Worker crushed during energy plant construction

Grant Prior 7 years ago
Share

Three construction companies have been fined after a worker was crushed by a falling section of conveyor at a plant in Sleaford.

The incident happened during construction of the Sleaford Renewable Energy plant on 14 February 2013 when the 4.5 tonne conveyor section overturned during installation.

It trapped Michael Doyle, a 49-year-old employee of Derby-based Shaw Group UK Ltd, who suffered multiple injuries including four cracked vertebrae, broken ribs, a punctured lung and broken ankle.

He has not returned to work since.

Lincoln Magistrates’ Court heard that Shaw Group UK Ltd had been subcontracted to install a boiler and associated equipment , including a conveyor system to carry large straw bales, by Burmeister and Wain Energy (BWE).

BWE was one of two Danish companies, the other being Burmeister and Wain Scandinavian Contractor (BWSC), that had formed a consortium to design and build the centre, which burns straw and wood to create electricity.

Shaw Group UK Ltd had already lifted three conveyor sections on to a slope leading up to the boiler by craning them on to a platform at the bottom of the slope.

Skates were bolted to the front and rear legs which helped keep the section of conveyor on rails as it was dragged up the slope by manual winches set up at the top.

In order to fix the sections of conveyor in place workers needed to remove the skates and used jacks to raise the legs enough to take the skates off and then lower the legs down onto the rail.

This was carried out successfully on the first three sections but as the jacks were released, on the lower legs of the fourth and final section, one side lowered faster than the other and the conveyor swung towards two workers before violently swinging the other way and turning on its side, trapping Doyle underneath.

An HSE investigation identified safety failings by all three companies.

Shaw Group UK Ltd had produced a risk assessment and a plan for the installation but it did not consider removal of the skates from the legs of the conveyor sections or the manual winching of the load up the slope.

The document had been sent to BWE for checking but the company did not pick up on the omission.

The lifting operation using jacks was not carried out safely and none of the three defendants was managing or monitoring the work in a way that would ensure its safety.

The investigation also found that BWSC failed in its responsibility as principal contractor to ensure work was properly assessed and co-ordinated between the many contractors on site.

Shaw Group UK Ltd, of Derby, was fined a total of £17,350 and ordered to pay costs of £1,710 after pleading guilty to safety regulations.

Burmeister and Wain Scandinavian Contractor, of Allerød, Denmark, was fined £4,670 and ordered to pay costs of £1,710 while Burmeister and Wain Energy, of Kgs Lyngby, Denmark, was fined £5,350 and ordered to pay costs of £1,710.

Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Martin Giles said: “This was a large site with multiple contractors and up to 300 people working at any one time.

“Although there was a series of site rules set out in a construction phase plan, BWSC’s management of the site was poor as each of the main contractors ran their own areas of the site as they desired and were able to set additional rules.

“This led to different procedures being followed and a lack of control over temporary works.

“The failure to ensure work was carried out safely on the slope was symptomatic of more general failures which were the responsibility of  principal contractor BWSC in setting the rules, procedures and checks needed to manage a large site. These failures put all the workers on site at risk.

“BWE specified the use of skates for installing the conveyor system but removing them required adequate risk assessment.

“Although the company had read the assessment and method statement produced by Shaw Group it made no comment on it and did not approve it before it was implemented. BWE should have picked up on that document’s failures and asked Shaw Group to re-evaluate before work was allowed to begin.

“Shaw Group UK Ltd’s risk assessment was flawed, and its management and monitoring of the task was not sufficient to identify potential problems and stop the work in the four days before Mr Doyle was hurt.

“The actual method of work followed by its employees was unsafe and led to Mr Doyle’s injuries when the load overturned.”

Latest news

Race starts for £500m Scottish zero carbon hospital job

Bidding starts for new University Hospital Monklands near Airdrie
40 mins ago

Manchester airport taxis out £60m terminal 2 pier job

Bidding to start before the end of 2022 for project start early next summer
39 mins ago

Plan for 1,100-home complex at Leicester factory site

Galliford Try investments plots Corah Factory transformation
36 mins ago

Axed House by Urban Splash staff plan legal action

Ex-workers consult with lawyers following administration
11 mins ago

Summer slowdown fears as latest contract award data droops

Latest Barbour ABI Snap Analysis paints uncertain picture
23 mins ago

Farrans wins £39m Somerset recycling hub

Site preparation gets underway for Keynsham Recycling Hub
37 mins ago

Balfour gets green light for £250m M25 junction 10

Autumn start for M25 junction 10/A3 Wisley interchange improvement scheme
3 days ago

Leeds plumbing contractor sinks with loss of 30 jobs

Dickinsons Plumbing and Heating goes down but renewables arm salvaged in sale
3 days ago

HS2 achieves first diesel-free construction site

Skanska Costain STRABAG JV runs Kilburn site with green kit
3 days ago

Administration confirmed at House by Urban Splash

160 jobs lost following "operational issues" at modular factory
4 days ago

Network Rail fined £1.4m after worker crushed by track machines

Judge highlights "many layers of failure" within site management
4 days ago

Kier picked for £350m Leatherhead regen plan

Property arm to draw up plans to redevelop two large town centre sites
4 days ago

Two seriously injured in London steelwork collapse

Two steel erectors left fighting for their lives after collapse at Ardmore site
4 days ago

Urban Splash modular staff start looking for new jobs

Work stops at House by Urban Splash factory and housing sites
4 days ago

Building facade specialist CMS goes into administration

Building envelope firm had turnover of £43m
5 days ago

Office work uplift returns construction output to growth

New commercial work drives output uplift for the first time since the pandemic
4 days ago

More suppliers wanted on £683m waste power plant

Meet the buyer event for North London Heat and Power Project: Register now
5 days ago

Vistry Partnerships lands £128m London flats deal

Legal & General signs up firm for 480-flats over five buildings in Wandsworth
5 days ago

HS2 Project Bank Accounts “not worth paper they are written on”

Subcontractors furious after payment protection promises evaporate in wake of Roadbridge collapse
5 days ago

Taylor Wimpey to tear down half-built £48m Hackney Wick scheme

Concrete frame to be demolished after discovery of "potential structural issue"
5 days ago

Data centre work lifts TClarke orders to record high

Orders hit £585m, more than £100m on last year
5 days ago

BAM lands largest ever fit-out job

Firm to fit-out landmark 12-storey Edinburgh St James Quarter 'ribbon' hotel
6 days ago

Winners revealed for £1.1bn demolition framework

Pagabo confirms 29 firms on new deal: Full list
6 days ago

Spie boss joins United Living as new MD of infrastructure

United Living rebrands Fastflow Energy and Pipelines businesses
6 days ago

Vinci/McAlpine JV wins £90m rehab hospital

Main contract award for National Rehabilitation Centre
6 days ago

Phoenix ME forecast revenue to rebound by 20%

London M&E specialists expects to return to around £200m revenue this year after set back last year
5 days ago

Roadbridge UK went down owing £60m

Supply chain owed £22.5m with little chance of any return
6 days ago

Bid race for tunnels on £150m Tube station upgrade

Bidders day on 27 May for Elephant and Castle capacity upgrade tunnels
7 days ago

ISG joins structural steel re-use project

Project aims to cost out business model for whole value chain from client to demolition contractor
6 days ago

Major hotel plan for Birmingham Central Methodist Hall

Three-storey rooftop extension will form part of historic hall restoration
6 days ago

Contractor services