TfL slammed for £900m Tube upgrade cost overrun

Aaron Morby 8 years ago
Share

The London Assembly has blamed Transport for London for gross mismanagement of a signalling contract with Bombardier setting the Tube modernisation programme back five years.

An investigation into the failed signalling contract said a catalogue of management failings and errors left the District, Circle, Metropolitan, Hammersmith & City line upgrade nearly £900m over budget.

TfL ultimately paid £85m to cancel the contract with Bombardier Transport in 2013, two years after appointment. The report estimates that £67m of the settlement was wasted expenditure.

A culmination of nearly three years’ work scrutinising TfL’s sub-surface upgrade programme, the budget and performance committee report highlights how poor commercial expertise and a lack of IT procurement skills left TfL ill-prepared to appoint a suitable contractor, and vulnerable enough to be duped into a contract which Bombardier was never able to deliver.

The critical report highlights a culture where TfL management was only interested in presenting good news and was in denial about the progress and effectiveness of the programme, allowing it to continue for much longer than it should have.

The committee concluded that neither TfL nor Bombardier’s management teams were up to the task of managing the programme.

John Biggs AM, Chairman of the Budget and Performance Committee, said: “What is most remarkable about this affair is that no-one in TfL has been held to account, and the Mayor, who chairs its board, serenely and indifferently acts as if a £900m increase to the budget isn’t an issue.

“In government, heads – political or official – would roll after such financial mismanagement.  At TfL the key players have been promoted and nobody was to blame. It is a scandal.”

Transport for London’s Signal Failure report

KPMG audit – Lessons learned

TfL’s procurement process was not well thought out. Most significantly, its scoring system for evaluating bids was flawed. This meant that by significantly underbidding its competition on price, Bombardier was almost certain to be taken forward, regardless of how it scored in the technical areas of the evaluation.

Furthermore, TfL seemed to change its procurement process as it went along. If TfL had followed the process as outlined in the tender notice, then neither Bombardier nor the firm that finished second would have made the cut. By the time the field had been narrowed to two bidders, Bombardier was offering a lot more and for a lot less. If Bombardier could deliver what it was offering, then the case for appointing Bombardier was compelling.

Unfortunately, as KPMG noted “the capability of the supplier to deliver these benefits had not been adequately demonstrated or interrogated”. TfL has openly admitted it agreed a “bad contract”. The payment and penalty regimes within the contract were aligned to spend, rather than progress. This meant that in ending the contract, TfL was required to pay Bombardier a sum based on how much it had spent on the programme and not on the value of the work it had produced.

Latest news

Employee-owned Neilcott staff share £250,000 payout

Employee-owned building contractor sales jump 38% to £139m
9 hours ago

Geoffrey Osborne supply chain hit for £26m

More than 500 suppliers and subcontractors left holding unpaid bills
3 days ago

Race for £800m South West Wales framework

Up to 16 firms face fight to renew spots on regional contractors framework
16 hours ago

SME contractors agree 4% pay rise for site workers

Workers will also get an extra day of holiday
3 days ago

South East expansion paying off for Meldrum Group

Turnover up to £55m as North East based contractor expands national coverage
9 hours ago

Wates boosts paternity leave to 12 weeks

Latest leave benefits apply from first day of working for contractor
9 hours ago

Taylor Wimpey chief honoured with CBE

Jennie Daly recognised in King's Birthday honours
2 days ago

Labour to mothball £320m A27 job to fix potholes

Manifesto confirms Arundel Bypass canned as "poor value for money"
3 days ago

Lendlease’s £1.9bn Smithfield Birmingham scheme approved

Initial work to start later this year despite questions over Lendlease's degree of involvement
3 days ago

Crest Nicholson rejects £650m Bellway bid

Second Bellway approach rebuffed
4 days ago

Hill submits £800m East London estate rebuild plan

Over 1,900 homes to be built in five phase at Teviot Estate in Poplar
4 days ago

Plan approved for 8,500-seat Edinburgh indoor arena

Construction expected to start next year once a contractor is appointed
3 days ago

Statom starts on £25m Bristol Airport precast car park

Major work package on transport upgrade being overseen by Griffiths Farrans JV
4 days ago

Build problems plunge Crest Nicholson to a £31m loss

House builder unearths more defects on completed sites
4 days ago

Rebooted Amey lifts contract win rate to 1 in 3 bids

Amey chief says firm exceeded expectations in first year under new owners
4 days ago

BAM Nuttall fined £2.3m after worker drowned

Court hears how series of safety failures led to tragedy
5 days ago

OCU buys Scottish civils contractor RJ McLeod

Deal takes multi-utility infrastructure specialist revenue to over £800m
5 days ago

£220m plan to restore secret wartime tunnels approved

Tunnels under High Holborn to become cultural exhibition space
5 days ago

Galliford Try wins £69m Scottish school job

Deal sealed on Paisley Grammar School project in Renfrewshire
4 days ago

Balfour wins design for £690m Skye transmission job

Main work contract for 137km power line to be awarded later this year
5 days ago

Student and resi developer Fortis goes under

Cheshire based developer follows construction arm into liquidation
5 days ago

Construction output falls for third month running

Heavy rain and strong winds blamed for sharp fall in activity in April
5 days ago

Plan in for Leeds 27-storey block of flats

390 flats planned at former Morgan Sindall office site
5 days ago

Firms readied for £1.5bn Parliament estate upkeep deal

Invitation to tender due to go out next month
6 days ago

Amey switches kit supplier

Deal with HSS was worth £24.5m a year to rental specialist
5 days ago

Track workers scatter to avoid runaway rail trolley

Track trolley careers 1km towards work site
5 days ago

Direct delivery model pays off as Murphy profit soars to £67m

Group operating margin jumps from 3% to 5% in record year
6 days ago

Ex-Galliard boss to lead Battersea next building phase

Don O’Sullivan joins as plans advance to start phase 3C of power station redevelopment
6 days ago

£100m Digbeth 33-storey flats job out to bid

483 flats will be delivered for Clarion housing association
6 days ago

Van Elle fined £233,000 after piling rig kills driver

Court hears how tragedy was caused by poorly maintained plant
6 days ago

Contractor services