Opinion: Time for change as majors suffer £850m loss

Aaron Morby 11 years ago
Share

There can be little doubt that big name contractors suffered more pain than expected coming out of the last recession.

Seven major contractor businesses have emerged like walking wounded after jointly running up a staggering £850m loss.

Much of this may be down to Balfour Beatty and Vinci, but the extent of the malaise calls in to question the quality of management and risk control processes during the downturn.

Such staggering losses contrast starkly with the volume house builders who are now enjoying a bumper crop of record profits and the help of a Government under intense political pressure to coax them into building more.

Not so magnificent seven Seven of the best house builders
Firm Loss Turnover % loss
on sales
Firm Profit Turnover Profit
margin
Balfour Beatty Constn £391m £6.6bn 6% Barratt £565m £3.8bn 15%
Vinci UK £217m £1bn 22% Berkeley £540m £2.12bn 25%
Sir Robert McAlpine £108m £862m 12.5% Persimmon £475m £2.6bn 18%
Laing O’Rourke Europe £58m £1.7bn 3% Taylor Wimpey £450m £2.7bn 17%
ISG £28m £1.6bn 1.7% Redrow £213m £1.15bn 19%
Morgan Sindall* £27m £1.1bn 2.4% Bellway* £159m £831m 19%
BAM Nuttall £20m £774m 2.6% Bovis £133m £809m 16%
*half-year

The industry is now in a two-speed recovery.

At the front are the country’s leading house builders who have shrugged off their land legacy and debt problems since the 2008/09 housing crash. Two of the best are each serving up stunning pre-tax profits of over £500m a year.

The few publicly-listed volume contractors that doggedly stuck to the traditional and once unfashionable model of running contracting alongside housing businesses are also in good shape to ride the recovery.

And those that can, like Willmott Dixon and Wates, are rolling out more development-led business as a strategy to improve the quality of profits.

In the slower lane, the phrase legacy project is often used to explain away present problems, but this is disguising something more troubling about the past and the future.

Already tight for cash, the recovery is asking big questions of the majors.

They see clients loathe to front-load project payment, Government tightening up on supply chain payment and the rising use of project bank accounts which are all leaving little opportunity to make a living holding onto others cash.

At the same time subcontractor cost inflation shows little sign of abating.

It means the cash flow squeeze is here to stay and it is hard to see better times ahead unless the majors ring the changes.

The brutal fact is the UK business model that sees main contractors take on high project risk for a 1-2% margin is simply not viable any longer.

It must be abandoned for sanity to prevail.

Clients may be moaning about outturn costs on projects now, but they simply are too used to projects being subsidised by loss-making supply chains.

Despite anecdotes that clients are considering stalling the odd marginal scheme, there is still plenty of headroom for a decent profit as a glance at most developers’ accounts testifies.

It would be smart for clients to work much more closely with contractors to understand cash and risk profiles as a starting point.

It would be even smarter for clients to allow main contractors to start pricing building work at a 4% margin.

Then everybody would have a chance to invest in building better and faster.

 

Latest news

Contractors forced into weekly price checks as volatility grows

Build costs up by nearly 6% in first quarter with further rises expected
11 minutes ago

Rydon losses deepen as remediation spend hits £31m

Losses widen to £4.9m as building safety work costs mount
23 minutes ago

Hunt for developer to restart stalled Broad Marsh site

Plan to start work on stalled Nottingham mixed-use quarter by 2028
50 minutes ago

Winchmore wins brickwork package on Kori care home

Specialist highlights benefits of long-term relationships with main contractors
3 minutes ago

Willmott Dixon brings development under one roof

Willmott Dixon Developments brings together existing operations
21 hours ago

Dalkia to deliver green hydrogen plant in Cumbria

Construction to start this summer at Barrow-in-Furness site
21 hours ago

Capital&Centric to lead £50m Plymouth civic centre revival

Plan advances to convert landmark 14-storey tower to 144 build-to-rent flats
20 hours ago

Barry Dodd takes charge at PJ Hegarty UK business

UK turnover set to hit £110m this year
18 hours ago

10 contractors paired with new hospital jobs worth £14bn

Skanska lands two jobs as RAAC rebuilds move to front of programme
1 day ago

Retentions axe will take three years to fall

Payments Bill sets out transition period before cash retentions finally outlawed
24 hours ago

Morgan Sindall wins lead role in £25m Andover theatre build

Council lines up June contract signing for new 400-seat venue
1 day ago

Twenty firms could face charges over Grenfell fire

Police files set to be submitted to prosecutors by September
2 days ago

Cost to complete HS2 hits £102.7bn

Government vows to get tough on contract claims as budget busted again
2 days ago

Funding boost for construction V Levels

More money, subjects and work placements in shake-up for vocational education
1 day ago

Mace Construct chief executive to step down

Jason Millett to leave in December but retain board seat at Mace Consult
2 days ago

Over 90 jobs axed as Falkirk steelwork firms collapse

Administrators called in at AIM Engineering & Fabrication Group and Hescott Engineering
2 days ago

Keady Construction lands £150m Stockport resi scheme

Construction to start in first quarter of 2027 for developer Amstone
2 days ago

Forterra plans brick and block price hikes

Materials giant to implement "pricing surcharges" from June
2 days ago

Renew snaps up electricity design specialist EDES

Engineering contractor targets grid boom with latest takeover
2 days ago

Sixteen win £1bn Southern Gas Networks deal

Clancy Docwra and Network Delivery Associates win places on all four lots
2 days ago

Kier submits plan for £60m Ellesmere Port school rebuild

RAAC-hit 1,000 place Catholic high school set for full demolition and replacement
2 days ago

Statom Holdings posts increased turnover and profits

Results for whole group highlight landmark year of growth
3 days ago

Morrisroe order book jumps 40% after Villa Park and Battersea wins

Diversified concrete frame specialist banks £340m order book after margin recovery last year
3 days ago

Trial date set after passer-by killed by falling window pane

Four firms to appear in court after glass fell 15 storeys from luxury tower
3 days ago

Norwich’s first build-to-rent scheme approved

£80m Victoria Gardens plan will deliver 432 rented homes
3 days ago

Dalkia lands M&E deal at £300m Children’s Cancer Centre

Major package award at Sisk site as piling work due to complete this month
3 days ago

London office fit-out second most pricey in the world

High-spec fit-outs now cost nearly £4,400 per sq m as occupiers chase top quality workspace
6 days ago

Developers called up for £10bn Old Oak mega-scheme

Race starts to find developer partner by spring 2027 to deliver 8,000 homes
6 days ago

Speller Metcalfe replaces Curo on £18m leisure job

Fenland council acts swiftly to keep Manor Leisure Centre on track
6 days ago

Bachy and Kilnbridge team up for ground-to-frame offer

New UrbanCore venture to target complex basement and structural packages
6 days ago