Tribunal victory “blows a hole” in agency payroll model

Grant Prior 7 years ago
Share

Unite has won a major legal victory at the employment appeal tribunal (EAT) in its battle against bogus self-employment and the use of payroll companies.

The union said the decision “blows a hole” in the way workers are employed on many sites via agencies using payroll companies.

Unite took the case on behalf of pipe fitter Russ Blakely against the employment agency On-Site Recruitment Solutions Limited and payroll company Heritage Solutions City Ltd.

The original case over the unlawful deduction of wages and employer’s national insurance contributions as well as the non-payment of holiday pay was rejected by Reading employment tribunal.

But the appeal to the EAT was upheld making it an important test case.

The employment appeal tribunal found:

  • The original tribunal was wrong to decide that Blakely was not a worker
  • When determining whether there was a contract (part of the test of whether someone is a worker) the tribunal must consider the intentions of the worker and all surrounding circumstances, not just the intentions of the employer
  • There was a contract between Blakely and On-Site (the agency) – importantly, the use of a payroll company did not circumvent this relationship
  • Blakely (and therefore other agency workers being paid through payroll companies) could be a worker of the agency, the payroll company or both.

Unite assistant general secretary Howard Beckett said: “This is a groundbreaking victory secured by Unite’s Strategic Case Unit in the fight against bogus self-employment in construction and other sectors.

“It blows a hole in the way that employment agencies hide behind payroll and umbrella companies and pretend that they are not responsible for the employment of the workers they recruit.

“The fact the EAT held that a worker could be jointly employed by two organisations is a game changer in the campaign against bogus self-employment.

“Unite will be ensuring that the EAT’s findings are fully utilised to ensure that other workers are not denied their basic employment rights or exploited by agencies and parasitical payroll companies.

“This decision sends out an unequivocal message to all those involved in bogusly self-employing workers, Unite and our Strategic Case Unit is on your case.

“Whilst this isn’t the type of appeal that a mistreated worker might bring on their own, employers should beware, as Unite members have the unwavering support of the country’s largest trade union.”

The case has now been returned to the employment tribunal, to determine who was Blakely’s employer, whether it was On-Site, Heritage or both.

The tribunal will also decide on his compensation, which is expected to be around £2,500.

Latest news

Alun Griffiths set to rescue firm he sold for £36m

Tarmac to hand back Welsh civils contractor after five years of losses
2 days ago

Landsec to pump £2bn into new house building drive

Developer to build 6,000 homes as it sells offices to fund new schemes
2 days ago

Severfield to start steel on McAlpine car battery site

Specialist to start on £4bn site next month after steel package signed-off
2 days ago

Construction Manager of the Year crowned

Jason Hunt of Willmott Dixon wins for work on Bristol concert hall
2 days ago

Tide gets go-ahead for over 1,000-home London scheme

Volumetric expert gains planning for co-living homes scheme in Southwark
3 days ago

Vital Energi lands £250m Gatwick decarbonisation deal

Five-year programme to switch airport away from gas heating
2 days ago

Construction output flickers into life in March

First quarter activity flatlines after slow start to year
3 days ago

Skanska lifts margin to 4.3% as profit hits £78m

Infrastructure and FM drive near-tripling of profits
4 days ago

Mayor backs 46-storey student tower at Canary Wharf

City Hall overturns Tower Hamlets council rejection of 912-bed scheme
4 days ago

Plans go in for 100 acre Port of Tilbury expansion

Construction could start next year on site the size of 70 football pitches
3 days ago

Inland Homes creditors face £38m hit

Administrator confirms no cash for supply chain
4 days ago

Durkan dogged by legacy jobs despite return to trading profit

Durkan scales down new homes contracting to focus on retrofit work
4 days ago

Munnelly founder hands over CEO role to son

Paul David Munnelly steps up to CEO as father becomes chairman
3 days ago

Barking build to rent towers face rebuild

Major remedial work needed on resi scheme built by Shapoorji Pallonji UK Ltd
4 days ago

London new home starts plunge 38% as Building Safety Act bites

Capital only region to see Q1 fall in NHBC new home registrations
5 days ago

Sureserve swoops for rival compliance outfit Kinovo in £56m deal

Recommended cash offer will take AIM listed contractor private
4 days ago

Crown Golf tees up £1bn plan to build 3,000 homes on course land

Major housing plan for spare land on eight UK courses
4 days ago

Green light for Peterborough Station Quarter £48m revamp

First phase to start before the end of the year
4 days ago

Morgan Sindall starts £38m Caerphilly leisure hub

New swimming pool and health suite forms part of town regeneration plan
4 days ago

145 firms win places on £800m building safety framework

Fusion21 confirms latest winners: Full list
5 days ago

Higgins Homes and site workers face manslaughter charges

Contractor and four site staff charged after woman killed by falling pallet of bricks
6 days ago

Operator spots cracked mast on Hinkley tower crane

Hinkley Point C contractor hit with safety notice over failed mast pin and cracks
5 days ago

Countdown starts for £1bn Birmingham highways bid race

Council will break-up mega framework into five lots
5 days ago

Acciona wins £400m Thames waterworks upgrade

Lea Valley Coppermills water treatment works to get full overhaul
5 days ago

Pension giants pledge £25bn for infrastructure push

Seventeen pension providers pledge to invest in projects
5 days ago

Safety row over London tower ducking fire regs by 30cm

Fire union calls on Mayor to block Bromley flats plan over single staircase
5 days ago

Midgard lands £145m deal to build Edition Birmingham

Construction to start shortly on twin residential towers
6 days ago

McAleer & Rushe set to break £500m turnover barrier

Pre-tax profit jumped 16% to £46m last year
6 days ago

Top design team picked for £2.5bn York Central scheme

Massive city centre regen scheme moves to detailed design
6 days ago

MoD to bid £100m command HQ enabling works

Hertfordshire joint forces command centre expansion advances
6 days ago

Contractor services