Costs quadruple on Carillion tram-train project

Grant Prior 3 years ago
Share

A tram-train scheme being built by Carillion in South Yorkshire has seen its budget quadruple and is running two-and-half-years late.

A report from watchdogs at the National Audit Office has revealed the scale of delays and cost overruns on the Sheffield to Rotherham route.

When the scheme was first mooted in May 2012 the initial cost to modify the national rail network to allow trams to run on it was estimated at £18.7m with a completion date of December 2015.

That has now been revised to a cost of £75.1m with work due to be finished by May 2018.

Cost increases have been blamed on additional works to the original spec and work being more technically challenging that expected.

Carillion did not actually start on site until January 2016 and the budget quickly rose because:

  • The original cost estimate had errors due to the under‑developed design
  • The design stage had to be further extended because of the complex integration of national rail and tramway technologies
  • The electrification design and safety case work was more complex than expected
  • The costs of dealing with the poor condition of assets was higher than expected
  • The technical innovation demanded by the project’s objectives needed more time and expert resources than the original estimate. Network Rail had to deviate from 12 industry infrastructure design standards to accommodate the tram‑train service

Ministers considered cancelling the project in July 2016 and a possible re-tendering of heavy rail infrastructure works but it was decided to press ahead.

Tram-train services are now expected to begin in summer 2018.

The project has now hit 19 construction milestones with six remaining.

Carillion declined to comment on the NAO report.

 

Latest news

Plans go in for 42 acre London food market

Billingsgate, Spitalfields and Smithfield to get a new home in Dagenham
4 hours ago

Premier Inn restarts construction work on 35 sites

Hotel giant committed to long term expansion plans
6 hours ago

Leading brick makers to axe 600 jobs

Ibstock and Forterra restructure businesses to meet forecast fall in demand
10 hours ago

Kier Highways and Seddon reinstated to Prompt Payment Code

Contractors now keeping to pledge to pay 95% of suppliers within 60 days
9 hours ago

London fit-out firm Square Metre in administration

Fifty jobs cut as lockdown tips £32m fit-out firm over the edge
10 hours ago

Last webinar for contractors interested in £600m plant

Final procurement information event before OJEU notice next month
10 hours ago

Offsite system to cut staircase construction times by 80%

New integrated balustrade system added before precast stairs lifted into place on site
1 day ago

Arup bags job to re-open Cardiff city centre

Arup plans to improve public spaces, repurposed streets and digital infrastructure
1 day ago

Hard-hat mounted cough guard will help protect site workers

New product from JSP will help keep sites safe
1 day ago
JSP Ltd

Keep the industry updated by joining the Enquirer Directory

Membership lets construction know you are open for business now or in the future
2 years ago

Balfour Beatty to start £355m Hull A63 scheme

All systems go for delayed Castle Street upgrade to transform Hull
1 day ago

Contractors face data danger fighting covid contract disputes

Redundancies could see project knowledge lost
1 day ago

Mace bags role on £39bn Northern Powerhouse Rail plan

Firm takes lead on project controls, project, stakeholder and commercial management
2 days ago

Cash flow fears spark call for another delay to VAT changes

Thousands of firms unaware tax change could cut cash flow by 20%
2 days ago

Driver unveils changes at the top

Mark Wheeler takes helm as Gordon Wilkinson steps down as CEO
1 day ago

ISG mobilises for £17m north London town hall fit-out

First phase of £150m Waltham Forest Town Hall redevelopment starts
1 day ago

Morrison wins £42m Scottish factory of the future

Work to start this summer on National Manufacturing Institute Scotland.
1 day ago

London mayor loans Mount Anvil £50m to boost building

New partnership to boost housing and construction in the capital
2 days ago

Henley Construct lands £12m Croydon housing contract

Demolition to start imminently to revamp street market site
1 day ago

Piling problems force BAM to tear down building frame

Major construction issues delay new £65m Sheffield University faculty building
2 days ago

Industry leaders draw up roadmap to recovery

Construction able to bounce back stronger and more productive within two years
3 days ago

Leaking diamond synchrotron roof to be replaced

Hunt starts for roofing contractor to strip and replace vast circular roof
2 days ago

ISG director leaves to head-up Structure Tone London division

Danny Blakeston joins rival as London managing director
2 days ago

Balfour sets-up “New Normal” Covid-19 taskforce

Contractor focuses on cash discipline and improving productivity on sites
2 days ago

Hinkley C team hits key target despite Covid-19 curbs

BYLOR delivers record pour on second reactor base with reduced workforce
2 days ago

Seven win new highways geotechnical framework

Highways England's new geotechnical framework worth £91m over four years
2 days ago

Plans lodged for £120m Nottingham hotel scheme

Grade II listed Guildhall to become 162-bed luxury hotel
2 days ago

Fit-out firm fined £1.1m after ladder fall

Engineer needs transfusion after massive blood loss caused by fall injury
5 days ago

SIG management blunders rack-up £112.7m loss

New boss promises growth strategy after PwC called in to investigate divisional forecasts
5 days ago

Union calls for construction workers to wear masks

Unite demands revisions to Construction Leadership Council guidelines
6 days ago

Contractor services