Opinion: Time to fight poor payment practice

Aaron Morby 12 years ago
Share

Carillion has managed to divide the subcontracting world with its so-called Early Payment Facility for the supply chain. 

Hundreds of firms working for Carillion have happily signed up to the new 120-day terms which allow earlier payment for a small fee.

They believe the reverse factoring agreement, based on the extended payment terms, is a small price to pay for the right to draw down payments at 45 days.

Carillion’s promise to reimburse the fee banks charge suppliers for the privilege of drawing down cash early has proved a more effective sweetener than many would have first thought. Of course, it remains to be seen how long this offer will last.

The rest of the industry sees the new terms as an attack on the 30-day payment or less that Government wants to see in private and public sector project supply chains.

What the heated payment debate has highlighted is the depths to which industry payment practices have sunk.

Subcontractors now appear willing to accept anything that will speed-up the flow of cash owed to them.

Predictably other main contractors now plan to follow suit although all are going to great pains to emphasise the fact that their payment terms are not being extended.

Reverse factoring will bring relief to some cash-strapped specialists in the short term. What it cannot be allowed to become is an alternative to paying firms promptly.

Whatever the good intentions, it is a fundamentally flawed and morally bankrupt approach.

Many subcontractors are struggling to live with the invidious main contractor rebate on money they are owed.

Paying an extra fee for the right to be paid earlier means many will find themselves 3-4% down in cash off sales.

This is a world away from the fine words and payment charters that Government believes are taking root in the supply chain.

What lies at the heart of the present problem is a major cash squeeze among main contractors.

Falling orders, the growth in term contracts that are far less attractive in cash flow terms and the advance of project bank accounts are all taking their toll on cash reserves.

The main contractor cash crunch will only get worse going forward.

Upward pressure already being felt on labour and material prices is sure to intensify in coming months and strike hard next year.

As order levels improve good subcontractors will find themselves in a much stronger bargaining position.

It may still be early in the recovery but subcontractors may soon be turning the tables on main contractors.

Latest news

Caldwell Construction collapses into administration

Insolvency specialist PKF Littlejohn appointed after rescue talks fail
2 days ago

£56bn hospital programme on track but delivery risks remain

NAO warns tight schedules and staff shortages could derail later waves
1 day ago

Modular firm backs ‘new chapter’ for Merit

Directors form new company after original offsite business crashed owing suppliers millions
1 day ago

A9 dualling switches to £1.9bn framework model

Bidding set to start for framework to deliver final five Highland sections
2 days ago

Kier set for £21m Edinburgh towers upgrade

15-storey buildings to get insulation upgrade
1 day ago

Rebar giant loses high court fight to save Chatham Docks base

High Court rejects judicial review paving way for Basin3 business park redevelopment
1 day ago

Heathrow kicks off third runway pre-planning design work

Airport targets 2029 consent with key policy calls looming in 2026
2 days ago

Civils firm Caldwell Construction files administration notice

Hundreds of workers sent home as Midlands firm says it is trying to find an investor
2 days ago

CW Plant Hire kit goes under hammer in fleet renewal sale

Euro Auctions to sell off used equipment next month
2 days ago

Henry creditors payout hangs on £31m family legal fight

Administrators say trade creditor dividend hinges on lawsuit against Henry directors and family
2 days ago

Ex-directors buy back Boutique Modern in £24k pre-pack deal

Modular housing firm reborn as BM Modular but creditors face £4.3m shortfall
2 days ago

Autumn Budget jitters knock construction output back

Uncertainty ahead of November statement triggers biggest quarterly fall since early 2023
2 days ago

Industry standards body racks-up huge loss

Accounts query invoices from firms linked to former leaders
3 days ago

Taylor Wimpey braces for margin squeeze this year

Lower opening order book and weaker margins shape cautious outlook
2 days ago

Green light for Ballymore 1,685 homes site

Go-ahead for latest redevelopment site in Royal Docks
2 days ago

Building boss fined for ignoring safety warnings

Court hands out fines after catalogue of safety concerns on pub conversion job
3 days ago

Treasury unlocks £1.1bn to revive Northern Powerhouse Rail

Cash to kick off design work on £45bn scheme ahead of 2030s build
4 days ago

Kier Construction appoints new southern region chief

Former Bouygues regional MD John Boughton joins Kier
3 days ago

Vistry saved by second half margin rebound to 8.4%

Cost control, site mix and partnership housing drive margin rebound
3 days ago

USA contractor acquires London super-prime specialist

Remian looks to expand in UK with deal for construction manager Rossco
3 days ago

McLaren takes 256-bed Leeds student tower job

Developer Pullans gets green light for Joseph’s Well student scheme
4 days ago

Milton Keynes plans £76m events venue

Operator chosen for 4,000-capacity scheme
3 days ago

Tower crane drivers set to strike

SItes could stop amid pay row with Wolffkran
4 days ago

Winvic wins £340m M&S mega shed at DIRFT

Low-carbon Midlands 1.3m sq ft twin sheds set to anchor food growth plans
5 days ago

Father-of-six dies in demolition site tragedy

Fatal accident while demolishing flats in Renfrewshire
5 days ago

Persimmon builds momentum with 12% jump in completions

House builder warns there will be no material uplift in market this year
4 days ago

Henry Boot seals planning for Goole 5.5m sq ft freeport

HBD partnership targets start on site this year for £130m first phase
4 days ago

FP McCann buys roofing products firm Easy-Trim

Concrete specialist acquires firm out of administration
4 days ago

Trade body BESA boots out five more firms in standards purge

Building engineering services body chief says race to the bottom is over
5 days ago

Bidders day set for £4.5bn Southern Construction Framework

Around 20 contractors brace for fight to retain places on sixth-generation mega deal
5 days ago