Infrastructure project final costs average 80% above bid prices

Aaron Morby 6 years ago
Share

Infrastructure project outturn costs are running nearly 80% higher than winning tender prices, according to new project data.

 London 2012 games is considered a crowning success, yet the games cost over three times the original budget.  The evolution of the budget and the political and public acceptance of this overspend, compares starkly with attitudes to Crossrail at 26% over budget
London 2012 games is considered a crowning success, yet the games cost over three times the original budget. The evolution of the budget and the political and public acceptance of this overspend, compares starkly with attitudes to Crossrail at 26% over budget

An influential report from Institution of Civil Engineers, which publishes the fresh figures from 25 projects, warns that the sector is facing a twin market failure.

A combination of unforeseeable cost increases driven by both external and project risks and low contractor margins, depressed by fears of not winning major project work, has stifled innovation, skills and sustainability, warn senior engineers.

The regular failure to deliver to budget has prompted calls for mindset changes among clients about cost envelopes during early project planning, more detailed scoping and much fairer allocation of risk with contractors.

The report is published as contractors planning to deliver HS2 main civils packages are locked in talks to agree on final bid prices near original cost estimates.

A leading infrastructure contractor supplied figures for projects awarded between 2009 and 2018 on the proviso it remained anonymous.

Only one project was delivered within the original tender price, with project costs swelling by 80% on average above the original contract value on the rest

The ICE emphatically rules out excessive profit taking, pointing out pre-tax margins in construction fell from just under 3% in 2013 to an average of –0.9% in 2018.

Miles Ashley, Chair of the report’s Steering Group, said: “Industry and government need to work smarter, find ways to reduce the disparity between forecasts and outturns, but also to change the narrative and ensure the wider public, the end users, are also aware of the whole-life benefits these incredible infrastructure projects are bringing to them.”

Recommendations


  • Infrastructure owners should complete scope, design and exploration before work starts to avoid scope creep or retroactive changes, taking steps to include contractors in design at an early stage.
  • The Government and infrastructure owners must move away from capital cost as the most important metric when assessing project benefits, and recognise the importance of whole-life economic, social and environmental value.
  • All public infrastructure owners undertaking procurement must award contracts based on a cost estimate range, using a should-cost estimate as a reference point, with an amount of contingency allocated appropriate to the level of project maturity.
  • Principles set out in the Government Outsourcing Playbook should be mandatory for infrastructure owners, this includes infrastructure owners undertaking should-cost modelling to help inform their expectations and knowledge of appropriate tender prices during the procurement process.

Report: Reducing the gap between cost estimates and outturns for major infrastructure projects and programmes

Latest news

Balfour Beatty terminates Danny Sullivan labour deals

Around 500 workers on HS2 will be moved to alternative agencies or be taken on direct
2 days ago

Trio face prosecution after Hinkley site death

Main contractors and client to face charges over death of site supervisor
2 days ago

Buyers see recovery in house building sector

But civil and commercial work still in the doldrums
3 days ago

Apprentice saws-off thumb on hotel refurb site

Court hears how digit was reattached and teenager continued training with another firm
3 days ago

Laing O’Rourke tops June contracts league

£919m animal super lab dominates new orders
3 days ago

TSL turnover smashes £500m as profit almost trebles

Data centre and logistics contractor rises high on surging demand
3 days ago

Gleeson Homes chief exec leaves business after restructure

Management revamp after "challenging" year
3 days ago

Green light for 1,600-home Oldham town centre overhaul

Plans for over 1,600 homes across six regeneration sites approved
3 days ago

DSM wins Norwich city centre clearance job

Anglia Square shopping centre clearance for £300m scheme
3 days ago

13-year-old becomes UK’s youngest qualified digger driver

Grandson of Gallagher Group chairman sets industry record
3 days ago

Cubby reborn in £12m Svella-backed takeover

£50m revenue target set as 14 firms combine under new Cubby Group banner
4 days ago

North East NHS trusts plot £3bn health estate overhaul

Market engagement begins for major construction push across four trusts
4 days ago

HG goes green on cranes in £1.2m switch to battery power

Diesel-free crane drive cuts fuel bills by 94%
4 days ago

Developer fined £165,000 for fire safety failings

Firm ignored fire safety orders on apartment job in Preston
4 days ago

Bidding to start for £1.8bn North West framework

Contractors invited to bid for latest Procure Partnerships deal
4 days ago

Hill hits record £90m profit as homes pipeline swells

Build-to-rent push and £4.8bn contracting book to fuel next growth phase
4 days ago

Rayner unveils £39bn plan to build 300,000 social homes

Council building revival and rent reform feature in social and affordable homes plan
5 days ago

Keltbray bounces back with £3.2m profit

Tighter controls and smarter project selection fuel strong turnaround
5 days ago

VINCI JV wins 500-home twin town centre revamps

Chester Northgate phase 2 and Northwich Weaver Square schemes move to delivery stage
5 days ago

80 energy projects unlocked as Ofgem backs grid expansion

£24bn energy networks deal gets green light from regulator
6 days ago

How to see your stories on the Enquirer

Join our Suppliers and Buyers directory to get your news published
5 days ago

Henley lands Midland Mill revamp on Leeds tower scheme

Restoration of 18th-century mill kicks off on South Bank regeneration project
5 days ago

New boss at Eric Wright Civil Engineering

Gavin Hulme takes top job as Diane Bourne moves to group role
5 days ago

Pinewood submits £1bn data centre plan

Studio giant adds green and learning spaces to tech hub blueprint
6 days ago

Record results after TClarke goes private

Britain's biggest M&E contractor flourishes after de-listing
6 days ago

Dalkia lands £200m nuclear maintenance deal

1,000 nuclear FM staff to join M&E contractor
6 days ago

Construction comeback to outpace wider economy

Arcadis forecast fueled by spending review optimism
7 days ago

First steel goes up on giant car battery site

Severfield gets to work on McAlpine Somerset site
6 days ago

Permasteelisa wins cladding deal on Bovis city tower

Facade specialist lands package at 60 Gracechurch Street
6 days ago

Fox buys recycled asphalt specialist Fisher

Acquisition adds major recycled asphalt capacity in north west
6 days ago