Fury at low fines in Liverpool crane death case

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

A crane driver and hire firm Bryn Thomas have been fined a total of £7,000 after an overloaded crane toppled and crushed a worker in Liverpool.

Supervisor Mark Thornton, 46, was killed when a six-tonne steel column hit him on a Liverpool building site four years ago.

Thornton was guiding a steel column with a rope when the jibbed Demag AC 150 telescopic mobile crane buckled and toppled over.

The steel beam struck Thornton on the head and shoulders killing him instantly.

The crane driver, crane hire firm and construction firm that employed Thornton were all prosecuted by the Health and Safety Executive.

North Wales mobile specialist Bryn Thomas Crane Hire admitted health and safety breaches for failing to ensure that its equipment was in good working order.

Liverpool Crown Court fined the firm £4,500 – a fine ‘significantly reduced’ because the company is in administration.

Judge Nigel Gilmour, QC, said he was unable to impose an appropriate fine of £300,000 on Bryn Thomas Crane Hire because it had now gone into administration with massive debts.

The mobile crane hirer was placed into administration earlier this year, although its assets were bought by a company trading as Bryn Thomas Cranes.

Merseyside crane operator Frederick Scott was fined £2,500 after he admitted to several health and safety breaches including failing to check the weight of the column and that a lift plan had been completed.

The driver, who had only three months experience, also admitted failing to check the crane’s overload alarm was audible and override switches were working, neither of which was the case.

Thornton’s employer and the third defendant Sitewell Construction is to be sentenced at a later date while its financial situation is examined by the court’s forensic accountants.

Thornton’s daughter Cheryl told the Liverpool Daily Post: “No justice was brought whatsoever. It could have been prevented and that is what makes it all the worse – it did not have to happen.

“These companies get a minimal fine and it is all over. It is not over for us. We have to live with this forever.”

Latest news

Keltbray bags brace of energy infrastructure wins

Civils work on huge converter stations worth £30m to specialist
39 mins ago

Safety blitz on “aches, pains and strains” on site

1,000 site visits planned in coming months to check how workers are moving heavy or bulky materials
2 hours ago

Balfour Beatty sole winner for £4bn Scape civils deals

Contractor reappointed to England, Wales and Northern Ireland and separate Scottish deals
8 hours ago

PR expert Baroness Rock to chair Costain

Kate Rock will take up senior board role at the end of the year
7 hours ago

Billington profit upgrade after strong first-half

Steelwork contractor says weaker pound will allow it to reignite its old export markets in Europe
8 hours ago

Green light for £120m Liverpool “super restaurant”

Historic Pumphouse at Stanley Dock to be transformed
1 day ago

Tolent bags £15m Sunderland skills academy

Work to start later this year on Housing Innovation and Construction Skills Academy
8 hours ago

Government launches net zero review

Pro-growth and pro-business review of net zero 2050 target launches
1 day ago

L&G Modular wins 400-home Wolverhampton job

Modular specialist wins 17-acre Canalside South regeneration scheme
1 day ago

£1.2bn A12 upgrade accepted for planning

15-mile Essex road upgrade between Chelmsford and Colchester aims for 2023/24 start
1 day ago

US consultant trumps WSP bid for RPS Group

Tetra Tech swoops but WSP could come back with new offer if bidding war breaks out
1 day ago

Sisk hands staff £900 cost of living cash boost

Firm also promises staff £400 Christmas voucher in November
1 day ago

Loathed IR35 reforms scrapped by Chancellor

Contractors will no longer have to determine tax status of freelance workers
4 days ago

Higgins signs deal for 740 West London homes

Work to start this autumn on two Hayes housing estate rebuilds
1 day ago

Kier wins Sefton net zero £36m school job

Deyes High School in Maghull will consist of 60 classrooms
1 day ago

Giant TBM cutterhead takes road trip to second drive

Balfour Beatty Vinci to drag remaining TBM back through tunnel for second bore
4 days ago

Fast-track 138-project growth plan – full list

Chancellor banks on road projects to lead growth plan recover
4 days ago

Kwarteng backs construction to lead “new era for Britain”

Planning rules to be ripped-up to speed infrastructure work as 38 new Investment Zones created
5 days ago

Green light for next two Manchester NOMA jobs

Work to start early next year on first of two major office buildings
4 days ago

Bouygues struggles to raise profitability

Loss-making contracts dent pre-tax profit at £835,000 from revenue up at £484m
4 days ago

Architect helps staff with £1,000 cost of living cash

P+HS Architects to make one-off payments this autumn
4 days ago

Sisk wins £69m rerouting of landslip-prone A59

Site clearance to start next month at Kex Gill in Yorkshire
5 days ago

Renewal race starts for £800m NEPO framework

Nearly 20 firms face fight to renew places on north east construction panel
4 days ago

Avonside supply chain left holding £17m in unpaid bills

Former bosses revealed as buyers of branches from administrators
5 days ago

Hexagonal tower plan for Manchester city centre site

Site will feature a 45 storey resi tower and 350,000 sq ft stepped office block
5 days ago

Keltbray staff get £1,000 cost of living payment

Contractor also plans annual pay rise of 5% for majority of employees
5 days ago

Eric Wright rebounds as profit nearly trebles

Second year of revenue fall brings profit reward
5 days ago

RSK buys Welsh contractor Spencer Group

RSK revenue forecast to hit £800m after busy year of acquisitions
5 days ago

National Highways director to lead Balfour civils business

Peter Mumford appointed Managing Director of UK Construction Regional Civils
6 days ago

Plan detailed for business energy price cap

Gas and electricity price cap comes into force from October
6 days ago

Contractor services