Opinion: Ghost of Laing haunts Balfour Beatty

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

The spectre of Laing Construction is looming over Balfour Beatty as it fights to get its finances under control.

Laing like Balfour had grown to dominate the market and looked bullet proof as a business.

But what started as a trickle of bad news ended in Laing being sold to O’Rourke only 18 months later.

Laing battled with similar problems of controlling a large conglomerate while instituting sweeping management changes.

But those fixes came too late to avert hefty profit warnings and gushing losses on a handful of jobs.

The parallels with Balfour to this point are striking.

Fourteen years ago the Laing family, cornered by mountainous losses, was left with no alternative but to sell the construction division for just a £1.

Balfour maybe a much bigger player – but the same alarm bells are ringing again.

The decision to call in KPMG to independently assess contracts and work in progress looks like a desperate measure by a board which has lost faith in its own internal financial controls.

Claims that the swelling number of problem contracts stem from legacy jobs that will be fully resolved by the end of the year are falling on deaf ears.

Contract settlements can only get harder to negotiate as Balfour’s woes pile up and its bargaining power diminishes.

After a fifth profit warning, it is not surprising that city investors have lost patience.

What is unnerving for Balfour and its 40,000 staff is that analysts, fearing the worst, are talking about writing the value of the firm down to zero.

Does anybody actually know where Balfour Beatty stands financially at this moment in time? The answer is a resounding no.

With KPMG going over the books in forensic detail and a new chief executive seeking to clear the decks when they join – it is almost certain that further problems will be uncovered.

Balfour Beatty is standing at a crossroads.

The sale of Parsons Brinckerhoff has bought some time and will help to stem growing net debt.

But Balfour appears too far down the Laing road to simply return to running the group as a UK and US focused construction business.

Carillion is still said to be waiting in the wings, but will need Balfour to approach them this time around.

The alternative is unthinkable for the industry and Balfour’s loyal legions of staff.

Latest news

£15bn Warm Homes Plan maps out mass retrofit drive

Government pledges insulation, solar and heat pumps for up to five million homes
9 hours ago

Muse scoops 1,350-home Barrow docks regeneration

Developer picked for Marina Village waterfront plan
5 minutes ago

FK Facades and Construction placed into administration

40 jobs axed as Man City stadium and Elephant & Castle facade jobs stall
9 hours ago

Galliford Try lifts profit outlook for first half

Firm upgrades full-year profit outlook backed by £211m cash pile and a £4.1bn order book
10 hours ago

Chinese mega-embassy plan in London approved

Royal Mint Court scheme approved opposite the Tower of London
1 day ago

Winvic targets data centres market

Contractor looks to expand into new sector
9 hours ago

South West civils firm Roadform files administration notice

£31m turnover contractor lodges court notice
10 hours ago

Plans in for Derby Market Place regeneration

VINCI and ION push forward flagship city revival project
1 day ago

Kier returns to monthly net cash for first time in over a decade

Balance sheet turnaround comes as order book hits record £11.6bn
1 day ago

Strabag UK snaps up failed HV transmission contractor

Austrian giant makes move on UK energy market after GTDS pre-pack deal
1 day ago

Mace name to disappear from UK contracting

Construct arm to be renamed as consultancy takes Mace badge
2 days ago

Motorway closed after road repair kit breaks down

Traffic chaos on M62 as broken-down plant shuts junction near Huddersfield
1 day ago

Align closes out civils on longest HS2 tunnel

10-mile Chiltern Tunnel moves to fit-out after near five-year long civils job
1 day ago

Legal expert rises to head Balfour Beatty regional civils

Kay Slade steps up after reshaping North West operations
2 days ago

Tilbury Douglas regional chief joins Caddick to head civils arm

Ellenor is tasked with growing third-party work and widen the firm's regional footprint.
2 days ago

Six scoop £2bn Southern Housing upkeep deal

Big name firms miss out on 10-20 year framework deal
2 days ago

Hercules delays annual results announcement

Auditors still working on labour supplier's numbers after string of acquisitions
2 days ago

Benniman to finish logistics park at former MG Rover plant

13-unit industrial package marks final chapter of Longbridge West transformation
2 days ago

Flannery to sell old fleet after £107m new kit investment

Huge auction of machines in March after massive investment by plant hire giant
2 days ago

Liverpool mayor sets out £2bn plan to unlock 64,000 homes

300-site pipeline targets stalled urban schemes
2 days ago

Graham lands £37m Leicestershire school rebuild

Castle Rock School overhaul will accommodate more than 1,500 pupils
2 days ago

Caldwell Construction collapses into administration

Insolvency specialist PKF Littlejohn appointed after rescue talks fail
6 days ago

£56bn hospital programme on track but delivery risks remain

NAO warns tight schedules and staff shortages could derail later waves
5 days ago

Modular firm backs ‘new chapter’ for Merit

Directors form new company after original offsite business crashed owing suppliers millions
5 days ago

A9 dualling switches to £1.9bn framework model

Bidding set to start for framework to deliver final five Highland sections
6 days ago

Kier set for £21m Edinburgh towers upgrade

15-storey buildings to get insulation upgrade
5 days ago

Rebar giant loses high court fight to save Chatham Docks base

High Court rejects judicial review paving way for Basin3 business park redevelopment
5 days ago

Heathrow kicks off third runway pre-planning design work

Airport targets 2029 consent with key policy calls looming in 2026
6 days ago

Civils firm Caldwell Construction files administration notice

Hundreds of workers sent home as Midlands firm says it is trying to find an investor
6 days ago

CW Plant Hire kit goes under hammer in fleet renewal sale

Euro Auctions to sell off used equipment next month
6 days ago