Human rights challenge to self employment crackdown

Grant Prior 6 years ago
Share

Recruitment specialists are warning that the recent Government crackdown on false self employment could be a breach of the Human Rights Act.

hmrc-logo-01

Trade body APSCo will write to Whitehall this week warning that legislation introduced last month could leave the Government open to a legal challenge.

The recruitment body fears the changes expose its members to great a risk in the complicated world of construction payroll arrangements.

Samantha Hurley, Head of External Affairs and Compliance at APSCo, said: “We are of course in favour of measures to curb tax avoidance and fully support the efforts of HMRC in its endeavours, but what we cannot support is burdening the recruitment sector with a tax liability over which it has no control without giving some form of statutory defence in the event of the unscrupulous behaviour of intermediaries further down the supply chain.”

“We are certainly not arguing for the removal of the legislation altogether – but what we are asking for is a defence for recruitment firms in the event that they have undertaken reasonable due diligence – a defence which already exists in the Agency Workers Regulations.”

“The legislation does include a defence for recruitment firms against the provision of fraudulent documents by other parties in the supply chain, but we believe that this is a red herring as the reality of this situation is that the onus would be on the intermediary to prove not only that fraud had taken place – but also that there was an intent to defraud.

“We will be writing to The Treasury outlining not only the concerns summarised above but also the fact that not providing for a statutory defence poses a major legal risk for the Government itself – a risk which is entirely unnecessary.

“As we are not asking for a removal of the legislation itself, we very much hope that the Government will see reason and provide the amendment needed to make the legislation reasonable, proportionate and above all legally robust.”

Latest news

Robo cone layers to make life safer on road jobs

Automatic cone laying machines could be on site by end of the year
2 days ago

NAO raises alarm over cost of finishing Carillion hospitals

Spending watchdog warns a significant risk of £2bn cost of both hospitals rising further
3 days ago

Green light for Birmingham’s tallest tower

£150m Broad Street skyscraper will rise to 61 floors
2 days ago

Plan for £33m cross laminate timber office block

Developer Southern Grove plans 6 storey office block in London's Shoreditch area
2 days ago

GMI to build 14-storey Leeds hotel

Scheme will occupy last remaining plot on Sovereign Square site
2 days ago

Burglar caught after ransacking construction training centre

Rampage and robbery disrupts Sunderland training hub
2 days ago

Alligator park plan for £230m mixed use London site

Developer plans to turn iconic gasholder into reptile house on Old Kent Road
3 days ago

Domis set for £300m landmark Manchester Viadux

Developers Ask and Salboy team-up for mixed-use scheme near Deansgate
3 days ago

Winners named for £3bn offsite schools framework

B&K, Caledonian, Elliott, Laing O'Rourke and Wates come top of class
3 days ago

£30bn NHS construction frameworks shake-up starts

General healthcare and son of ProCure22 framework contests to start
3 days ago

Man extradited from Albania and charged with site murder

Albanian national appears in UK court after year-long extradition proceedings
4 days ago

Stepnell West Midlands boss leaves business

John Rawlinson departs after overseeing shift from civils to building
3 days ago

Farrans brings in two civils directors

Jonathan Kerr joins from Graham and Jim Steele was former Morrison MD
3 days ago

Richard Desmond wins planning for £1bn Westferry Printworks

Housing secretary overrules planning inspector to grant planning for 1,500 flats
4 days ago

Sisk wins UK’s tallest Premier Inn job

Foundation work gets underway on Canary Wharf site in London Docklands
4 days ago

Worker killed as excavator falls through concrete slab

McGee fined £500,000 following death on demolition site
4 days ago

Bouygues to start £115m Canterbury Riverside scheme

Work to start shortly on mixed use leisure and rental accommodation project
4 days ago

Green light for first homes in £1bn Purfleet regen scheme

Work to start on first 61 homes in Essex town centre regeneration
4 days ago

Balfour crowned 2019 contracts league champion

Multiplex and Bowmer & Kirkland join Top 10 firms for first time
5 days ago

Contracts manager jailed after roofer falls to his death

Police find risk assessment documents with forged signatures during investigation
4 days ago

Winners named for £2bn Hyde new-build housing deal

Eleven selected for £25m-plus projects among 41 winners
4 days ago

Worker killed and another injured on Birmingham Uni site

Men fall from a scissor lift at Balfour Beatty site
4 days ago

Firm set up by ex-Bardsley QS throws lifeline to 12 former staff

Goodwin Construction hires axed Bardsley staff as revenue set to hit £70m
5 days ago

Laing opens picture archive on post war construction

Picture vault reveals the industry's journey from flat caps to hard hats
5 days ago

VolkerFitzpatrick wins £40m Brent Cross West Station

Work to start on station in May, which will help to unlock £4.5bn
4 days ago

Historic building specialist Stone Edge collapses

Skipton-based stone building restoration firm in administration
5 days ago

£10bn Pagabo major works framework winners

ISG, Morgan Sindall and McAlpine scoop all project values in six of seven regions
6 days ago

Developer launches own contractor after Bardsley collapse

Newly formed DEX Construction will complete Manchester resi scheme
6 days ago

Boost your online presence – join the Enquirer Directory

Site for suppliers and buyers showcases products, services and latest stories
2 years ago

Watkin Jones lifts development pipeline to 26 sites

Build to rent and student accommodation specialist sets out five year growth plan
5 days ago

Contractor services