Opinion: Time to fight poor payment practice

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

Carillion has managed to divide the subcontracting world with its so-called Early Payment Facility for the supply chain. 

Hundreds of firms working for Carillion have happily signed up to the new 120-day terms which allow earlier payment for a small fee.

They believe the reverse factoring agreement, based on the extended payment terms, is a small price to pay for the right to draw down payments at 45 days.

Carillion’s promise to reimburse the fee banks charge suppliers for the privilege of drawing down cash early has proved a more effective sweetener than many would have first thought. Of course, it remains to be seen how long this offer will last.

The rest of the industry sees the new terms as an attack on the 30-day payment or less that Government wants to see in private and public sector project supply chains.

What the heated payment debate has highlighted is the depths to which industry payment practices have sunk.

Subcontractors now appear willing to accept anything that will speed-up the flow of cash owed to them.

Predictably other main contractors now plan to follow suit although all are going to great pains to emphasise the fact that their payment terms are not being extended.

Reverse factoring will bring relief to some cash-strapped specialists in the short term. What it cannot be allowed to become is an alternative to paying firms promptly.

Whatever the good intentions, it is a fundamentally flawed and morally bankrupt approach.

Many subcontractors are struggling to live with the invidious main contractor rebate on money they are owed.

Paying an extra fee for the right to be paid earlier means many will find themselves 3-4% down in cash off sales.

This is a world away from the fine words and payment charters that Government believes are taking root in the supply chain.

What lies at the heart of the present problem is a major cash squeeze among main contractors.

Falling orders, the growth in term contracts that are far less attractive in cash flow terms and the advance of project bank accounts are all taking their toll on cash reserves.

The main contractor cash crunch will only get worse going forward.

Upward pressure already being felt on labour and material prices is sure to intensify in coming months and strike hard next year.

As order levels improve good subcontractors will find themselves in a much stronger bargaining position.

It may still be early in the recovery but subcontractors may soon be turning the tables on main contractors.

Latest news

McAlpine healthcare MD joins BAM as Northern chief

Mark Gibson joins as Northern regional director
2 days ago

HS2 Align JV completes Britain’s longest rail bridge – video

Final deck segment sees HS2 viaduct break 137-year old record held by Tay Bridge
2 days ago

Green light for major London city fringe office retrofit

Overhaul of 30 Finsbury Square to start next Summer
1 day ago

John Lewis submits plan for £80m Reading rental flats scheme

Construction hoped to start on 215 flats scheme at the start of 2026
1 day ago

Balfour Beatty lands £27m Highlands flood defence scheme

Work to start imminently building river walls in Comrie
1 day ago

Buyers believe construction has “turned a corner”

Residential rebounds, commercial still strong but civils slows
2 days ago

Vistry unseats Barratt as Britain’s biggest house builder

Partnership homes specialist on track to build 18,000 homes this year
2 days ago

23 jobs axed as Lincolnshire contractor goes under

C G Godfrey provided civils and M&E services in Eastern England
2 days ago

Winvic first to use remote-control tower crane on site

Crane driver sits in ground floor command centre at Birmingham 33-storey tower
3 days ago

Starmer vows to ban Grenfell firms from public contracts

Prime Minister to write to named and shamed construction firms
3 days ago

Grenfell Inquiry calls for uber construction regulator

Shake-up must include licensing of main contractors taking on high rise projects
3 days ago

Robertson to restore historic Newcastle market

Work to revamp Grainger Market to start by the end of this month
2 days ago

Three bidders chase £1.4bn Midlands rail hub alliance

Balfour, Skanska, Bam and Laing O'Rouke in bidding for eight-year rail upgrade
3 days ago

Barratt profit nosedives as margin slumps to 4.2%

Fire safety provisions jump by an extra £126m to total £628m
3 days ago

First viaduct completed on HS2: Video site report

Eiffage, Kier, Ferrovial Construction and Bam Nuttall finish 163m long Highfurlong Brook Viaduct
3 days ago

Bouygues bags £28m Oxfordshire school job

St John’s Academy to be at heart of Wellington Gate Development
3 days ago

Willmott Dixon wins £49m Wigan college expansion

New campus for Wigan & Leigh College to be net zero in operation
3 days ago

Work to start on Liverpool office to flats job

Truman D&B wins resi conversion in Moorfields district
3 days ago

Government mothballs plan to scrap CE Mark

Building safety minister warns there is insufficient capacity in present testing regime
4 days ago

Government backs record number of clean energy projects

131 projects will produce electricity to power 11 million homes.
4 days ago

Tube station housing plan gets Government green light

Plans to transform Cockfosters Tube station were blocked by previous regime
4 days ago

Go-ahead for Bristol Temple Quay hotel and build to rent job

A trio of blocks will house a 230-room hotel, 170-room apart-hotel and 100 rental flats
4 days ago

Construction costs cut for Plymouth city centre revamp

Price of Armada Way scheme falls to £30m after exploratory work on site
4 days ago

Tilbury Douglas chief Paul Gandy to step down

Craig Tatton to take on CEO role from November
5 days ago

Local pressure unblocks £240m Oxford sewage works upgrade

Council warns Thames Water delay is halting building of thousands of new homes
5 days ago

Knights Brown bags last phase of £86m Portsmouth flood defence job

Contractor has already completed second and third phases of North Portsea Coastal Scheme
5 days ago

Bidding starts for £1bn housing decarbonising framework

National housing energy efficiency retrofit deal will come into force in 2015
5 days ago

World’s strongest land-based crane launched

Mammoet crane will help build major energy and infrastructure projects
5 days ago

Big Yellow gets go-ahead for largest London site

Storage giant to build 176,000 sq ft scheme next to Kensington Olympia
5 days ago

Worker dies after being buried by trench collapse

Court hears workers on new build housing site had no training on working within excavations
5 days ago

Contractor services