Legal contract rows soar and take longer to resolve

Aaron Morby 12 years ago
Share

Construction legal disputes have skyrocketed in average value and now take a third longer to resolve than they did in 2011.

According to an EC Harris study dispute values jumped from £6.6m in 2011 to £17.7m last year and now drag on four months longer than they did in 2011.

The firm said the sudden jump was likely to be been influenced by its team working on an unusually high number of disputes on major programmes of work.

Construction disputes now take on average 12.9 months to be settled compared to 8.7 months the year before.

The extended time it takes to resolve rows was put down to construction courts
now ordering mediation in the first instance in the majority of cases.

The most common cause of dispute was a failure to properly administer the contract.

    Top five causes of construction disputes

    1. Failure to properly administer the contract

    2. Failure to understand or comply with contractual obligations

    3. Employer imposed change

    4. Conflicting party interests

    5. Incomplete and/ or unsubstantiated claims

Taking the top five as a whole, disputes tend to be attributable to parties taking a less collaborative approach to projects than in other parts of the world.

For example, the employer imposing change and conflicting party interests feature highly.

One of the highest profile disputes last year involved the construction of the Shard in London. 

The dispute between steelwork companies Cleveland Bridge UK and Severfield-Rowen Structures first came to light in early 2010, but was only resolved in January 2013 following a lengthy dispute that ended up in the High Court.  

Cleveland Bridge was ultimately ordered to pay o £824,478 in damages to Severfield-Rowen for delays and defects which were estimated to cause a delay of 42 days on the Shard’s construction.

This year’s report Global Construction Disputes: A Longer Resolution also found greater joint venture working was leading to more disputes within project teams.

On the international stage, one in five disputes were driven by conflict within a joint venture team.

Gary Kitt, head of Contract Solutions, UK at EC Harris said: “Joint venture agreements are becoming more prevalent, particularly where a project is of such a large size and scale or there is a need because of licensing requirements for a local JV Partner.

“These JVs are causing a significant number of cases, so more needs to be done in order to ensure that the JV itself does not end up in dispute.”

Despite the increase in dispute values, the UK is still below the global average which stands at £20.4m.

The Middle East continued to experience the highest value disputes at £41.8m, whilst disputes in the US had the lowest value at £5.8m.

Latest news

Elements Europe went down owing supply chain £8.7m

Korean owner kept offsite specialist afloat with £71.8m of loans in bid to stem losses
14 hours ago

Altius and Erith win landmark London tower rebuild

Westminster council advances Huguenot House redevelopment
17 hours ago

Corbyn suppliers left £4.4m out-of-pocket

£33m-turnover civils contractor only employed eight staff
1 day ago

McAlpine to restore England’s largest Victorian water tower

Colchester’s iconic ‘Jumbo’ to be reborn as visitor destination
17 hours ago

Andrew Scott lands £20m Grand Pavilion revamp in Porthcawl

Restoration of landmark Art Deco building gets underway with 2027 finish target
16 hours ago

Keepmoat profit drops 35% as completions slide

Land pipeline expands to 24,400 plots as firm eyes rebound
16 hours ago

Bid race begins for £425m water transfer scheme

Contractors invited to help shape Affinity Water project
16 hours ago

Legacy building defects return to haunt Barratt Redrow

House builder sets aside £248m for Redrow fire and concrete frame fixes
2 days ago

Skanska agrees £153m price to revamp A47 Thickthorn junction

New link roads and underpasses to ease traffic near Norwich
2 days ago

First tower plans go in for £1bn Liverpool Pier Head site

First design will "set tone" of scheme which could contain 60-storey tower
2 days ago

Barhale creates new low-carbon chief board role

Haddon takes board seat while Solomon becomes eastern regional director
2 days ago

Met Police preps £300m framework for estate upgrade

Early market talks start ahead of October bid contest
2 days ago

Raft of SME firms win £94m framework places

More than 50 demolition and asbestos specialists chosen: Full list
2 days ago

GRAHAM gets go-ahead for £110m Boddingtons Brewery revamp

Work to start this summer after Gateway 2 approval secured
3 days ago

Thames Water finance chief joins BAM UK & Ireland

Abigail Farrell-Black joins contractor as new finance head after senior roles at Thames and Southern Water
3 days ago

FM Conway profit jumps to £33m under Vinci

Turnover hits £608m and cash surges £68m just two months into new ownership
3 days ago

McAlpine breaks ground at £1.25bn Port Talbot green steel job

Port Talbot switch to scrap-powered production by 2027
3 days ago

Cappagh lands £136m Portsmouth Water deals

Utility specialist wins AMP8 contracts for infrastructure and smart meters
3 days ago

Rethink over “anti-dumping” tariffs on Chinese diggers

Fair trade body reconsiders ruling after lobbying by manufacturers
3 days ago

Sparks agree near 4% wage increase from 2026

Top hourly rate in London to rise to £26.70 under JIB deal
3 days ago

Morgan Sindall to build new Cambridgeshire school

Latest win for contractor at Alconbury Weald development
3 days ago

BSR backlog swells as new build approvals run to 36 weeks

First official Government figures expose full extent of Gateway project logjam
6 days ago

Repair slowdown drags down construction output

New work activity rises in May despite overall 0.6% output fall
6 days ago

Equans suffers £29m loss as new build exit drags on

Refocused retrofit contractor still dogged by legacy losses despite profitable core work
6 days ago

Scaffolding trade body NASC facing discrimination claim

Former training manager to take trade body to Employment Tribunal
6 days ago

ACS lands lead role on Stafford transformers lab

Contractor to start main £20m expansion in live site environment
6 days ago

GRAHAM sees profits rise despite dip in turnover

Record order book as contractor confident about future prospects
6 days ago

Nixon Hire sells 200-strong welfare van fleet to Sunbelt

Sunbelt more than doubles mobile site welfare capability
7 days ago

Henry family and directors face claims topping £31m

Administrators chasing dividend payout, unpaid loans and family benefits
7 days ago

Vistry eyes second-half affordable homes work surge

Government rent reforms and funding pledges power-up work pipeline
7 days ago