Councillors vote to keep building Edinburgh tram

Aaron Morby 14 years ago
Share

Edinburgh City councillors have voted to complete the troubled tram project as far as St Andrew Square.

The decision to build-on will cost £770m according to an independent consultants report, nearly 40% more than budgeted.

Now the council faces having to find £200m to bridge a huge funding gap just to get the first phase of the project, which is already three years behind schedule, finished.

City council officials have been given two months to produce detailed funding options to get the scheme up and running amid fears the council is facing a costly legal battle if it ends up pulling out of the project.

During a five-hour meeting, the full council considered a number of options, including scrapping the project.

On the table were choices to mothball the project and break the deal with contractor Bilfinger Berger at a cost of £750m.

The second option was to complete the original scheme in full but with no guarantee of the final bill. The third option was to press on regardless and complete the first phase of the disastrous project at a cost of £770m.

The consultant’s report said building to St Andrew’s looked the most favourable of the options available because it would earn £2m a year in profits when the tram became fully operational.

This option will also see Bilfinger Berger fullfil its pledge to fully fund the relaying of track in Princes Street, a section of the route beset with problems.

Eighty percent of the £545m budget has already been spent with huge sections still incomplete.

A long and bitter dispute between the tram company Tie and contractor Bilfinger Berger pushed the project over budget and behind schedule.

Conflicts have been blamed largely on utility companies failing to keep accurate records of underground pipes and a badly drafted original contract.

Mediation talks are understood to continuing after initial meetings between Tie and Bilfinger Berger were held in Glasgow in March.

Construction began in 2008 on the line which was due to run from Edinburgh airport through the city centre and eastwards to the old port of Newhaven.

Latest news

CITB cuts more training funds despite £95m cash pile

Training body imposes another round of sudden cuts on contractors
2 hours ago

Trapped load drags labourer over scaffolding

Two firms fined £800,000 for not planning work properly
22 minutes ago

Hampstead mega mansion to become super-prime apartments

Investor Bentry Capital to use in-house construction arm for three-year build programme
5 hours ago

DfE names 23 winners for £15bn schools framework refresh

Galliford Try and McLaren join major school delivery team for first time
8 hours ago

Employee-owned plant dealer Warwick Ward collapses

Case machinery dealer placed in administration with 89 jobs axed
8 hours ago

Tucker M&E went under owing suppliers £4.7m

Assets of £25m turnover company bought for £55,000 by former director
9 hours ago

Historic contractor sold to staff

Employee Ownership Trust deal at Emanuel Whittaker Ltd
8 hours ago

Jobless young people to get six-week construction course

Industry to benefit from latest employment initiative
8 hours ago

Reforms urged to unlock £262bn London office upgrade boom

Industry warns viability pressures are stopping critical upgrade projects
8 hours ago

Graham bags £45m Uni of East London campus build

Construction to start in early 2026 on new medical teaching hub in Stratford
9 hours ago

£700m Scottish super-hospital goes to ministers for final approval

Laing O'Rourke on track to start Monklands Replacement Hospital next year
3 days ago

Gateway 2 sign-off for landmark Stratford student tower

RG Group tipped to build 41-storey, 952-bed building
3 days ago

13 firms win £150m Lincolnshire roads race

County signs four-year deal for general works and resurfacing across A and B roads
3 days ago

£125m South London estate rebuild approved

278 homes to be delivered at New Cross Achilles Street Estate rebuild
3 days ago

Roofer verbally abused safety inspector

Court issues fine to Cornish roofer
3 days ago

Ravenscraig 200-acre site remediation gets go-ahead

Huge land remediation push will clear way for 2,000 future homes
3 days ago

Kori wins £30m London care home job

Main construction work to start next month in Highgate
3 days ago

Buyers report steepest output fall for five-and-half years

Budget uncertainty sends workloads plummeting across all sectors
4 days ago

Balfour Beatty powers up order book 20% to over £20bn

£3bn Sizewell C civils and power grid haul ends year on a high
4 days ago

Monster TBM hunt starts for Lower Thames Crossing

Motorway tunnel project cost soars to £11bn
5 days ago

Anglian Water to shift £1.5bn work to single Tier 1 partner

Bidding to open in New Year for single integrated partner in fresh drive for value for money
4 days ago

Builder ordered to pay back stolen plant and car money

Construction director faces jail if he can't repay £190,000
5 days ago

BAM gets green light for £140m Cardiff Central revamp

Spring 2026 start for major rebuild adding new entrances, bigger concourse and platform upgrades
4 days ago

Electrical apprentice falls through fragile roof

M&E contractor and surveyor fined after accident
4 days ago

Willmott Dixon tops contracts league after £136m Luton win

Contractors report softer pipeline as client caution drags down November totals
5 days ago

Civils firm files administration notice as part of restructure

E.J. Taylor & Sons lines-up pre-pack sale of £41m turnover contractor
6 days ago

Iconic London meat and fish markets line up Royal Docks move

Albert Island relocation unlocks Smithfield cultural hub and 4,000-home Billingsgate plan
5 days ago

Water orders flow as Kier nets £44m ECI haul

Southern Water signs off fresh batch of AMP8 waste water packages
5 days ago

£350m plan lodged for Leatherhead town centre revamp

Revamp plans 480 homes, new offices and a full Swan Centre rebuild
5 days ago

Tilbury Douglas appoints new fit-out MD

Jack Dixon joins from Structure Tone
6 days ago