Bilfinger hits back over Edinburgh tram debacle

Grant Prior 15 years ago
Share

Main contractor Bilfinger Berger has spoken out for the first time about the Edinburgh tramline row which brought work on the project to a standstill.

Bosses at the German contractor broke their silence after a gagging clause was lifted.

The £776m project is now two years behind schedule and 40% over budget.

Bilfinger Berger is leading the international consortium building the tramline.

Dr Jochen Keysberg, one of the company’s most senior executives, told BBC Scotland the dispute happened because of the way original client Transport Initiatives Edinburgh was interpreting the tram contract.

He said: “Maybe they were badly advised, maybe they just tried to pressure us in a certain position.

“This was frustrating, and if you have a completely different reading of the risk assessment in the contract, you cannot come together.”

Dr Keysberg also insisted that TIE had always been responsible for increases in the cost of the project caused by design changes and problems encountered during utility diversion work.

He claimed the Edinburgh project turned out to be unlike anything the company had experienced anywhere else in the world.

Bilfinger Berger has repeatedly clashed with TIE, the publicly-owned company set up to manage the project.

TIE has frequently criticised Bilfinger Berger, even describing the contractor as “delinquent”.

Edinburgh City Council has now scrapped TIE and work has restarted on key sections of the line.

The local authority’s transport convener has conceded he may not have had the skills needed to help oversee the project.

Councillor Gordon Mackenzie was one of four councillors on the board of TIE.

He said: “I have a social work background, others have electronics and banking management experience, that sort of thing.

“We were not people who had previously had experience of major projects like this.”

BBC Scotland Investigates: The Great Tram Disaster will be broadcast on BBC1 Scotland tonight at 2235.

Latest news

Formwork panel hits Hinkley worker after falling 29 metres

Improvement notices issued by nuclear regulator extended
6 hours ago

Focus on growing markets pays off for Balfour Beatty

Strong set of half-year results with momentum expected to continue for 2026
19 hours ago

Ardmore directors fight to save property firms with CVA plan

Seven firms seek CVA lifeline as Ardmore fights BLO ruling in Court of Appeal
20 hours ago

Investment giant acquires Phoenix ME

Deal set to accelerate growth strategy at M&E specialist
2 days ago

Structure Tone revenue almost triples to record £449m

London fit-out boom swells order book to £1.3bn
19 hours ago

Kier inks second Derwent London office scheme for £99m

Firm lands repeat business on flagship Oxford Street redevelopment
21 hours ago

Hill hires former Telford Homes boss

John Fitzgerald to oversee Eastern Residential and Western businesses
20 hours ago

Willmott Dixon kicks off Oldham town centre regen

Firm picked for £28m first phase of Prince's Gate for developer Muse
21 hours ago

VINCI UK profit jumps 51% after group overhaul

Highways, civils and FM Conway acquisition lift earnings as turnover approaches £3bn
2 days ago

Clancy Consulting administration move sheds historic liabilities

70 jobs safeguarded as core civil and structural engineering business survives
2 days ago

Multiplex gets start date for City Road 36-storey tower

Main construction to get underway this quarter
3 days ago

Bellway beats build target despite weaker buyer demand

CEO calls for Stamp Duty cuts and first-time buyer help to revive housing market
2 days ago

Trade credit insurer could cut cover for Vistry suppliers

Allianz Trade reportedly reduces credit limits as house builder battles to cut £470m net debt
3 days ago

Bricklayer breaks back after falling through roof

Contractor fined £20,000 for safety failures
2 days ago

M&E specialist ACES files administration notice

Avon Combined Electrical Services expanded into the capital last year to win larger jobs
3 days ago

Portsmouth picks ECF for 2,300-home city centre regeneration

Council finally advances ambitious City Centre North regen plan
3 days ago

Newcastle office block plan unveiled

12-storey scheme to be latest addition to One Founders Place
3 days ago

Eric Wright to start £65m Tebay-style M56 services

Yates starts groundworks on Cheshire motorway services
3 days ago

Plans in for retrofit of London Charing Cross office icon

Major retrofit plan keeps 90% of iconic 1990s office building
3 days ago

Higgins lands Brentford estate revamp

Construction to start this autumn on 182-home scheme
3 days ago

Kier bags biggest sewage treatment job yet

Firm signs ECI deal on £265m Thames Water AMP8 treatment works upgrade
6 days ago

Plan in for 53-storey Birmingham build to rent tower

42 High Street tower near the Bullring could be Birmingham's tallest building
6 days ago

HG seals hat-trick of Gateway 2 project approvals

Bristol, Manchester and London schemes will deliver 664 homes and student beds
6 days ago

Farrans to build new Stansted skylink walkways

Sections to be built "offsite" in vacant airport hangar
6 days ago

Ceiling specialist Zentia went down owing suppliers £5.6m

Unsecured creditors left holding worthless invoices
6 days ago

Mears secures £4.2bn pipeline after contract winning spree

Housing upkeep giant lands £1.4bn of work as Birmingham deal leads bumper order book
7 days ago

Construction buyers see first signs of a turnaround

July data shows construction market starting to stabilise
7 days ago

£90m bid race for iconic Foster museum revamp

UAE's Sainsbury Centre museum to get new envelope and low-carbon building services
7 days ago

Persimmon sharpens axe on costs as inflation threat grows

Builder targets procurement savings as inflation clouds outlook
7 days ago

Multiplex tops contracts league with £400m office job

July order haul among Top 50 contractors edges up 3.5% in July
7 days ago