Insurers slam fire test regime for building materials

Grant Prior 6 years ago
Share

The insurance industry has attacked the “utter inadequacy” of laboratory based fire safety tests on building materials.

ABI tests on cladding with vents
ABI tests on cladding with vents

The Association of British Insurers (ABI) commissioned the Fire Protection Association (FPA) to carry out research in the wake of the Grenfell tragedy.

The experiment recreated  “more realistic building conditions than those in which the standard tests are done”.

The ABI said real-life factors overlooked by the current official testing regime include:

  • Test fires which are only made up of wood. In modern blazes, around 20% of the materials involved are plastic.
  • Cladding materials are sometimes tested as a sealed unit, whereas when fitted on a building they often include gaps, and cover a far more extensive area.
  • Materials tested will be in manufacturer condition, but during their actual use will often be pierced by things such as vents or ducts.

The ABI called for an end to the use of all but non-combustible materials in construction in its submission to the Hackitt review.

It also demanded reform of the testing regime to replicates real world conditions to provide genuine evidence of how materials perform in a fire.

Huw Evans, Director General of the ABI, said: “Dame Judith Hackitt’s important work post-Grenfell has already recognised the building control system is broken.

“This latest research is yet more evidence that fundamental reform is needed to keep our homes and commercial premises safe from fire.

“It is a matter of urgency that we create the right testing regime that properly replicates real world conditions and keeps pace with building innovation and modern design.”

Jonathan O’Neill, Managing Director of the Fire Protection Association said: “The results of this important research confirm long-held concerns by many in the fire sector that the current cladding test standard requires urgent review to ensure that systems that pass are reflective of the systems that are installed and of the risks to which they are exposed.

“We urge BSI (British Standards Institution) to urgently reconvene the group responsible for this standard to consider the results of this research and to make changes to the standard as required.”

TESTS AND RESULTS

THE ISSUE: Test fires are only made up of wood. In modern blazes, around 20% of the materials involved are plastic.

Test 1: Two fires were created with the same energy content, one purely built out of wood, the other containing 20% plastic.

The results: The flames created by the fire containing plastic had a flame length around 1 metre longer than the wooden fire; the temperatures involved were 100 degrees hotter and still increasing when the plastic-containing fire had to be extinguished because it was exceeding lab safety conditions.

The implications: As well as the ability of the fire containing plastic to spread faster and create higher temperatures, building materials such as aluminium lose a lot of their strength at higher temperatures. A lot of cladding, including that used on Grenfell Tower, is made up of aluminium composite panels.

 

THE ISSUE:  Cladding materials can be tested as a sealed unit, whereas when fitted on a building they often include gaps, and cover a far more extensive area.

Test 2: Fires were started at the bottom of three columns. One had no cladding or cover at all, the second had cladding fitted to create a void but with sealed edges and ends, the third was clad with a void, leaky sides and some ventilation at the top and bottom.

The results: Fire climbed 1.5 metres up the open face before burning out and self-extinguishing; the sealed cladding unit also saw fire climb a similar distance before it ran out of oxygen and self-extinguished; the unit where the cladding had gaps rapidly caught fire up the entire 6 metre height of the testing column.

The implications: The availability of oxygen makes a massive difference to how materials respond to fire. In well-ventilated voids, such as behind some cladding systems, the rate at which fire spreads can be greatly increased by a chimney effect. Any tests which restrict the availability of oxygen in a way that doesn’t happen on a full scale building will not be able to correctly assess how the materials will behave in practice.

 

THE ISSUE:  Materials tested will be in manufacturer condition, but during their actual use will often be pierced by things such as vents or ducts

Test 3: A section of wall and cladding was set up with a plastic vent installed – a common feature – and a fire started beneath the structure.

The results: Temperatures inside the vent indicated it was providing an almost instantaneous route for fire directly into the void between the wall and cladding, long before the time it would take fire to break through the outside cladding panels.

Implications: Fire safety, particularly in high rise buildings, often relies upon assumptions about how long it will take fire to penetrate certain areas of the building. The presence of fittings such as vents can make a big difference to how materials perform and how a fire will spread, and needs to be realistically modelled in testing.

Latest news

Lendlease puts construction arm up for sale

Radical global restructure to raise £2.3bn and focus on Australia
2 hours ago

Former Crossrail boss Mark Wild to lead HS2

Wild to bear down on spiralling costs and bring rejigged scheme in on time
20 hours ago

Receivers in at £125m Manchester tower developer

Domis Construction walked away from scheme following doubts over funding
2 days ago

Costain A1 £260m dualling job finally gets go-ahead

Ministers sat on planning inspectors report for nearly three years
7 hours ago

Election delays decision on Lower Thames Crossing

Planning decision on £1.2bn Luton airport expansion also pushed back six months
7 hours ago

Caddick steps-in at former Lane End housing job

Contractor to restart phase of £262m scheme hit by administration
7 hours ago

Plans in for Leeds iconic Tetley building revamp

Former brewing giant's HQ to become indoor market and offices
7 hours ago

BAM wins first phase of North Devon hospital revamp

New staff accommodation to kick-off hospital redevelopment
7 hours ago

McAlpine pulls out of £55m Carlisle Citadels project

University of Cumbria starts hunt for replacement contractor
5 days ago

Strabag UK suffers further big trading loss

Austrian contractor is gearing up for major presence in the UK market
4 days ago

Durham Uni picks UPP for £130m student scheme

Firm will deliver 1,000 self-catered bed spaces
4 days ago

Architects now upbeat after 10-months of work gloom

Larger practices see rising workloads in next three months
4 days ago

Motorist dies after collision with road paver

Police Scotland investigating fatal crash
5 days ago

McLaren Living appoints HG Construction for £69m scheme

Build to Rent scheme will transform former vacant car park site in Leeds city centre
5 days ago

Squibb liquidator probes £2m of “missing” plant

Machinery, cars and scrap metal have disappeared at demolition specialist
5 days ago

Galliford Try to re-enter affordable homes market

Contractor sets out new five-year plan to build margin to 4%
5 days ago

Former Sellar chief to lead civils contractor Kilnbridge

Owen Dannatt joins as new CEO as founder Dermot McDermott becomes Chairman
5 days ago

Hunt starts for nuclear fusion plant construction partner

Fusion energy plant to be built at West Burton coal power station site.
5 days ago

National Grid raises £7bn for big infrastructure upgrade

Rights issue to fund a major round of capital investment in energy infrastructure
5 days ago

Grenfell police probe to last at least until end of 2025

19 companies and 58 individuals could eventually face charges
6 days ago

Mace confirmed on £100m London office retrofit

Work underway on Helical's 100 New Bridge Street job near Ludgate Circus
6 days ago

Wylfa chosen for next big nuclear power station build

Government names Anglesey site for a large-scale gigawatt nuclear power plant.
6 days ago

Bowmer & Kirkland trading profit halves

Contractor buys HVAC specialist Adcock despite challenging market
6 days ago

Piling specialist Van Elle plans further job cuts

Piling specialist plans further cost savings in face of lower demand
6 days ago

Civils contractor A Catlow files administration notice

High voltage cable specialist lodges court notice
6 days ago

Green light for ARC Oxford lab campus

Work to start later this year on £40m Ascent building job
6 days ago

Stonehenge tunnel hit by another legal delay

Court upholds latest appeal against £1.7bn scheme by campaigners
1 week ago

Plans go in for huge Olympic Park construction hub

Bow Goods Yard could deliver 3.5m tonnes of materials a year to sites across London
1 week ago

40% affordable homes target for Labour’s new towns

Labour pledges to select new town sites by end of first year
1 week ago

Plan for £100m Liverpool Baltic station

Construction work could begin next year
1 week ago

Contractor services