Carillion directors ‘contemptuous’ of pension funding

Aaron Morby 6 years ago
Share

Watchdog MPs have accused Carillion directors of being contemptuous of their pensions obligations in their probe in to the collapse of the group.

Carillion directors refused to give an inch to the pension schemes, says pension committee chairman Frank Field
Carillion directors refused to give an inch to the pension schemes, says pension committee chairman Frank Field

The work and pensions select committee also slams the pensions regulator for doing too little too late after being called on to intervene on two occasions.

About 29,000 members of Carillion’s 13 pension schemes face cuts to their benefits after the group collapsed last month with a pension shortfall that almost doubled to nearly £1bn in three years.

Letters published by the work and pensions select committee on Tuesday reveal the trustees wrote to the watchdog in 2010 and 2013 pleading for help to break a deadlock with Carillion over funding its plans.

But the regulator only opened a formal investigation into Carillion on 18 January three days after its collapse.

Frank Field MP, Chair of the Work and Pensions Committee, said: “These letters suggest the Carillion directors were contemptuous of their pensions obligations. Over two successive 15-month negotiations they refused to give an inch to the pension schemes.

“Their private pleading that the company could not afford more was in stark contrast to the rosy picture – and bumper dividends – being presented to the outside world. Richard Adam, the longstanding Finance Director, has particular questions to answer.

“With characteristic alacrity, the Pensions Regulator started its arduous process of chasing money down from Carillion a few days after it was formally announced there was no money left. I can only assume – and hope – they are going after some of those very generous bonuses.”

Key pension deadlock dates

2010 – Bullishness in public did not reflect private negotiating position

Despite a recent bullish results announcement and a 12% increase in dividends, Carillion maintained it could not afford to pay more than £23m per year for the pension deficit. The trustees had advice that a minimum of £35m was affordable.

Carillion pushed for a 15-year recovery plan when anything more than 10 years is considered exceptional.

Negotiations got no further than £25m per year, which the trustees considered “not acceptable” and “far less than … reasonable”.

2013 – ‘Take or leave it’

The 2013 letter said that an “impasse” had been reached in negotiations between the trustees and Carillion.

The trustees had proposed contributions of £65m per year over 14 years to meet a deficit they estimated at £770m.

Carillion made a “take it or leave it” offer of just £33.4m per year over 15 years. The company pushed for more optimistic assumptions which resulted in lower estimates of the deficit.

The trustees contended that Carillion had got weaker in recent years and wanted that reflected in calculations, but this was rejected by the company.

Carillion had “made no move from its original position throughout the whole negotiation process”. The trustees wrote to the regulator after the statutory 15-month negotiation period had passed warning that the pension schemes were falling behind relative to other Carillion stakeholders and taking a disproportionate amount of risk.

In a statement, the Pensions Regulator said: “When the trustees wrote to us in 2013 to say they could not agree funding plans with the company, we did intervene by threatening to use our powers unless a funding plan was agreed.

“Our intervention resulted in a significant increase in the amount of money the company was prepared to pay into the scheme. We believed this was reasonable based upon our understanding of the company’s trading strength as set out in its audited accounts.”

The evidence was released as MPs prepare to question KPMG, the company’s auditor, on Thursday.

Latest news

Plan in for £3bn Lincolnshire mega data centre

3.3m sq ft Humber Tech Park will be one of Europe's largest data centres
3 days ago

Green light for Digbeth 1,300 homes scheme

Warner’s Fields scheme to start with excavation and landscaping of the River Rea
3 days ago

Flagship biodiversity net gain scheme flawed

NAO warns Government's flagship green development scheme at risk of failure
2 days ago

£210m M3 Junction 9 upgrade gains consent

VolkerFitzpatrick to start work in early 2025 on Winnall roundabout, near Winchester
3 days ago

United Living wins 14-year L&Q homes repairs deal

Trafford housing upkeep deal worth £205m
3 days ago

£400m Lewisham resi-led scheme advances

Land deal paves way for Amro Partners' 1,000-home London scheme
3 days ago

McLaren gets go-ahead for Grade II listed Leeds student scheme

Springfield House to be revamped and two new wings added
3 days ago

Piling giant to fit people alarms on all rigs

Cementation Skanska upgrades site safety systems
3 days ago

Vistry to make £800m profit after subcontractor cost cuts

House builder bullish about shareholder returns after asking suppliers for discounts
4 days ago

Shareholders approve £2.5bn Barratt and Redrow merger

Final hurdle is for the competition regulator to approve the deal.
4 days ago

Green light for £80m Leith waterfront revamp

Build-to-rent homes and student accommodation scheme to be built
4 days ago

Tilbury Douglas clears Interserve legacy jobs to return to profit

Revenue tops £500m in first year as standalone contractor
4 days ago

Land deal paves way for Manchester civil service office hub

Government buys five acres at former Central Retail Park
3 days ago

Speller Metcalfe wins Wolverhampton library upgrade

Full works are due to start in the autumn
4 days ago

Skills shortage puts big infrastructure projects at risk

Government failing as an intelligent client and now over-reliant on consultancies
5 days ago

Contractors face further insulation board price hikes

Cost of PIR insulation boards set to rise another 10%
5 days ago

Henry Boot wins £36m Rotherham Markets job

Project involves upgrading existing market and building a new library
5 days ago

Keltbray hires new head of infrastructure procurement

Lukasz Olszewski will oversee rail, energy and highways business units
5 days ago

Tunnel fit out robot to revolutionise civils work

Costain and VVB Engineering part of innovative consortium
5 days ago

Funding deal for £86m wind turbine test centre

Latest investment at National Renewable Energy Centre in Blyth
5 days ago

Plan in for Manchester ‘upside-down’ 18-storey tower

Landmark cantilevered NXQ building plan for city Northern Quarter
6 days ago

London 25km Super Sewer hooked up for commissioning

Tideway completes connection to existing Lee Tunnel sewer system
6 days ago

£200m Lincoln ring-road approved

North Hykeham Relief Road granted planning permission
6 days ago

£1bn Manchester Airport City plan rebooted as new sci-tech hub

Plan pivots from offices to science and manufacturing campus, called MIX Manchester
6 days ago

Record results at maintenance specialist Renew

Infrastructure maintenance work continues to pay off for contractor
6 days ago

Barhale lands £21m shaft scheme for Thames Water

Civils specialist bags latest upgrade deal on Thames Water Ring Main
6 days ago

Caddick names new north east director

Former Laing O'Rourke project lead joins Yorkshire contractor
6 days ago

Mount Anvil wins London Camden estate rebuild

Deverloper wins £133m Bacton Phase 2 development in Gospel Oak
7 days ago

London Met Uni seeks firm for £280m estate upgrade

A single partner contractor will deliver 10-year building upgrade plan
7 days ago

Top 30 M&E contractors set for growth – ranking

Growth in data centres and commercial refits creates optimism for year ahead
7 days ago

Contractor services