Opinion: Can we trust civil servants in bid races?

Grant Prior 14 years ago
Share

The West Coast main line franchise fiasco should be setting-off alarm bells among contractors.

The debacle calls into question the competence of the whole civil service after a cock-up at Whitehall cost the taxpayer at least £40m in refunded bid fees.

Knowing that the cost of several schools has been wasted because a Government official can’t operate a calcualtor is bad enough.

But the whole sorry episode now raises huge doubts over tender races at every level.

How many construction contracts have been awarded to the “wrong” winners?

And how can the Government lecture private contractors over efficiency when it is making such basic – and costly – mistakes?

Senior political figures are now demanding an overhaul of the civil service – but we’ve been down that route before.

If mandarins are good at one thing, it’s protecting their own backs .

Obviously there are thousands of very talented people working in public office.

But it is equally obvious that there are thousands who are not up to the job and seem protected from any sort of punishment when things go wrong.

The West Coast main line blunder has led to a few suspensions.

But will anyone be surprised if the guilty parties pitch-up at another department or retire early on a fat public pension?

The whole system is flawed because companies on the wrong end of mistakes find it nearly impossible to accuse their biggest client of bungling.

Private contractors are doing their bit to keep costs down in a world where the Government is trying to squeeze every penny out of the public purse.

The least the industry can expect in return is that Whitehall now gets its own house in order.

Latest news

Worker dies in fall on Mayfair site

Air ambulance arrives but worker pronounced dead at scene yesterday
3 hours ago

Seddon defies sluggish market with profit lift

Operating margin restored to 2.2% despite public sector scheme delays
3 hours ago

Green light for ‘poo powered’ eco homes scheme

Yorkshire Water seeks developer for pioneering wastewater powered community
3 hours ago

Speller Metcalfe posts record £5m profit as cash pile hits £32m

Midlands contractor lifts profits despite flat turnover with nearly all next year's workload booked
3 hours ago

Apprentice joiner crushed to death by falling boards

Company and director in court after renovation site tragedy
3 hours ago

Four firms land £300m Scottish electricity network deal

Quartet to upgrade network across north of Scotland
18 hours ago

Industry unites to warn new PM against more infrastructure cuts

Twenty eight leaders warn against damaging return to stop-start funding
1 day ago

Funding deal to kick-start Middlewood Locks tower phase

Scarborough JV targets early 2027 start on 909-home phase 4
1 day ago

Hampshire council seeks D&B firm for £100m housing job

Phase two set to start at country's largest council led housing scheme
1 day ago

Margins hit 4.8% as profits triple at Esh Group

Record year for North of England contractor
1 day ago

Labourer dies after scissor lift fall

Court hears falling wall panels knocked worker from machine during demolition work
1 day ago

MoD to split £6.6bn military homes maintenance mega deal

Procurement rethink aims to widen competition and boost SME opportunities
1 day ago

Vistry warns of first-half loss as daily net debt nears £800m

Finance chief to step down in October after new CEO completes strategic plan
2 days ago

Battersea job lifts Sisk to top of contracts league

Infrastructure work buoys top contractor order books in June
2 days ago

Council bosses blast ‘shoddy’ work by failed contractor

£3m of problems found on housing job hit by collapse of Westridge Construction
3 days ago

Capital&Centric lines up five Rotherham regeneration starts

Developer begins work on £100m plan for homes-led town centre revival
2 days ago

Higgins wins £47m school and flats scheme

New Hammersmith school funded by 91 flats next door
2 days ago

Balfour Beatty pumps £10m into venture capital tech fund

Contractor hopes to get on board early with construction innovators
3 days ago

Blue Sky floors tier one rivals in £176m Barbican revamp race

Boutique CM specialist beats Bovis, McAlpine and McLaren to landmark City arts job
3 days ago

HS2 workers left out of pocket after safety shutdown

Agency staff angry after going unpaid
3 days ago

140 homes and aquarium plan for Swansea Civic Centre

Urban Splash unveils retrofit plans for landmark Brutalist building
3 days ago

Graham names finance chief as next CEO after bumper year

Revenue climbs 16% as contractor enters new era with £261m cash pile
4 days ago

Green light for latest Winsford Gateway warehouse

Construction go-ahead for 225,000 sq ft logistics building
3 days ago

Buyers report sharpest fall in civils work for six years

Purchasing managers still in gloomy mood
4 days ago

McLaren employs robot army for site quality checks

Autonomous robots use AI to boost productivity, safety and quality
4 days ago

Morris & Spottiswood storms £230m turnover barrier

Fit-out and M&E specialist southward expansion fuels 46% profit rise
4 days ago

Final segment installed at problem HS2 green tunnel

Watch as last of 5,020 reinforced concrete segments goes in
4 days ago

Loan unlocks offices to student accommodation deal

Vacant Royal Albert Dock office complex to be transformed
4 days ago

Morganstone lands key role in Port Talbot steelworks revival

First main build package awarded at Tata's Project Invictus
4 days ago

Battle starts for places on £250m animal labs framework refresh

Market testing begins ahead of 2027 tender for Animal and Plant Health Agency
4 days ago