Three storey buildings collapse during refurb job

Grant Prior 12 years ago
Share

A Buckinghamshire contractor and its managing director have been fined for a series of blunders which led to the total collapse of two large properties in Westminster.

The three-storey buildings were reduced to rubble in January 2011 and neighbouring properties sustained serious structural damage.

Westminster Magistrates’ Court heard that Ethos Construction, led by director Pritish Lad, was the principal contractor for a major project to refurbish a self-contained block of 14 buildings on Fulham Road to create 56 new apartments and 13 commercial units.

Adjoining properties at numbers 270 and 280 collapsed without warning on Sunday 23 January.

The weekend timing meant there was no work activity and nobody was on site.

The fallen rubble and debris took several days to clear and Fulham Road was partially closed for several weeks while neighbouring buildings were checked and made safe.

A Prohibition Notice was put in place to stop the resumption of the renovation project until the site was declared as safe and stable.

HSE inspectors identified a number of safety failings in investigating the collapse. They included:
• Allowing existing structures to become weak and unstable. There was evidence of renovation activity within the collapsed buildings, including work on party walls and the demolition of rear extensions.
• Not assessing whether there was any evidence of a collapse risk.
• No temporary works plan for workers and no checks on whether workers were sufficiently trained and competent to undertake the work
• The storage of large piles of bricks on several floors of still-standing buildings, which posed a potential over-loading risk.
• The poor installation and positioning of building props.

HSE also identified further issues elsewhere, including: an unsafe excavation up to three metres deep running the entire length of the development site; risks concerning working at height; fire risks because flammable materials were poorly stored and controlled; a failure to provide suitable emergency exits; insufficient fire detection and fire fighting equipment; and inadequate site security.

Two further Prohibition Notices were served to immediately stop unsafe activity.

Ethos Construction Solutions Limited, of Chesham, Bucks, was fined a total of £14,000 and ordered to pay a further £9,000 in costs after pleading guilty to safety breaches.

Pritish Lad, 34, of Hatch End, Pinner, Middlesex, pleaded guilty to safety breaches and was fined a total of £9,500 with costs of £6,750.

After sentencing HSE Inspector Andrew Verrall-Withers commented: “The development site was a scene of complete devastation following the collapse and had anyone been working at the time there could have been multiple fatalities and serious injuries.

“It is also good fortune that the collapsed building didn’t come down in the direction of the busy Fulham Road, which could also have had tragic consequences.

“Thankfully that wasn’t the case, but they are the only positive outcomes from the incident.

“The failings we identified at the site were shocking, both in terms of their scale and severity, and there were numerous risks elsewhere that could also have caused death or injury.”

 

Latest news

MPs call for fraud probe in solid wall insulation scandal

Poor quality control and weak oversight cannot be carried into £15bn Warm Homes plan
4 hours ago

Another immigration raid on huge warehouse site

All workers found to be working legally at Panattoni Park in Swindon
3 hours ago

HS2 final tunnel drive to Euston starts next week

Skanska Costain Strabag to start last 4.5 mile tunnelling phase
4 hours ago

MPB lands £37m Midland Metro Phase 2 civils job

Wednesbury to Brierley Hill extension work includes 225m multi-span viaduct
3 hours ago

Balfour to start £108m Middlewich bypass this spring

Funding agreed and contract signed-off with council
3 hours ago

Wates and Mount Anvil seal deal to deliver 1,100-plus London homes

Site deal with Southwark Council includes 360 council houses
20 hours ago

Contractor hunt begins for £5.7bn Thames Water reservoir

Main works tender issued for Oxfordshire White Horse Reservoir job
1 day ago

Worker dies on Winvic warehouse site

Fatal accident on £15m Kent job
1 day ago

£74m refit of landmark Bristol office to go-ahead

Summer start for low-carbon overhaul of Grade II Canons Wharf
1 day ago

Birmingham City Hospital site set for 750-home rebuild

Homes England and Vistry seal deal to kick-off demolition and rebuild
1 day ago

Barhale promotes trio in senior leadership shake-up

Contractor creates new executive director role in Southern restructure
1 day ago

£1.5bn funding to tackle cultural buildings repair backlog

Museums, libraries and arts venues set for major repair works
1 day ago

JJ Rhatigan lands lead role on £78m City office conversion

Main works will start on Barbican site following Gateway 2 approval
2 days ago

Muse scoops 1,350-home Barrow docks regeneration

Developer picked for Marina Village waterfront plan
2 days ago

£15bn Warm Homes Plan maps out mass retrofit drive

Government pledges insulation, solar and heat pumps for up to five million homes
2 days ago

FK Facades and Construction placed into administration

40 jobs axed as Man City stadium and Elephant & Castle facade jobs stall
2 days ago

Galliford Try lifts profit outlook for first half

Firm upgrades full-year profit outlook backed by £211m cash pile and a £4.1bn order book
2 days ago

Chinese mega-embassy plan in London approved

Royal Mint Court scheme approved opposite the Tower of London
3 days ago

Winvic targets data centres market

Contractor looks to expand into new sector
2 days ago

South West civils firm Roadform files administration notice

£31m turnover contractor lodges court notice
2 days ago

Plans in for Derby Market Place regeneration

VINCI and ION push forward flagship city revival project
3 days ago

Kier returns to monthly net cash for first time in over a decade

Balance sheet turnaround comes as order book hits record £11.6bn
3 days ago

Strabag UK snaps up failed HV transmission contractor

Austrian giant makes move on UK energy market after GTDS pre-pack deal
3 days ago

Mace name to disappear from UK contracting

Construct arm to be renamed as consultancy takes Mace badge
4 days ago

Motorway closed after road repair kit breaks down

Traffic chaos on M62 as broken-down plant shuts junction near Huddersfield
3 days ago

Align closes out civils on longest HS2 tunnel

10-mile Chiltern Tunnel moves to fit-out after near five-year long civils job
3 days ago

Legal expert rises to head Balfour Beatty regional civils

Kay Slade steps up after reshaping North West operations
4 days ago

Tilbury Douglas regional chief joins Caddick to head civils arm

Ellenor is tasked with growing third-party work and widen the firm's regional footprint.
4 days ago

Six scoop £2bn Southern Housing upkeep deal

Big name firms miss out on 10-20 year framework deal
4 days ago

Hercules delays annual results announcement

Auditors still working on labour supplier's numbers after string of acquisitions
4 days ago