£1bn potentially wasted on M25 widening

Aaron Morby 12 years ago
Share

Spending watchdog MPs have slammed the Highways Agency for mishandling the massive M25 widening project.

Public accounts committee MPs believe poor cost estimates and serious delays to plans to widen two stretches of Britain’s busiest motorway may have potentially cost taxpayers an extra £1bn.

Errors in calculations on cost estimates ruled out hard shoulder running as an option at an early stage while financing costs soared by £600m during the nine years it took to sign a deal with contractors.

The agency said the project to widen 35km between junction 16 and junction 23 of the M25, in Buckinghamshire, Hertfordshire and Essex was progressing on time and under budget.

But the agency’s cost estimates for a 30-year, £3.4bn private finance contract for widening the M25 were “poor”, the committee said.

Committee chairman Margaret Hodge MP said: “The Highways Agency’s mishandling of the project to tackle congestion on the M25 could cost the taxpayer an extra £1bn.

“The agency should not have focused just on widening but also have given proper consideration to a much cheaper alternative, hard shoulder running.

“A private finance project intended to transfer risk to the private sector should not have restricted innovation by ruling out this alternative solution.

“The decision to stick with widening was also substantially influenced by a technical error in the agency’s cost estimates. Had the error not been made, HSR would have been shown to be the cheaper option.”

She added: “The costs of the widening project have also been driven up by the nine years it took to conduct the procurement process, from the first commissioning of consultants in 2000 to the signing of the private finance contract in May 2009.

“This delay exposed the project to the credit crisis, resulting in £660m of extra financing costs. And the advisers upon whom the agency spent an excessive £80 million would have benefited from the drawn-out procurement.”

Roads Minister Mike Penning said: “This Government is driven by the need to get value for money for taxpayers so I welcome this report. It is another example of Labour costing taxpayers dearly. I am determined to learn the lessons of the report and we will act on its recommendations.”

Highways Agency chief executive Graham Dalton said: “We note the conclusions reached by the Public Accounts Committee and will act on its recommendations.

“Meanwhile, widening of the M25 in Buckinghamshire, Hertfordshire and Essex is progressing to time and under budget and will be completed before the opening of the Olympic Games in summer 2012.”

Latest news

Materials giant CRH looks to sell contractor Farrans

More than 550 staff set to get new owner
5 hours ago

Ilke Homes pulls off £100m record-breaking fund raise

Largest-ever capital raise by a UK modular house builder to fund expansion
9 hours ago

Construction buyers fear for year ahead

"Construction companies now have a tightrope to walk in terms of being ready for recovery and cautious around investment"
8 hours ago

Gove calls for competition probe into house building

Levelling Up and Regeneration Bill 'strengthened' with new measures
11 hours ago

Schools get £500m for energy upgrades this winter

Extra cash found for better heating controls, insulation and energy efficient lighting
10 hours ago

1,000-home North London scheme approved

Developer Hill will start work in the Spring on South Tottenham site
11 hours ago

Bid race for £500m Suffolk construction framework

Construction and building services firms called up for East of England four year deal
10 hours ago

Mace employs robot dog to avoid slip and trips in tunnel

Robot working in dark and hazardous conditions under Heathrow Airport
11 hours ago

Administrator details confirmed at Southampton M&E firm

Begbies Traynor now in charge at Working Environments as suppliers face large losses
1 day ago

Former Galliard chief takes helm at Inland Homes

New CEO Don O'Sullivan sets out to return south east house builder to profitability
11 hours ago

Applicant numbers nosedive for construction vacancies

Recruitment market gets even more competitive - how the Enquirer can help
1 day ago

Industry veteran to head Henry Bros northern arm

Peter Commins, former Kier and Balfour Beatty northern chief, to spearhead growth drive
11 hours ago

Housing association shuts in-house modular factories

Swan closes loss-making steel frame and cross-laminate timber factories
1 day ago

350-homes approved around iconic London Tube station

Housing blocks to be built around Grade II-listed Hounslow West Tube station
1 day ago

Domis set for £195m Boddingtons Brewery scheme

Developer Salboy buys Manchester site to kickstart long-awaited 556 homes project
1 day ago

John Lewis £500m funding deal to build 1,000 rental homes

Deal to advance BTR flats at store sites in Bromley, West Ealing and Reading
2 days ago

Esh launches new housing retrofit division

Esh Retrofit Solutions will target market to improve the energy performance of social rented homes
1 day ago

Eric Wright wins tricky £52m Liverpool transformation

Contractor working with engineers at Ridge and Partners on "challenging" Stanley Lock Flight site
4 days ago

Investment giant buys Bristol M&E contractor

RDCP Infrastructure acquires Avon Combined Electrical Services
4 days ago

Demolition start for £50m Farnworth town centre rebuild

Caddick Construction is tipped for main works due to start in the spring
4 days ago

L&G Modular strikes deal to build 1,000 affordable homes

Modular homes business teams up with Hampshire's Vivid housing association
4 days ago

Former Erith operations director joins John F Hunt

Scott Exell named new operations director at demolition specialist John F Hunt
5 days ago

Green light for £135m Leeds twin tower resi scheme

Construction to start in New Year on 500 build-to-rent apartments
5 days ago

Mace hits 1m tonnes carbon saving target for clients

Present work pipeline betters 2026 carbon emission saving target
5 days ago

Plans in for £40m surf park at former Kent colliery

Seahive surf lagoon and health resort will be built near Deal
5 days ago

Crushed demolition worker vows to return to industry

Shannon Brasier hoping to return to construction following horror accident
5 days ago

Mount Anvil to start 900-home North London estate rebuild

Planning approval paves way for Barnsbury Estate rebuild in Islington
5 days ago

Green light for major laboratory campus in Cambridge

Developer BioMed to tender first building on 600,000 sq ft lab complex in the New Year
5 days ago

Belfast firm signs the biggest work deal yet under Project Gigabit

Fibrus to hook-up rural Cumbria to lightning-fast broadband under £108m deal
5 days ago

McLaren wins Leeds logistics park contract

Work to start imminently on warehouse complex for Firethorn Trust
6 days ago

Contractor services