NAO raps MoD for starting nuclear building jobs too early

Aaron Morby 1 year ago
Share

The Ministry of Defence has been criticised for its poor management of construction projects needed for Britain’s nuclear weapons programme.

MENSA nuclear warhead assembly facility at AWE's Burghfield site near Reading originally costed at £1.8bn
MENSA nuclear warhead assembly facility at AWE's Burghfield site near Reading originally costed at £1.8bn

According to the government spending watchdog decisions to start construction before final designs were signed off has led to delays of between one and six years, with costs increasing by £1.3bn.

The National Audit Office looked at three Defence Nuclear Estate projects together budgeted at £2.5bn.

  • MENSA: a new nuclear warhead assembly and disassembly facility, valued at £1.8bn, at Burghfield in Reading.
  • Core production capability facilities: upgraded facilities, costing at least £474m, at the Rolls Royce-operated site in Raynesway, Derby
  • Primary build facility: new facilities at the dockyard in Barrow-in-Furness, costing £240m to upgrade aging facilities and support improved submarine construction techniques.

Problems in the earlier and riskier stages of these projects caused delays and cost increases.

It said some of the designs may have been more costly than necessary, mainly as a result of construction starting before the requirements or designs were fully developed, and changes to the project management or commercial approach.

The way that the MoD set up the contracts also meant that it must foot the bill rather than share it with the contractors.

The NAO recognised unique challenges with the projects, including the need to comply with additional nuclear-related regulations, the limited pool of suppliers and the complexity of the designs.

But it said the MoD should have learnt more from the early stages of other nuclear infrastructure projects concluded in the UK and elsewhere.

Gareth Davies, the head of the NAO, said: “While these infrastructure projects are complex, the MoD has encountered similar challenges before in its nuclear work.

“Although it has recently introduced changes to enhance its oversight of the projects and improve its contracts with suppliers, it should have learnt earlier from past mistakes and the experience of others in the nuclear sector.

“Instead, the MoD’s failure to mitigate commercial and delivery risks early on has led to project delays and cost increases, as well as impacting its wider work.”

Similar challenges arose for the MoD in the 1980s and 1990s, as well as in American defence projects and UK civil nuclear projects, such as at Sellafield.

Latest news

Green light for City of London office tower

Hong Kong developer bangs drum for future of offices in Square Mile
10 hours ago

Morgan Sindall pushes 11,000 tonne tunnel: Video

155-metre curved concrete box tunnel pushed into place at 150cm per hour
18 mins ago

Taylor Woodrow starts on £100m recycling centre

Site team mobilises ahead of piling work starting in March
15 hours ago

B&K set for £125m Next mega-shed in Yorkshire

850,000 sq ft giant warehouse will be built in South Elmsall
5 mins ago

Homes England chief steps down

Nick Walkley to leave at the end of next month
22 hours ago

Falling prefab steel balcony kills worker

Court hears how 400kg steel structure fell during loading
19 hours ago

Galliford Try starts £23m Coventry student scheme

Latest university accommodation win in the city
21 hours ago

Sisk wins £260m Birmingham skyscraper

Moda picks Sisk for second major tower project in the city centre
2 days ago

First UK carbon neutral road improvement project

Innovative asphalt recycling generates 43% carbon reductions on first carbon neutral pavement scheme
1 day ago

ISG hires London fit-out veteran

Darran Brand joins Agility arm specialising in sub 50,000 sq ft projects
1 day ago

Kier bags £200m London road tunnels upkeep

Eight-year deal to maintain 10 tunnels and 106 pump stations
1 day ago

AECOM chief joins Kier as London building MD

David McKenzie to lead growth of London construction business
2 days ago

Brick and block sales continue to surge for Forterra

Products giant upgrades financial forecasts as performance exceeds expectations
1 day ago

Scaffolders take on 300 Government ‘kickstart’ youngsters

Fifty NASC contractors commit to industry work placement push
2 days ago
NASC

Plans in for £18m Newcastle hotel

8-storey Moxy hotel to be built next to St James' Park
24 hours ago

£760m confirmed for East West Rail next stage

£34m released for plan to reopen Northumberland line from Newcastle to Ashington
2 days ago

Strong trading lifts hirer P Flannery revenue to £116m

Revenue soars to record high for fast-growing plant hirer
2 days ago

Site demand soars for Covid killing spray tunnels

Battersea Power Station site latest to install personal protection tunnels
2 days ago

CSCS skills cards go virtual

Workers can now hold cards on their mobile phones
2 days ago

GMI starts final £27m phase of Sheffield office complex

Developer Scarborough Group International commits to latest scheme
2 days ago

St Modwen starts on speculative logistics site

Developer starts demolition work on major Basingstoke site
2 days ago

Keep the industry updated by joining the Enquirer Directory

Membership lets construction know you are open for business as recovery gathers momentum
1 week ago

Over 50 jobs axed as steelwork contractor collapses

Conder Allslade placed in voluntary administration
5 days ago

Henry Construction wins London City Road tower

Work to start shortly on 22-storey red-brick skyscraper project
5 days ago

Galliford Try poaches HS2 civils contract boss

David Lowery joins as operations director, responsible for highways
5 days ago

BAM bags £29m Dartford high school

Work to start on Stone Lodge School in Kent
5 days ago

Go-ahead for 850-home west London TfL scheme

Bollo Lane trackside high rise residential scheme to be built in Acton
6 days ago

Sinkhole swallows homes on Manchester street

Collapsed sewer blamed for 10ft sinkhole
5 days ago

Bouygues to build latest Tower Hamlets resi block

Construction to start in March on 100 per cent affordable development
6 days ago

Scaffolders plan strike action at British Steel works

Scunthorpe site faces disruption as scaffolders take strike action over pay
6 days ago

Contractor services