Council in court after “too thin” wall kills toddler

Grant Prior 15 years ago
Share

A north London council “failed in its duty” to maintain a wall which killed a toddler when it collapsed in high winds in January 2007, a court has heard.

Two-year-old Saurav Ghai was crushed as he and his childminder walked along Southampton Road in Gospel Oak.

Camden Council admitted two breaches of health and safety legislation but argued it was a subcontractor’s duty to ensure the wall was maintained.

The BBC reported that Southwark Crown Court was told the wall was too thin for its height.

A trial of issue has begun at the court in south-east London.

The council initially pleaded not guilty to failing to discharge a health and safety duty, contravening two sections of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, but changed its plea to guilty in October.

The contentious point was the extent of its breach of the law, prosecutor James Ageros said.

“It appears that the fact the wall was not built in accordance with good practice is agreed,” he told the court.

“The issue is whether Camden Council was at fault for not realising the wall was built badly in the first place.”

He said it was “unsatisfactory and unsafe” and “a risk to passers-by”.

Dominic Key, defending the council, said the wall was built in the 1970s and repaired in 1997.

It was accepted that the wall was “too thin for its height”, he added.

A former building surveyor for the council, Patrick Campbell, said the wall could have been cracked by sledgehammers or vehicles.

But while there was no reason to think it was unsafe, he said it was half as thick as a wall of that height would normally be.

In a statement, a council spokeswoman said: “Our deepest sympathy remains with Saurav’s family, and we offer our condolences to all those affected.”

The trial continues.

Latest news

HS2 chief pushes major project reset back to end of 2026

Wild says project overhaul must be “robust” as slower trains option explored
5 hours ago

Winvic tops April contracts league after shed hub win

Orders secured by top 50 firms fall by nearly 20% compared to prior month
12 hours ago

Briggs & Forrester banks £511m record pipeline after stronger year

Leaner Briggs & Forrester boosts profit and cash generation
5 hours ago

Henry Boot chief prepares exit after strategic overhaul

Tim Roberts to leave later this year as successor named from inside business
5 hours ago

1m sq ft Northumberland industrial park approved

Logistics park revival gains momentum with giant Northumbrland scheme
4 hours ago

Construction buyers report rampant cost inflation

Input costs rise at fastest rate for nearly four years
1 day ago

Caddick taps B&K veteran to spearhead East Midlands drive

Paul Sykes joins as Caddick eyes £1bn Midlands pipeline
1 day ago

Balfour Beatty powers ahead on energy and defence boom

Contractor says 15 major transmission schemes to start construction within next 18 months
1 day ago

HG targets £500m turnover after Gateway 2 approval surge

Profit jumps 56% as contractor powers through BSR bottlenecks
1 day ago

Go-ahead for another giant data centre at Redhill

New owners of Surrey site to spend another £200m on expansion plans
1 day ago

Port of Dover picks 14 firms for civils and marine works

Conway, Jackson and Knights Brown land Dover £80m framework spots
1 day ago

Caddick looking for subcontractors across the North East

Meet the Buyer event to highlight work opportunities: Register now
2 days ago

Reds10 brings steel fabrication in-house

Modular contractor invests in ESL Fabrication Engineers
2 days ago

Gridlock eases as 12,000 Gateway 2 flats approved in 12-weeks

Complex high-rise building safety approvals gather pace after months of delays
2 days ago

£1bn data centre gets green light in west London

Park Royal 72MW liquid-cooled scheme set for 2026 start
3 days ago

Contractors gear up for NHS SBS £750m framework rebid

Bidders invited to June briefing ahead of formal tender launch this autumn
2 days ago

Taxes, green rules and inflation slap £76,000 onto new home cost

Whitehall policy pile-on spreads viability crunch across swathes of England
2 days ago

Kier hires water sector commercial chief from Costain

Craig Message leaves Costain after 15 years to joins Kier Infrastructure
2 days ago

Tilbury Douglas lifts revenue to £600m

Profit rises as firm finds sweet spot in mid-value public projects
3 days ago

Lighting tower hits power line on road maintenance job

CCTV captures accident which left worker in hospital for five weeks
3 days ago

Vinci acquires developer ION

Merger with VINCI UK Developments will focus on local authority urban regeneration schemes
3 days ago

Recession fears deepen as building faces sharp decline

Forecasters warn Gulf-driven cost shock to drive 2.6% fall into workload in 2026
3 days ago

Bathroom pod maker OEP files administration notice

Modular specialist lodges court papers five years after buying sister firm in pre-pack deal
3 days ago

Sisk bridges the gap at York Central over Bank Holiday

Installation of seven 86m-long bridge beams complete engineering milestone
3 days ago

Birmingham lines up £400m highways design team

Atkins, Jacobs, Mott MacDonald and Pell Frischmann land eight-year roles
3 days ago

T&T appoints former Royal Mail chief in AI drive

Emma Gilthorpe joins consultant in new role as Chief Transformation Officer
3 days ago

Subcontractors wanted across Scotland

Marketplace Live event in Glasgow this month
3 days ago

Government blinks on steel tariffs after contractor backlash

Steel tariff rethink on table as industry warns of cost spikes and delivery delays
1 week ago

Gleeson Homes finds £5m+ of faults on legacy jobs

Infrastructure problems on Yorkshire sites as region restructured
1 week ago

McAlpine nudges margins higher as strategy reset pays-off

Profit climbs to £16m as sharpened sector focus beds in
1 week ago