Worker brain damaged by scaffold pole plumb line

Grant Prior 14 years ago
Share

Two contractors are facing huge fines after a worker was left with severe brain injuries after being hit with a scaffold pole being used as makeshift plumb line.

Richard Chodkiewicz, 53, now needs 24-hour care for the rest of his life after the pole fell 15 storeys down a lift shaft and hit him in the head in July 2008 at the Radisson Blu hotel site in Bristol.

Bristol Magistrates’ Court heard that the 7lb pole was being used to measure the shaft when a line holding it – made of either plastic or piano wire – broke and it fell to the shaft pit.

Chodkiewicz, who was wearing a hard hat at the time, suffered a “catastrophic brain injury” that required part of his skull to be removed.

The Bristol Evening Post said he spent six weeks in intensive care and was then transferred to a brain injury rehabilitation unit.

Prosecuting on behalf of the health and safety executive, Dale Collins said the accident had completely changed the lives of Chodkiewicz and his family, who are receiving counselling.

He said: “This has had a devastating effect on Mr Chodkiewicz and also his five children and grandchildren. He now requires 24-hour care and is unable to work.”

Reading a statement from his family, Collins said: “Richard can’t be left alone because he is always at risk, and he needs help with all aspects of daily living. Richard is very childlike in his abilities and needs prompting for all basic skills.”

Yesterday Hoistway Limited, Mr Chodkiewicz’s employer, pleaded guilty to failing to ensure the health and safety of an employee.

Main contractor Miller Construction also pleaded guilty to failing to ensure that a person was not exposed to risks while undertaking the installation of lifts.

Collins told magistrates that Hoistway had failed to provide adequate risk assessments and did not identify hazards; that using a piece of scaffolding was not standard equipment checked by a competent person and was improvised; that there was inadequate site management and supervision, and that there was inadequate protection against people or objects falling.

He said that Miller Construction had carried out insufficient risk assessments, had left openings unguarded and at risk of falling objects, and had not fully checked and failings in Hoistway Limited’s risk assessment.

Defending Hoistway Ben Compton said it “accepted unequivocally” failings in a duty to its employees.

He added: “The offence was not a deliberate breach of the law. It was not reckless, but careless.”

Simon Antrobus, for Miller, said the company’s role was of “overview and monitoring”, adding that its culpability in the case was “relatively low”.

Magistrates said the two companies had failed in their duties “to a significant degree” and ordered the pair be sentenced at Bristol Crown Court, saying that their own powers, to impose a maximum fine of £20,000, were insufficient to adequately punish the firms.

Latest news

Coroner in training call after scissor-lift tragedy

Practical rescue training needed after worker crushed to death
4 hours ago

Vinci Building and FM arms rack up big losses for second year

Inaugural consolidated accounts for all Vinci UK operations slip into the red
12 hours ago

Plan lodged for two Birmingham student towers

Sama plans nearly 2,000 student rooms in 48 and 41 floor buildings at Lancaster Circus
12 hours ago

Galliford Try delays annual results announcement

Accountants want more time to go through books
12 hours ago

CITB urged to give everyone a say over need for levy

Consensus process slammed as a "charade"
13 hours ago

Subcontractors wanted across north London

Constructionline event to highlight work opportunities: Register now
13 hours ago

Latest construction hotspots appear outside London

Research reveals fastest growing areas for contract awards
13 hours ago

Bachy Soletanche rejigs business in new growth plan

Business split into two regional and a major projects division
15 hours ago

BAM, Arup and Amey win £2bn Network Rail contract

Largest single contract by value ever awarded by Network Rail.
4 days ago

Luton airport £2.4bn expansion decision delayed

Application decision deadline pushed back 3 months to January 2025.
3 days ago

Plan in for 2m sq ft Hertfordshire data centre campus

Proposed £3.75bn construction project near M25 would sustain 500 jobs
4 days ago

Balfour Beatty wins £363m electricity grid upgrade job

Work to start next year on 29km Bramford to Twinstead high voltage project
4 days ago

Winchmore wins £10m brickwork package with Lovell

Specialist will lay nearly 1m bricks on Thamesmead job
4 days ago

Green light for £125m Camden student scheme

Work to start later this year on site next to iconic Roundhouse
4 days ago

Strong revenue and profit growth puts Kier on firm footing

Revenue recovers to £4bn again with profit ahead almost a third to £68m
5 days ago

Galliford Try steps-in to build £57m Banwell bypass

New contractor found after original winner Alun Griffiths walked-away from job
5 days ago

Hotel M&E specialist Gallant files administration notice

Gallant Building Services is working on hotel, flats and care home projects
5 days ago

Torsion to deliver £43m Leeds student scheme

Construction to start next month on latest project for joint venture
5 days ago

Go-ahead for London Barbican office to flats project

London developer Hub aims to create over 170 co-living homes
5 days ago

Traditional builders dominate £800m MMC framework

20 out of 22 places on modular housing deal go to local contractors
5 days ago

Dubai contractor sells 15% stake in Costain

ASGC sells stake for £38m after investing £25m in fund raise four years ago
5 days ago

Amazon to invest £8bn in hyperscale datacentres

Data centre sector heats up as cloud computing giant AWS unveils big expansion plans
6 days ago

Plan lodged for Square Mile’s fifth tallest tower

54-floor 99 Bishopsgate tower will provide 1 m sq ft of office space
5 days ago

Morgan Sindall pulls off contracts league double

Firm swoops to top monthly and 12-month contracts league rankings
6 days ago

Hadden Construction goes into administration

66 jobs lost at £30m turnover Perthshire contractor
6 days ago

McAleer & Rushe wants to meet subcontractors across Scotland

Register now for Meet the Buyer event: Full list of suppliers wanted
6 days ago

Construction output slide in July ends two-month growth spurt

Recovery stutters along as construction activity dips 0.4%
6 days ago

Laing O’Rourke finance chief to join plastic products firm

Rowan Baker to join Essentra in November
6 days ago

Tight cost control returns Laing O’Rourke to profit

Group margin back to 1.9% as orders swell to record £10.8bn
7 days ago

Kier to noise-proof 20,000 homes around Heathrow

Eight-year programme will involve new windows, doors, loft insulation and upgrade ceilings
7 days ago

Contractor services