements should have been put in place before the announcement.

The challenge from Catesby Property Group takes a different tack.

Its green field site – which was to contain 30% affordable homes – was recommended for approval by the planning inspector at appeal.

But Pickles rejected the findings of the planning inspector when the decision to revoke regional spatial strategies was made.

Catesby will argue that the Secretary of State acted unlawfully by failing to notify them of this departure from the inspector’s recommendations and by not providing the opportunity to present evidence at a re-opened Inquiry.

Stuart Andrews, head of planning at Eversheds, said: “Catesby have been left with no other choice than to challenge this decision in response to a complete failure by the Secretary of State to afford the opportunity for a fair hearing and, more particularly, the opportunity to present evidence as to housing need.”

A Communities and Local Government Department spokesperson said: “It would be inappropriate for the government to comment on any legal proceedings.”

Councils that have reduced housing plans

  • Milton Keynes Central – by 13,360 homes
  • Luton/Central Bedfordshire – 10,650 homes
  • Horsham District Council – 6,888 homes
  • Exeter City Council – 3,000 homes
  • Bristol City Council – 9,560 homes
  • Torbay Council – 5,000 homes
  • Cotswold District Council – 900 homes
  • North Somerset Council – 10,750 homes
  • North Hertfordshire Council and Stevenage Borough Council – have suspended plans for 9,200 homes.

Councils that intend to reduce their targets

  • Ashford Borough Council
  • Northampton Borough Council, Daventry District Council and South Northamptonshire Council (with regard to the West Northamptonshire Growth Area)
  • Leeds City Council
  • Aylesbury Vale

Latest news

Graham lands University of Bath 960-bed campus job

Firm starts design and pre-construction work on Claverton Down student housing scheme
1 day ago

Kier lands £70m Sizewell C gateway civils job

June start lined up for North Plaza 15ha logistics and security hub
2 days ago

Plans in for Hull 850-home East Bank docklands revival

Council and ECF hybrid application sets out 15-year regeneration vision
1 day ago

Keller hires former Aarsleff boss to run foundations arm

Andy Waghorn joins world's largest geotechnical contractor
1 day ago

Worker crushed by one tonne concrete block

Haulage firm fined after horror accident
1 day ago

GMI seals £40m deal for Tiger Developments

Construction starts on latest Manchester student scheme
2 days ago

Contractors hold bid discipline as public work keeps jobs flowing

Gleeds survey shows 85% of contractors declining tenders
2 days ago

Morgan Sindall upgrades 2026 outlook as profits surge

Fit-out boom and construction margin gains drive upgraded guidance
2 days ago

New housing lifts construction output in February

1% monthly rise fails to shift ongoing workload three-month decline
2 days ago

Coventry airport £2.5bn gigafactory zone cleared for take-off

GreenPower Park wins detailed consent for 4.8m sq ft manufacturing hub
2 days ago

McLaughlin & Harvey seals £45m Dumfries flood job after cost surge

43-month Whitesands price rises by £8m from ECI into construction
2 days ago

Skanska builds pipeline with 43% order surge to £1.36bn

New wins across building and infrastructure reshape outlook after flat 2025
3 days ago

Lack of site hot water lands contractor in court

Workers also had nowhere to rest on Telford site
3 days ago

Lindum hands staff £2m windfall from profits

Employee-owned builder shares profits as workforce pockets double payout
3 days ago

London fit out boom sees profits surge at BW

Profits up 132% as contractor targets £500m turnover by 2030
3 days ago

Vistry agrees deal for next 1,000 homes at Northstowe

Contract with Homes England for next phase of new community
4 days ago

Barratt Redrow shrugs off Middle East turmoil to hold profit forecast

Strong forward sales and tighter land spend keep house builder on track
3 days ago

Robertson bags starring role on £16m Ashington cinema job

Portland Park scheme to anchor wider £36m town centre regeneration
3 days ago

Willmott Dixon lands £61m Merseyside school rebuild

Mosslands secondary school deal lifts firm's school tally to £700m
4 days ago

East West Rail reset plan to speed up construction

Delivery plan switches from sequential build to parallel construction packages
4 days ago

Muse installs national ops chief to deliver £6.3bn pipeline

North West boss steps up as firm shifts focus from pipeline to construction
4 days ago

MCS Group lands £22m Walsall warehouse deal

Speculative scheme to start in May
4 days ago

Avove hits 6.9% margin as growth streak continues

Utility contractor profit hits £17m in 4th year of growth
4 days ago

Apex lands £15m Medway Council HQ overhaul job

Council presses ahead with HQ rescue after RAAC shut sections
4 days ago

Network Rail lines up £450m Scotland electrification deal

Single contractor sought to deliver OLE, power and design work across eight-year programme
4 days ago

Eurotunnel fined £2.25m after surveyor hit by lighting

115kg lighting carriage fell during winching operation
5 days ago

Willmott Dixon final sign-off on Forest of Dean leisure job

New builder gets start date after BAM exit from Five Acres community hub project
4 days ago

Bovis swings back to profit after Atlas takeover reset

£35m provision cover drives turnaround following carve-out from Lendlease
5 days ago

McAvoy go-ahead for £65m Bradford hospital overhaul

Modular specialist to start Lynfield Mount mental health hospital rebuild
5 days ago

Vistry promotes from within to succeed Greg Fitzgerald

Adam Daniels to lead house builder
5 days ago