Pickles’ decision to scrap housing targets illegal

Aaron Morby 15 years ago
Share

Communities Secretary Eric Pickles has lost a High Court battle with Cala Homes over scrapping regional housing targets.

The High Court found that the secretary of state for Communities and Local Government acted unlawfully in unilaterally scrapping the regional planning system in July.

Today’s judgment effectively reinstates planning policies and housing targets until the Localism Bill becomes law, which is expected by the end of 2011.

Other house builders have launched similar legal action after seeing their schemes refused planning.

House builder Catesby Property Group took on top legal firm Eversheds to challenge Pickles’ decision to refuse planning permission for a £50m scheme of 400-homes in Bude, Cornwall.

Developer Colonnade Land is also taking legal action over a decision to block 326 homes at Rochford in Essex.

Pickles had said he wanted to return planning powers to local communities. An aide said that no appeal was planned.

At the earlier court hearing Peter Village QC, appearing for Cala Homes (South), told the judge Pickles was seeking to revoke regional strategies through an executive decision.

Village argued primary legislation should have been introduced, giving Parliament the opportunity to debate an issue crucial to future planning in England.

Pickles’ decision “struck at the heart of parliamentary democracy”, he said.

Communities and Local Government minister Bob Neill said the judgment changed little.

“The Government remains firmly resolved to scrap this layer of confusing red tape. Instead, we will work with local communities to build more homes.

“This was a commitment made in the coalition agreement and in the general election manifestos of both coalition parties. We intend to deliver on it.”

Andrew Whitaker, Planning Director of the Home Builders Federation said: “HBF and the industry remain keen to work with government to ensure that changes to the planning system are introduced in a clear and methodical way.

“Everyone involved in the delivery of housing, both private and public sectors, has been struggling with the policy vacuum caused by the revocation of Regional Strategies.

“Today’s judgment allows the Government to put in place a clear transition to get from the old system to the proposed localism based one, ” he added.

“This will avoid throwing away the many years of planning for future housing delivery in which many people, including local communities, have invested their time and money.”

Latest news

Tower crane drivers set to strike

SItes could stop amid pay row with Wolffkran
1 hour ago

Winvic wins £340m M&S mega shed at DIRFT

Low-carbon Midlands 1.3m sq ft twin sheds set to anchor food growth plans
22 hours ago

Father-of-six dies in demolition site tragedy

Fatal accident while demolishing flats in Renfrewshire
18 hours ago

Persimmon builds momentum with 12% jump in completions

House builder warns there will be no material uplift in market this year
1 hour ago

Henry Boot seals planning for Goole 5.5m sq ft freeport

HBD partnership targets start on site this year for £130m first phase
2 hours ago

FP McCann buys roofing products firm Easy-Trim

Concrete specialist acquires firm out of administration
2 hours ago

Trade body BESA boots out five more firms in standards purge

Building engineering services body chief says race to the bottom is over
9 hours ago

Bidders day set for £4.5bn Southern Construction Framework

Around 20 contractors brace for fight to retain places on sixth-generation mega deal
1 day ago

Facade specialist Permasteelisa (UK) hit by third year of losses

Legacy projects, and fixed-price contract pressures continued to bite
1 day ago

“Future of construction” firm in administration

Versarien fails to strike a solvent sale for business
4 days ago

British Land CEO to join warehouse developer

Simon Carter to leave after five years at the helm
1 day ago

Paddington life sciences tower moves into planning

16-storey hub planned beside St Mary's Hospital in London
1 day ago

Balfour secures £900m Midlands highways upkeep deal

Firm beats rival M Group and Ringway bids for new combined council deal
4 days ago

Skanska slides 4,200 tonne railway bridge into place

Watch time-lapse video of major civil engineering feat
1 day ago

Student rooms builder cancels London and defers Bristol projects

Unite cans £147m Paddington scheme but pledges £100m share buyback
4 days ago

Mace crowned annual contracts league champion

Hoard of big wins in the capital secures 2025 title for most work won
4 days ago

Offsite specialist Merit went down owing suppliers £17m

Assets bought by firm newly formed by former directors
5 days ago

Leeds United set to kick off stadium expansion this summer

New West and North stands to deliver 53,000-capacity ground
5 days ago

Bovis hires Sisk healthcare chief to scale up NHS work

Nadeem Chaudhry joins as UK head of health
5 days ago

Muse picked to steer 10,000-home Bristol Temple Quarter plan

Major housing and commercial build-out planned for 135-acre station neighbourhood
5 days ago

Paul Bentley joins Mott MacDonald executive board

JN Bentley director steps up after driving water work growth
5 days ago

£300m Wales indoor ski resort clears final planning hurdle

UK’s longest indoor ski run heading for Merthyr
5 days ago

Former Carillion finance directors fined £371,700

Richard Adam and Zafar Khan accept fines for misleading statements in run-up to collapse
6 days ago

Andrew Scott forecasts record-breaking year ahead

Order book strength underpins £120m revenue forecast
5 days ago

£80m London housing scheme unlocked after flip to 100% social

Extra grant funding pushes 228-home Bromley Blenheim Centre scheme over the line
5 days ago

Construction buyers see better times ahead

Business activity hopes hit five-month high
6 days ago

Collapsing wall knocks labourer down stairwell

Contractor fined £60,000 after injured worker faced a month in hospital
6 days ago

McAlpine tipped for £150m West End office revamp

Funding deal paves way for start at 125 Shaftesbury Avenue
6 days ago

Site acquired in Chichester for new Premier Inn

Construction to start this Spring
6 days ago

Multiplex signs £250m London Wall construction contract

Main contract to start after year of enabling works by Erith
7 days ago