Opinion: Huge Balfour fine is a worry for all contractors

Grant Prior 10 years ago
Share

Eyebrows must have been raised at construction companies across the country when Preston Crown Court handed out a £2.6m safety fine last week.

Balfour Beatty Utility Solutions was hit with the massive penalty following the death of a worker in a trench collapse.

The verdict came just weeks after sentencing guidelines were changed for safety breaches.

And we could now be entering a new era of much larger fines for firms of all sizes.

Improving site safety is always the number one priority in construction.

But is simply ramping up court fines the best way to improve things?

There is a also a huge question mark over what happens to the money pulled-in by the courts.

If it was put towards more mandatory site safety training then no-one could argue about bigger penalties.

But the suspicion remains that this could be another revenue raising exercise by a Government keen on replenishing its coffers.

Major contractors have done more than most to improve safety. Larger sites are better run than smaller ones.

Awful cases still surface with mainly smaller companies showing complete contempt for safety rules.

These higher fines will not deter firms like that – they will simply fold the business and walk away from their responsibilities.

Perhaps a better way forward is holding more individuals accountable at the smaller end of the construction market.

While for larger companies a combination of appropriate fines and enforced training improvements – with a court appointed budget – would be a more effective solution in the long run.

Massive fines make good headlines for the safety authorities.

But simply taking millions from a company could be counter productive when that cash could be channeled into improving site conditions and saving more lives.

Latest news

McLaren seals go-ahead for £2bn York Central scheme

Phase one work to start next year when site investigation works finish
10 hours ago

M&J Evans moves into new market as profits jump

Housing groundworks specialist expands into utilities sector
9 hours ago

Berkeley calls for urgent stamp duty reform in Budget

London house builder wants 1% cap for first-time buyers and downsizers
9 hours ago

Housing activity dives 5% in July as construction stagnates

Total new work output falls 0.4% in July as industry bumps along the bottom
9 hours ago

RSK buys £61m turnover highways contractor MSF

Expanding group takes on another 175 staff in latest deal
10 hours ago

OCU smashes through £1bn revenue barrier

Organic growth hits 25% as order pipeline passes £4bn
1 day ago

Higgins cleared to restart stalled Ealing estate rebuild

Firm brought on board to finish final 400 homes on Green Man estate regeneration
1 day ago

Consultant RLB cuts staff numbers

Employees left reeling by sudden round of redundancies
1 day ago

£2bn London Vauxhall Square tower trio approved

Nearly 3,000 homes, co-living units and student beds planned across seven buildings
1 day ago

Seddon replaces Vistry on £40m Salford resi scheme

Council lines up contractor switch for 144-home Ordsall project
1 day ago

Worker died under two tonnes of soil in trench collapse

Two firms fined £1.1m and contracts manager given suspended jail sentence
2 days ago

80 firms win places on £350m Fusion21 repairs framework renewal

Wates, Mears, Equans and Axis among firms named on four-year UK deal
1 day ago

Infrastructure demand helps Clancy to record results

Strong work pipeline and cash position boosts investment in training and plant
2 days ago

McGee boss Fossey takes top job at Permasteelisa

Specialist engineering chief moves to lead global façade giant
2 days ago

Torsion Construction went down owing suppliers £15m

Hundreds of subcontractors left holding unpaid invoices
2 days ago

London Mayor backs 3,000-home Beckton gasworks regeneration

Approval unlocks £250m enabling programme at east London riverside site
2 days ago

Plan lodged to turn BT Tower into 400-room hotel

Landmark retrofit will create 1,000 construction jobs and reopen tower to public
2 days ago

£1bn heatwave hit sparks resilience spending call

Civil engineers push for national review to put hard numbers on benefits of climate adaptation
2 days ago

Vistry pitches plan to unlock 30,000 homes a year

Choice-led shared ownership model would combine buyer mortgages with institutional capital
3 days ago

Contractor hunt for £50m South Wales link road

Council to start procurement for 1.2km Cynon Gateway route near Aberdare
3 days ago

Plans lodged for one of Europe’s tallest student towers

Scape's 851-bed Elephant & Castle scheme rises to 45 storeys
3 days ago

Wales housing giant to start race for £750m contractor deal

Codi Group seeks builder line-up for new homes and refurbishment pipeline
3 days ago

Conlon lands £18m Wigan SEND school

Employee-owned firm secures one of its biggest education jobs to date
3 days ago

London Square lands homes role on major Waterloo scheme

Developer picked for Royal Street scheme in planned life sciences district
3 days ago

Security patrols stepped-up to fight cable theft

Pro-active patrols on East Coast Main Line to deter thieves
3 days ago

Kier storms August contracts league with £530m haul

Thames Water job helps contractor sweep to top of monthly rankings
4 days ago

Building safety Gateway 2 applications soar as levy looms

Building Safety Regulator workload jumps by more than 100 live cases ahead of October levy
4 days ago

McLaughlin & Harvey lands £70m Holborn Circus office job

Main works to start later this year after Erith completes demolition
4 days ago

Tilbury Douglas gets green light for £30m Leeds SEND school

Firm is in line for Broomfield specialist learning centre job
4 days ago

Plans to slash paperwork for company reports

Government looks at cutting "nonsensical" corporate reporting rules
4 days ago