Civils probe finds £3bn annual waste on big projects

Aaron Morby 13 years ago

The high-level investigation into civil engineering on major projects in the UK has concluded costs could be slashed by around 15%.

This would equate to £2-£3bn out of the annual cost of building power, transport and water schemes, where an estimated £15bn to £20bn is spent each year.

Arup’s Terry Hill  produced the report for Infrastructure UK, as part of the Treasury’s drive to find out why major projects in this country cost as much as 25% more than the rest of Europe.

During the course of the investigation, Hill held more than 300 interviews with main contractors and organisations at home and abroad, including Balfour Beatty and Kier.

Ian Tyler, CEO of Balfour Beatty and a member of Hill’s steering group, said: “Many of these challenges are well known, but have not been tackled.

“There is now a real opportunity for Government and industry leaders to work together and find ways to reduce costs and stimulate economic growth for our industry and the UK.”

The review singles out six key areas where the Government and private sector contractors could extract big savings on future infrastructure spending.

Hill has called for fresh measures aimed at increasing certainty of the investment pipeline, removing wasteful process and strengthening the capability of those involved in procurement and the supply chain.

The report also says the industry and Government should work to better clarity the roles of different subcontractors so risk on projects is not being factored into to every bid price.


  • there is a lack of certainty over long-term workflow
  • the UK over-specifies and applies unnecessary standards
  • strategic investment is constrained because industry is fragmented
  • blurring of decision-making roles make governance inefficient
  • competitions are burdensome and stifle innovation
  • a lack of data limits capability to set challenging targets

Action needed to reduce costs

  • eliminating peaks and troughs in the infrastructure investment pipeline
  • improving client leadership, streamlining project governance and procurement
  • reducing unnecessary prescription, standards and third party requirements
  • improving asset management and benchmark data
  • developing smarter ways to use competition
  • encouraging industry to invest more in innovation and skills

Lord Sassoon, commercial secretary to the Treasury, said he had been surprised by how willing contractors had been to help the government reduce infrastructure spending.

The Government said it planned to implement the report’s findings by next year’s Budget.

A benchmarking study also confirmed that civil engineering projects cost 20-25% more in the UK than schemes in countries like Ireland and France. Only Nordic countries suffer from higher costs than the UK.

Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Danny Alexander said: “One look at projects like the Olympics, where over £600m has been saved, shows that the UK can deliver big infrastructure projects on time and within budget.

“We just have to make sure that the rest learn from the best. By working with industry we can identify ways to save money for them and the taxpayer.

He added: “The data gathered through IUK’s investigation has enabled us to identify savings of between £400m and £800m from the initial cost estimate for High Speed 2.”

    Steering Group

    Terry Hill (Chairperson) : Global Transport Market, Arup Humphrey
    Cadoux-Hudson: Managing Director Nuclear New Build, EDF
    Lucy Chadwick : Director of Rail and Road Projects, DfT
    Stephen Dance : Head of Public Sector Markets, Infrastructure UK
    Peter Hansford : President, Institution of Civil Engineers Phil Holland : Executive Vice President Projects, Shell
    Chris Newcome : Director, Anglian Water
    Paul Morrell : Chief Construction Adviser, BIS David Pitchford : Head of Major Projects, ERG
    Ian Tyler : Chief Executive Officer, Balfour Beatty

Latest project news

Galliford Try to upgrade Red Arrows base

Contractor seals quartet of RAF base upgrades
4 months ago

Galliford Try bags £87m Brent Cross build to rent job

Firm picks up another three blocks at Argent's North London £8bn regeneration scheme
5 months ago

Balfour starts £67m Edinburgh school campus

Passivhaus certified campus buildings will replace Liberton High School
6 months ago

Red wins Bristol retirement village £14m expansion

44 extra care flats to be built at former Frys chocolate factory
6 months ago

Caddick bags UK’s largest fertiliser plant job

Yorkshire contractor seals £28m contract for new plant in Yorkshire
6 months ago

Mace wins concrete bunkers for world’s most powerful laser

Firm will build two 7m tall bunkers with 2m thick radiation resistant concrete walls
7 months ago

Robertson to deliver £20m Alloa Wellbeing Hub and school

Design work will now start on Wellbeing Hub and Lochies primary school
6 months ago

Green light for Canada Water next phase of 380 homes

Zone G plan includes major resi tower, supermarket and park
7 months ago

Mace to start £230m Landsec London office job

Timber Square project will pioneer a hybrid cross laminate timber and steel superstructure
7 months ago

British Land multi-storey logistics hub approved

London urban last-mile logistics hub pipeline hits £1.3bn
7 months ago

£350m Birmingham triple tower scheme approved

Vast curving Ringway Centre to be demolished for 1,750 flats development
7 months ago

Midgard lands £245m Tottenham Hale towers

Three towers of up to 38 storeys complete north London regeneration scheme
7 months ago

Go-ahead for Wates £35m Hartlepool leisure centre job

Work on the Highlight waterfront centre to start in November
7 months ago

Green light for 690-home Birmingham Smithfield scheme

Prosperity Group plans to start work in Autumn next year on major Smithfield scheme
7 months ago

Go-ahead for 289 homes next to Saltaire World Heritage site

Ambitious plan to demolish a vacant Bradford office complex for new residential quarter
7 months ago

Plans in for 800-bed Leeds student and retail scheme

Major scheme will replace The Core shopping centre in the city
7 months ago

McAleer & Rushe awarded £60m Barking flats job

Work to start in November on near 200 rental homes project
7 months ago

ISG clinches £155m Cat D prison expansion

Firm to deliver 780 new places at three existing prison locations
7 months ago

27-storey Salford student tower approved

540-bed student block to be built on former site of McDonalds' regional HQ
7 months ago

Morgan Sindall £48m Dumfries school job approved

Building work to start before the end of 2023
7 months ago

Bouygues/Murphy JV tipped for £2.3bn Thames tunnel job

Frontrunner emerges for Lower Thames Crossing 4.2km tunnel job
7 months ago

Vinci/McAlpine JV to start £105m NHS rehabilitation centre

Treasury clears New Hospital Programme job to start main construction
7 months ago

Three giant lab buildings approved at £700m Oxford R&D district

Phase 2 Oxford North office and lab buildings to deliver 460,000 sq ft of space
7 months ago

RG Group to build tallest student block in the world

Contractor confirmed on 45-storey tower in Leeds
7 months ago

Vinci wins major St Helens town centre revamp

£90m first phase includes new market hall, 120-bed hotel and over 60 flats
7 months ago

Work to start this year on Manchester £250m spa resort

Developer Therme gets green light for re-engineered 28-acre Trafford complex
7 months ago

Barhale JV sign-off for £18m Dewsbury sewage works upgrade

Project forms part of Yorkshire Water’s £500m investment in Phosphorous removal
7 months ago

Murphy seals main build on £124m Essex station

Contractor lands main contract after successful start on enabling works package
7 months ago

GMI lands latest £42m phase of lab cluster

Citylabs life sciences complex in Manchester continues to grow
7 months ago

Green light for Canada Water commercial scheme

Twin-tower scheme will offer "a new type of office for London"
7 months ago

Contractor services