Legal contract rows soar and take longer to resolve

Aaron Morby 10 years ago
Share

Construction legal disputes have skyrocketed in average value and now take a third longer to resolve than they did in 2011.

According to an EC Harris study dispute values jumped from £6.6m in 2011 to £17.7m last year and now drag on four months longer than they did in 2011.

The firm said the sudden jump was likely to be been influenced by its team working on an unusually high number of disputes on major programmes of work.

Construction disputes now take on average 12.9 months to be settled compared to 8.7 months the year before.

The extended time it takes to resolve rows was put down to construction courts
now ordering mediation in the first instance in the majority of cases.

The most common cause of dispute was a failure to properly administer the contract.

    Top five causes of construction disputes

    1. Failure to properly administer the contract

    2. Failure to understand or comply with contractual obligations

    3. Employer imposed change

    4. Conflicting party interests

    5. Incomplete and/ or unsubstantiated claims

Taking the top five as a whole, disputes tend to be attributable to parties taking a less collaborative approach to projects than in other parts of the world.

For example, the employer imposing change and conflicting party interests feature highly.

One of the highest profile disputes last year involved the construction of the Shard in London. 

The dispute between steelwork companies Cleveland Bridge UK and Severfield-Rowen Structures first came to light in early 2010, but was only resolved in January 2013 following a lengthy dispute that ended up in the High Court.  

Cleveland Bridge was ultimately ordered to pay o £824,478 in damages to Severfield-Rowen for delays and defects which were estimated to cause a delay of 42 days on the Shard’s construction.

This year’s report Global Construction Disputes: A Longer Resolution also found greater joint venture working was leading to more disputes within project teams.

On the international stage, one in five disputes were driven by conflict within a joint venture team.

Gary Kitt, head of Contract Solutions, UK at EC Harris said: “Joint venture agreements are becoming more prevalent, particularly where a project is of such a large size and scale or there is a need because of licensing requirements for a local JV Partner.

“These JVs are causing a significant number of cases, so more needs to be done in order to ensure that the JV itself does not end up in dispute.”

Despite the increase in dispute values, the UK is still below the global average which stands at £20.4m.

The Middle East continued to experience the highest value disputes at £41.8m, whilst disputes in the US had the lowest value at £5.8m.

Latest news

Housing contractor Real LSE files administration notice

Real LSE part of group formed in 2021 following acquisition of Rydon contracts
3 hours ago

ISG clinches £155m Cat D prison expansion

Firm to deliver 780 new places at three existing prison locations
3 hours ago

27-storey Salford student tower approved

540-bed student block to be built on former site of McDonalds' regional HQ
2 hours ago

Morgan Sindall £48m Dumfries school job approved

Building work to start before the end of 2023
2 hours ago

Pagabo starts race for £1.6bn decarbonising frameworks

Two frameworks are anchored by Great Ormond Street Hospital and Hull City Council
3 hours ago

Former HS2 chairmen blast plans to scale back scheme

Fears grow for future of UK's biggest construction project
2 hours ago

Redrow plans 1,400 home garden village in Rochdale

Construction on first phase could start next year
3 hours ago

Bouygues/Murphy JV tipped for £2.3bn Thames tunnel job

Frontrunner emerges for Lower Thames Crossing 4.2km tunnel job
3 days ago

Subbies facing squeeze as main contractors tighten belts

Pay disputes increasing as suppliers fear major contractors returning to "bad old ways"
3 days ago

Portview takes control of Fulham Buckingham stand

Fit-out specialist steps in after main contractor failure
3 days ago

Firefighters probe cause of Leeds modular scheme blaze

Fire broke out in timber frame office job at Citu's eco development
3 days ago

Manslaughter probe dropped after demolition deaths

HSE to now lead investigation of 2019 tragedy
3 days ago

Vinci/McAlpine JV to start £105m NHS rehabilitation centre

Treasury clears New Hospital Programme job to start main construction
3 days ago

First sign of price falls for construction products

Supply returns to pre-covid levels as demand drops
4 days ago

Three giant lab buildings approved at £700m Oxford R&D district

Phase 2 Oxford North office and lab buildings to deliver 460,000 sq ft of space
5 days ago

PM fails to quash speculation about plan to axe HS2 phase 2

Sunak ducks future of HS2 question at big net zero Government briefing
4 days ago

Green light for giant North Wales offshore wind farm

Awel y Môr wind farm is the biggest renewable investment in Wales for a decade
4 days ago

T&T breaks £1bn revenue mark for first time

Global consultant enjoys strong growth across all seven geographical regions
4 days ago

Subcontractors and suppliers wanted across Scotland

Constructionline Meet the Buyer event next week at Hampden Park: Register now
4 days ago

Springfield switches strategy as private housing slumps

Scottish house builder turns back to affordable homes market
5 days ago

Sunak details zero carbon targets climbdown

Ban on gas boilers delayed five years; 50% rise in scrappage scheme
5 days ago

RG Group to build tallest student block in the world

Contractor confirmed on 45-storey tower in Leeds
5 days ago

Galliford Try forecasts profit to double next year

Contractor delivers strong results this year and raises expectation for 2024
5 days ago

Strabag hires 15 senior Buckingham Group staff

Austrian civils giant to set up UK building business with pool of staff
6 days ago

Contractors raise pay offer to avert engineering construction strike

Blue book agreement employers up final offer to 10%
5 days ago

Former Mid Group chief joins Tilbury Douglas

Steven Hearn gets new role as regional director of the South East division
5 days ago

Crumbly concrete found at extra 27 schools

A total of 174 schools now found to contain RAAC concrete
6 days ago

Henry Boot Construction struggling to find work

Contracting arm looking to fill order book
6 days ago

More schools found to have crumbly concrete

Surveyors find another 27 schools containing Raac
6 days ago

Buckingham Plant Hire still trading as normal

Separate plant business "not affected" by collapse of contractor
6 days ago

Contractor services