End of road for payroll company kickbacks

Grant Prior 6 years ago

Payroll companies are being accused of giving “kickbacks” to labour agencies and contractors to keep their workers self employed.


The industry is facing a massive clampdown in April when Government plans to stamp out agency self-employment come into force.

Firms operating in the multi-million pound payroll and agency sectors fear the changes will blow a massive hole in their business.

Thousands of construction workers are employed via payroll companies who typically charge individuals up to £25 a week to manage their self-employed tax affairs.

The Enquirer understands some firms have been offering “rebates” of £10 a week per worker to agencies and contractors who use them

One tax expert said: “This has been going on a for a long time and everyone has been turning a blind eye.

“But there’s a lot of money involved.

“Payroll firms who work with agencies will hand some of their fees back to keep workers employed through them.

“The money goes straight into the pocket of the agencies or contractors they are working for.

“Some of these firms have grown to have massive influence in the industry and the tax man has had enough of it.”

The new measures in the draft Finance Bill will hit at least 200,000 construction workers – with some experts estimating that figure could double.

The changes will result in an estimated £520m tax haul for the chancellor.

The bill states: “The engager and employment intermediary often share between them the employer NICs and employment rights savings, with the worker receiving very little, if any, financial benefits from these arrangements.

“In recent years there has been a rapid growth in the number of intermediaries being used to facilitate false self-employment by exploiting weaknesses in the existing legislation.

“This model initially started in the construction industry and grew rapidly there.

“Unsuccessful challenges by HMRC using the existing legislation, alongside aggressive marketing of these schemes, has increased the rate of growth of these models.”

One of the leading payroll firms has also hit out at the practice of kickbacks.

Hudson Contract Services Ltd said: “We would welcome a clampdown on the practice used by many payroll companies of taking fees from workers to give back to clients as kickbacks.

“We are compelled to draw three distinctions between these companies and Hudson; firstly Hudson is not simply a payroll company, (the services we provide to our clients are far more complex than that of simply payroll), secondly we never charge the operatives a fee, and thirdly because we do not charge the operatives a fee, we cannot offer rebates.

“We have been approached by many high street agencies over the years, who mistakenly expect us to charge the operatives and pay a rebate. Our answer is always the same ‘we don’t deal with agencies and we have not and never would give rebates’.

“These practices have long since been a cause of frustration to Hudson as the agency payroll firms are spreading their wings and pushing their schemes toward contractors. We have lost clients to these schemes as they are sold as ‘money making schemes’ as opposed to Hudson who expects the clients to pay for the services that they need.”


Latest news

Plans in for 1m brick monument of hope

Construction of The Wall monument is planned to start later this year
2 hours ago

Historic London markets to move to Dagenham

Billingsgate, New Spitalfields and Smithfield to get new home together
42 mins ago

Trio selected for £135m Meridian Water civils packages

BAM Nuttall, Vinci and VolkerFitzpatrick in for London Lee Valley infrastructure work
3 hours ago

Major contractors to stop using dodgy umbrella companies

Big names sign charter to protect employment rights and promote equality
22 hours ago

Berkeley to boost construction by 50%

Cash rich housing giant to hand out extra £455m to shareholders
6 hours ago

30 jobs to be axed as Sanderson Contracts shuts down

Yorkshire contractor collapses while working on two Easy Hotel projects
7 hours ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

Site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
2 years ago

Van Elle profit slides in first-half

Slowdown in rail work hits margins but revenue grows 13% on higher housing demand
7 hours ago

Amey hires collapsed glazing contractor boss

Craig McGilvray joins Amey to head FM and defence arm just a week after FGS collapsed
14 hours ago

Willmott Dixon nabs £20m Humberside police hub

Work to start in autumn on new operational support building
15 hours ago

Multiplex gets start date for £86m Glasgow Uni block

July start for postgraduate hub and business school building
23 hours ago

Laing O’Rourke to build Gary Neville’s £200m tower scheme

Work to start this summer on St Michael's complex in Manchester.
1 day ago

Late payment bill to enforce 30-day terms

Latest legislation aims to outlaw abuse of subcontractors and supply chain finance schemes
1 day ago

Building safety police force to be run by HSE

Government promises "biggest change in building safety for a generation."
2 days ago

Report submitted on Shaylor directors following collapse

Latest update holds out little hope for more money for trade contractors owed £19m
2 days ago

Green light for new stand at Emirates Old Trafford

Lancashire Cricket Club will have the largest ground outside of London
2 days ago

SME contractors to have their say on CITB levy

CITB training system branded a "billion pound bodge job"
1 day ago

Green light for £137m Midland Metro eastside extension

New 1.7km Birmingham Eastside Extension will connect planned HS2 station at Curzon Street
2 days ago

HS2 review slams project team as costs could hit £106bn

Oakervee review to give "lukewarm" backing to project
2 days ago

Demolition winner for vast Elizabeth House job

Fierce competition for demolition package to pave way for new 31-storey tower at Waterloo
2 days ago

Anglo American commits to saving £2.5bn potash mine project

Mining giant aims to get Yorkshire construction project back on track
2 days ago

South Koreans buy stake in UK offsite specialist

Elements Europe aims to ramp up production with new factories
1 day ago

T+T secures PM role on Bradford Odeon job

Restoration of former 1930s Odeon cinema to be completed late next year
2 days ago

Robo cone layers to make life safer on road jobs

Automatic cone laying machines could be on site by end of the year
5 days ago

NAO raises alarm over cost of finishing Carillion hospitals

Spending watchdog warns a significant risk of £2bn cost of both hospitals rising further
6 days ago

Green light for Birmingham’s tallest tower

£150m Broad Street skyscraper will rise to 61 floors
5 days ago

Plan for £33m cross laminate timber office block

Developer Southern Grove plans 6 storey office block in London's Shoreditch area
5 days ago

GMI to build 14-storey Leeds hotel

Scheme will occupy last remaining plot on Sovereign Square site
5 days ago

Burglar caught after ransacking construction training centre

Rampage and robbery disrupts Sunderland training hub
5 days ago

Alligator park plan for £230m mixed use London site

Developer plans to turn iconic gasholder into reptile house on Old Kent Road
6 days ago

Contractor services