Stewart Milne facing £1.7m payout to council

Grant Prior 11 years ago

Stewart Milne could have to write a cheque for £1.7m to Aberdeen City Council after losing an appeal yesterday over a long-running land dispute.

The Scotsman reported that Stewart Milne Group lost its appeal to the Supreme Court after Scottish judges had ordered the company to pay the money due to the council over the sale of a plot of land in Westhill.

The company is now hoping to work with the council to appoint an independent valuer to assess the cost of the land.

The row began in 2004 after the council sold an 11-acre site at Westhill to the company for £365,000 with the condition that it would receive a share of any profit Stewart Milne made by selling or leasing the land in the future.

An appeal hearing at the Court of Session in Edinburgh last year was told that the company sold the land to a linked company, Stewart Milne Westhill, for £483,020, and said there was no money in the deal for the city council because the sale cost the company £559,696.

After the sale in 2006, the council went to the Court of Session and argued the land was actually worth £5.6m.

Following a hearing in 2009, the building firm was ordered to pay £1.7m to the city council.

Stewart Milne appealed but the decision was upheld at the Court of Session last October.

And yesterday the Supreme Court upheld the Court of Session ruling, following an appeal by the company.

Glenn Allison, Group Managing Director, Stewart Milne Group said: “Stewart Milne Group accepts the ruling of the Supreme Court which has determined the criteria on which a land valuation can now be made by an independent expert.

“We should make it clear that the ruling of the Supreme Court is not and has never been about determining the value of the land.  It has determined the criteria on which such a valuation will be made.

“The often quoted figure of £1.7m is an assessment of that value by Aberdeen City Council and is based on an overstated assumption by Aberdeen City Council.

“We appointed external experts to review independently the value and on the basis of the criteria determined by the Supreme Court, their assessment of the value which will be due to be paid by Stewart Milne Group is substantially below £0.5m.

“We are keen to appoint in conjunction with Aberdeen City Council an independent expert external to both parties who can look at the full information and decide the value to be paid.

“We will be happy to abide by whatever valuation is decided by this independent expert.

“We have already offered this option on several occasions to the Council as a way to come to a resolution more speedily but they have always refused to engage with us in this way.  They have also refused every attempt we have made to resolve this disagreement.

“We have always had a good working relationship with the Council, built up over many years.

“It is important to us and despite this dispute we will continue to develop that relationship for the future.

“We now hope that the Council work with us speedily to go to an independent valuation so that we can bring this matter to a close.”

Latest news

RG Group wins £82m Leeds build to rent job

Work to start on developer Hub's 488-flat Latitude Blue scheme
14 hours ago

Speedy kit count finds £20m of missing equipment

Hire giant launches review after shortfall of small equipment
19 hours ago

Administrators appointed at concrete flooring specialist

Malin Industrial Concrete Floors has worked with a host of major contractors
2 days ago

Barratt sees early signs of a New Year trading uplift

Britain's biggest house builder reports strong first half but warns it is still too early to call depth of 2023 downturn
18 hours ago

Balfour launches new guide for inclusive behaviour

Right to Respect inclusivity initiative shows "where the boundaries are"
1 day ago

Concrete specialist Byrne Bros names new boss

Forty-year-old project director Philip Beausang promoted
19 hours ago

World’s first net zero cement production trial starts

Process combines scrap steel recycling in a the furnace with cement production
19 hours ago

VINCI to build new £100m Blackpool office scheme

Contractor to build new seven-storey regional hub for civil servants
1 day ago

Shapps to lead new Net Zero Government department

Business Energy and Industrial Strategy to split into three new Government departments
2 days ago

M&E firms readied for £545m Pagabo deal

New framework to meet demand for smarter buildings, particularly in healthcare and education
2 days ago

Mivan bags £100m haul of hotel and resi fit-out jobs

London hotel and prime residential orders put firm on track for £75m revenue this year
2 days ago

Graham hospital site hut complex destroyed by blaze

Site offices ravaged by fire which took eight hours to get under control
2 days ago

Mace wins £150m over-station job at Liverpool Street

Latest win from Aviva Investors and Allianz Real Estate following earlier Moorgate contract
3 days ago

Turner & Townsend and alinea join forces

110 alinea staff join T&T cost management team
2 days ago

Developer confidence high in big regional cities

Crane survey reveals Birmingham, Leeds and Manchester can count on resilient development pipelines
2 days ago

Caddick wins £21m Oldham off gas housing scheme

West Vale housing job forms part of £160m plan for 1,100 homes in Oldham
2 days ago

Buyers see brighter days ahead despite resi slump

"Construction can see a path through for better outcomes in 2023"
3 days ago

Australian firm to buy £300m gigaplant backer Britishvolt

New owner vows to complete giant factory in Northumberland
3 days ago

Project delays curb Ardmore growth ambitions

Refurb and housing specialist sees profit fall after challenging year of delays and supply chain failures
3 days ago

Scaffolders and sparks strike at antibiotic plant

Engineering construction workers down tools in bonus pay row
3 days ago

McAlpine bags £1bn Sellafield concrete structures deal

Contractor signs 17-year concrete structures and groundworks framework
3 days ago

Moving in to new markets paying off for McLaren

Contractor carving out new niche as leading player in heavy refurbs
5 days ago

Heavy materials sales fall amid slowdown in starts

Light side product sales grow helped by pace of activity for refurbs and energy-efficient retrofits
3 days ago

Plan to add retentions record to payment reporting law

Government consults on tougher reporting to include disputed invoices and retention policies
6 days ago

Morgan Sindall wins £88m Beckton DLR depot upgrade

Delayed work to start on Docklands Light Railway train maintenance depot in East London
6 days ago

Hare and Severfield win £250m Sellafield deal

Country's two biggest steelwork contractors secure 17-year framework
6 days ago

Max Steward returns to head up ISG’s Agility fit-out arm

Former ISG project director returns after three years to take up MD role
6 days ago

McLaren wins massive Portland House refurb

Construction to start this year on £380m revamp of 28-storey building in central London
7 days ago

Green light for £275m HS2 Midlands nerve centre

Trio of contractors battling it out to win huge new depot near Birmingham
6 days ago

Winners named for Government £10bn offsite framework

29 firms secure places on mega framework for schools, healthcare, defence and justice jobs
7 days ago

Contractor services