UK civils costs are 4th highest in Europe

Aaron Morby 11 years ago

Civil engineering projects cost 20-25% more in the UK than schemes in countries like Ireland and France.

The initial research findings from the high-level probe into civil engineering by quango Infrastructure UK confirms big inefficiencies plague major civil engineering projects in this country.

The interim report also warns that the economic downturn risked a return to adversarial contracting because clients were fixed on a strong contractual to delivering major projects.

“This leads to perverse behaviour particularly in tough market conditions, where low prices achieved under competition may be increased at out-turn as a result of claims.”

The report also blames greater numbers of smaller contractors acting as main contractors compared to peers in Europe for a failure to develop appropriate skills in the civils industry.

So far the benchmarking study found only Nordic countries suffer from higher costs in Europe.

Now the review panel chaired by Arup’s Terry Hill will draw up a set of recommendations to cut outturn costs in a final report due at the end of the year.

These will see fresh measures aimed at increasing certainty of the investment pipeline, removing wasteful process and strengthening the capability of those involved in procurement and the supply chain.

The interim report said: “Whilst many of the factors identified by IUK have been recognised in previous studies, there has not been sufficient concerted effort by government and industry in the past to make the changes necessary to resolve them.

“The current fiscal environment and drive for efficiency provide an opportunity to ensure that, this time, the necessary actions will be taken.”

Reports on the costing of High Speed 2 and benchmarking studies conducted on roads scheme and metro systems unearthed further evidence of higher costs in the UK.

IUK said: “In some instances, higher relative capital costs in the UK can be attributed to greater intensity of use and enhanced design life of assets, together with geographical factors such as the UK’s greater density of population.

“However, these factors do not fully account for the differences in cost – the cost of labour, plant and raw material inputs, including public and private sector investments.”

Stop-start investment, the complex web of regulation, planning and standards compliance come in for heavy criticism, along with poor public sector commissioning and cost management.

IUK will now draw up a detailed action plan to deliver the identified cost saving benefits for UK infrastructure projects and renewals programmes.

Emerging measures for consideration

Increase certainty and continuity of pipeline for committed projects
  • Explore opportunities to extend investment programmes across regulatory review periods.
  • Enable other public sector and regulated commissioning bodies to commit to longer term programmes and set cost reduction targets.
  • Through alliancing and partnering agreements encourage greater investment by contractors in trade skills, innovation and supply chain development.
Create clearer distinctions between the roles of commissioner, client, funder, and delivery agents
  • Measures to implement effective leadership and governance so that key decisions vest through individuals or bodies capable of discharging their function as a ‘single controlling mind’.
  • Incentivise unified management of costs, risks and contingency between stakeholders.
Instil  greater discipline to commissioning
  • Encourage greater use of outcome based specification and the removal of unnecessary prescription of standards to encourage innovation.
  • Introduce greater objective challenge of the specification of requirements and budget costs.
  • Explore the benefits of separate management of contingency budgets outside of the promoter or delivery body, particularly on larger one-off infrastructure projects.
  • Improve the availability and transparency of asset condition and benchmark data, including cross-sector access to UK and international benchmarks.
  • Consider the opportunities to derive better value for money from a portfolio management approach to risk transfer, for example in contingency budgets, project insurance and cost indexation.
Develop smarter ways of using competition
  • Encourage the use of effective competition and procurement to realise cost savings through the whole supply chain and minimise wastage in the procurement process.
  • Develop mechanisms to encourage greater alignment of interest between contractors and clients in reducing costs.
  • Continue to encourage increased early contractor involvement.
  • Where appropriate, encourage further standardisation of contracts, including payment and incentive arrangements.
Reduce the direct costs of construction
  • Develop measures to improve productivity, for example through site project management, supervision and skills.
  • Encourage standardisation, the use of off-site fabrication and other means of improving efficiency.
  • Review the way in which standards and regulations are applied with a view to developing more efficient means of ensuring safe and high quality construction.
  • Support the development of better structured and incentivised partnering between supply chain providers.
  • Improve the standardisation and processes around change control under the current preferred standard forms for infrastructure and consider ways to avoid escalation of a ‘claims culture’.

Latest news

Work grinds to a halt on Midas sites

Client "increasingly concerned" over Devon hotel jobs as pay row hits Somerset site
16 hours ago

Kier launches recruitment drive for over 1,200 staff

Large-scale talent hunt starts for the next generation of construction skills
7 hours ago

Ex-PDR staff launch compensation claim

Former workers at failed contractor could get up to 90 days pay if successful
8 hours ago

McLaren submits plans for £85m Leeds build-to-rent tower

Work expected to start this summer on latest city scheme
8 hours ago

Skills and material crisis hitting London housing delivery

Mayor calls for new visa system and extra funding to get affordable house building back on track
7 hours ago

Plan for £140m north London college campus

United Colleges Group reveal detail of Wembley campus plan
1 day ago

Overbury gets green light for £300m Citi Tower refurb

Revamp of 42-storey Canary Wharf tower will be one of London's biggest ever refurb jobs
1 day ago

McAleer & Rushe confirms £23m Manchester hotel job

Work to start on 17 storey Maldron hotel next month
1 day ago

£130m cash injection kick-starts first Wirral Waters resi blocks

Wirral Waters One 600-home project secures funding
1 day ago

Government commits £100m to Sizewell C nuclear project

Government’s cash injection hoped to ‘maximise investor confidence’ while EDF courts private investors
1 day ago

Public raise alarm over unsafe roof work high above Manchester

Court hears how HSE swooped to shut down site after tip off
2 days ago

Realstar and Lendlease ink £120m London build to rent deal

Forward funding deal for 251 private rental flats at Deptford Landings scheme
1 day ago

Balfour Beatty chalks up 100th Scape civils job

Procurement body prepares to invite bids next month for next generation net zero civils framework
1 day ago

Forterra hikes brick prices by 10%+ with more rises to come

Demand continues to surge and costs increase for masonry products giant
2 days ago

Go-ahead for £40m Manchester spec office scheme

Local firm PP O'Connor to demolish Speakers House for 17-storey office block
2 days ago

Spanish giant lands deal to build £683m waste power plant

New plant will turn black bin bag waste into electricity
3 days ago

Henry wins six Ealing council housing projects

Henry Construction secures £40m West London council homes deal
2 days ago

Landsec eyes £825m Glasgow Buchanan Galleries rebuild

Glasgow's mammoth shopping mall could be demolished for mixed-use city quarter
3 days ago

Mace lands £300m London court and police complex

Main construction works to start on Fleet Street site this autumn
3 days ago

Graham bags £30m Birmingham build to rent job

Work set to start Crown Works residential scheme in the Colmore Business District
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty names new investment arm chief

Leo Quinn promotes former major projects finance director Gavin Russell
3 days ago

M1 fraud probe exposes contract management problems

M1 J13-16 investigation finds £320,000 of central barrier scrap metal went missing
3 days ago

Beaumont Morgan Developments goes into administration

Begbies Traynor now in charge of £47m turnover Manchester contractor
3 days ago

Green light for major overhaul of Surrey pharma campus

Kier and Mace bidding for revamp project with three storey glulam building at its heart
3 days ago

Morgan Sindall hires Crossrail safety director

Carole Bardell-Wise joins infrastructure business as SHEQ Director.
3 days ago

Galliford Try bags £28m Dover inland border control facility

Major inland border facility to be built alongside the A2 outside of Dover
3 days ago

Plans go in for £280m Leeds Whitehall Riverside scheme

Major office and flats scheme to be built next to River Aire
3 days ago

Roofer dies in six metre plunge through asbestos sheets

Court hears no safety nets were fitted on site
4 days ago

Subbies stop working for Beaumont Morgan Developments

Manchester based contractor was delivering Fortis Quay for associate development company
4 days ago

Gove threatens ban on cladding suppliers failing to pay for retrofits

Cladding and insulation suppliers now in firing line for cash for £9bn post-Grenfell remediation bill
5 days ago

Contractor services