Roof fall as contractors ignore cherry picker plan

Grant Prior 8 years ago
Share

Two contractors have been fined after a Liverpool labourer suffered life-threatening injuries when he fell through the roof of a former Cheshire factory.

Peter Tracey was removing asbestos roof sheets from a disused building in Poynton when he stepped onto a fragile panel and fell more than five metres to the concrete floor below.

He was airlifted to hospital with critical injuries, before being placed into an induced coma.

Haydock-based Local Asbestos Services Ltd and Leicestershire-based Construction Contracting UK Ltd were both prosecuted by the HSE after an investigation found they had allowed workers onto the roof without safety measures in place.

Liverpool Magistrates’ Court was told that 59-year-old Tracey, from Fairfield, was part of a group of labourers hired by Local Asbestos Services to remove the asbestos sheets from the roof of a former factory during its demolition.

Construction Contracting was overseeing the project as the principal contractor and both companies had agreed that the sheets would be removed using a cherry picker or scissor lift underneath the roof.

This would have allowed workers to cut the bolts holding the sheets in place, without the need for them to go onto the roof itself.

The court heard that, despite this, two of the men, including Tracey, were allowed to climb onto the roof to remove the panels from above.

No safety equipment, such as nets or harnesses, were provided to stop them falling or to prevent them from being injured.

On 5 April 2013, Tracey was removing an asbestos sheet when it started to slip away. He went to grab it and stepped onto a clear plastic panel, which gave way under his weight.

Tracey suffered critical injuries, including two collapsed lungs, blood in his left lung, fractures to his ribs and hip, and a ruptured left shoulder tendon.

He was in hospital for a month and will be affected by his injuries for the rest of his life.

In a victim statement to support the HSE investigation, he said: “I now struggle to do everyday things like going to the shops, and have had to rely on my daughter and sister to do my washing and clean my home.”

Construction Contracting UK Ltd, of Hinckley, Leicestershire, was fined £12,000 and ordered to pay costs of £23,502 after being found guilty of a single breach of the CDM Regulations.

Local Asbestos Services Ltd, of Haydock, was fined £8,000 and ordered to pay £6,191 in prosecution costs after pleading guilty to a single breach of the Work at Height Regulations.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE Inspector Kevin Jones said: “Sadly this kind of incident is all too common in the roofing industry, and Mr Tracey has suffered debilitating injuries because of the failings of both Local Asbestos Services and Construction Contracting.

“Many industrial buildings have clear plastic panels on them designed to act as roof lights, but they are fragile and can collapse if workers stand on them.

“Both companies had prepared a risk assessment and method statement identifying a safe system of work, but this wasn’t implemented.

“Instead, Peter and another worker were allowed onto the roof instead of using a cherry picker underneath, which put both their lives in danger.

“This case should act as a warning to firms of the consequences of not following agreed safety systems.”

Latest plant news

Vac UK puts in another giant order for £10m of machines

20 new Longo Rhino excavators add to specialist's impressive fleet
5 months ago
Vac UK

Construction materials cost increases hit 40-year high

Steel and timber soar quickest with rises set to continue next year
9 months ago

Cementation Skanska switches all large-scale plant to bio-fuel

Piling contractor commits to Green D+ fuel after big HS2 site trial
9 months ago

JCB targets first hydrogen diggers by end of 2022

Plant giant is investing £100m in developing super-efficient hydrogen engines
10 months ago

House builder backs plant warning cameras on all sites

Countryside commits to AI proximity warning cameras on all site telehandlers
1 year ago

Police launch specialist plant theft busting unit

ACE unit will focus on tackling organised plant theft gangs
1 year ago

On-board breaker takes suction excavator to new level

Specialist manufacturer cracks problem with world first design innovation
1 year ago

Construction plant shortages start to bite

Smaller excavator delivery dates being pushed to 2022
1 year ago

Laing O’Rourke joins switch to electric cars

Plan to transition 1,000-car fleet to all-electric by 2025
2 years ago

JCB to hire 400 agency workers in production push

Demand for machines has rebounded sharply in Europe and North America
2 years ago

Strong trading lifts hirer P Flannery revenue to £116m

Revenue soars to record high for fast-growing plant hirer
2 years ago

Plant hire firm plans £33.8m tourism development

Perthshire site will see construction of hotel, lodges and transport museum
2 years ago

New pothole machine delivers road repairs four times faster

JCB Pothole Pro machine can repair a pothole in under eight minutes and at half the cost of a road gang
2 years ago

Wernick acquires Robert Purvis Plant Hire’s portable accommodation fleet

Wernick boosts presence in Scotland
2 years ago

Plant hirer fined £220k after crane nearly hits apprentice

Court hears how apprentice forced to leap for his life
2 years ago

JCB launches electric telehandler and dumper

Stand-alone rapid charger unit also unveiled to support E-Tech range
2 years ago

City Hire expands guaranteed tool hire service

Equipment delivery time guarantee extended beyond London
2 years ago
City Hire

Three sisters set-up plant hire business

Finnegan sisters buy first kit after securing funding deal
2 years ago

Fox Bros snaps up north west hirer Clive Hurt

North West haulier and earthworks contractor now on the hunt for bigger jobs
2 years ago

Speedy trials electric taxis as tool delivery vans

Converted red taxicabs can carry two pallets up to 800kg
2 years ago

Major plant hirer Vp sees revenues rebound

Hire revenues back to 80% of pre-Covid level
2 years ago

Flannery trials first electric tele at HS2 site

Skanska Costain Strabag JV to roll out more machines across HS2
2 years ago

Tower crane lifts end long climb to work for operators

Laing O'Rourke trials mast climbing lifts for tower crane operators at London site
2 years ago

JCB powers up first hydrogen fuelled digger

JCB in race to lead the world on hydrogen-powered plant
2 years ago

Self driving plant to be standard on road jobs by 2035

Highways England launches 15-year plan for a 'digital revolution'
2 years ago

JCB switches to online sales for first time

Micro, mini excavators and one tonne dumpers can now be bought online
2 years ago

JCB plans to cut 950 jobs

JCB chief warns furlough scheme was never going to be enough to cope with demand halving
2 years ago

New trainee plant operator scheme ready to launch

Industry and client-led apprenticeship will help to train next generation of operators
2 years ago

JCB resumes production at five UK factories

Thermal imaging cameras to be used in factories to ID workers with fevers
2 years ago

Plant theft soars as construction sites close

Thieves taking advantage of coronavirus impact to steal site equipment
2 years ago

Contractor services