Emails reveal key Grenfell firms knew cladding would fail in blaze

Aaron Morby 5 years ago
Share

Emails revealed in the second day of evidence to the Grenfell Inquiry suggest that architect Studio E, contractor Rydon, facade subcontractor Harley and fire consultant Exova knew cladding panels would fail in the event of an external fire.

Emails reveal fire consultant, architect, main contractor and facade contractor new cladding would fail in external fire
Emails reveal fire consultant, architect, main contractor and facade contractor new cladding would fail in external fire

Insulation manufacturer Celotex – which itself has been accused of producing misleading market information about product performance – revealed a crucial email exchange regarding the use of fire stopping.

In emails between staff at the firms, a technical manager at Harley said: “there is no point in ‘fire stopping’, as we all know; the ACM will be gone rather quickly in a fire!”

In another email fire consultant Exova, accepted the zinc cladding being considered at the time would fail if there were external flames.

In response, an architect at Studio E said that “metal cladding always burns and falls off”.

In its evidence Celotex said: “None of the individuals involved in the March 2015 email exchange have sought to explain how their knowledge that the cladding would fail in the event of a fire with external flaming can be reconciled with their responsibility as designers, contractors or consultants to ensure, or exercise reasonable care to ensure, that the rainscreen cladding system on Grenfell Tower complied” with building regulations relating to the spread of fire.

The inquiry heard that there was no indication that any of those involved contemplated requesting a full-scale test of the proposed system.

Evidence from fire consultant Exova revealed that the Grenfell Tower was originally expected to be clad in zinc.

But value engineering led to the use of cheaper ACM cladding saving £454,000, according to a Harley estimate.

It said that when Rydon was appointed, it was on the basis of employer’s requirements which specified zinc cladding with an aluminium honeycomb core; and contemplated that alternative materials might be used but must comply with prevailing fire regulations.

“It was only later that – evidently guided by the pressure to cut costs – Rydon (together with Studio E and Artelia, and with support from Harley) pursued, and obtained client KCTMO’s approval for the change to ACM,” said Exova.

The fire consultant added that it was only then that work on designing the cladding system commenced, under a team that comprised Rydon, Studio E, and Harley.

The inquiry continues today with cladding manufacturer Arconic providing its opening statement.

Latest news

Three arrested in Blu-3 and Mace bribery probe

Serious fraud office swoops over alleged £3m bribes to former Mace associates
5 hours ago

Scotland’s most complex A9 dualling job heads to market

Market testing starts for £205m Pitlochry to Killiecrankie 6.4km upgrade
4 hours ago

Turkish contractor Limak to build new Luton Town stadium

Construction to start this summer on 25,000-seater venue
14 hours ago

Murphy on board at new £32m rail station

Construction to start next year at Golborne station
12 hours ago

HS2 engineers finish UK’s heaviest bridge slide early

A46 Kenilworth Bypass reopens 30 hours earlier than planned
12 hours ago

Bowmer + Kirkland to build £190m Oxford science scheme

Work to start at end of next month on 180,000 sq ft Fabrica scheme
19 hours ago

New BAM leisure centre pool springs a leak

Contractor investigating "technical issues" delaying new £36m green leisure centre
2 days ago

United Living lands £250m HyNet pipeline deal

Firm wins deal to design and build over 34km of pipework to collect CO2
20 hours ago

Hydrogen diggers get green light to use roads

JCB hails historic decision for advance of hydrogen-fuelled plant on sites
20 hours ago

Go-ahead for McAleer & Rushe Glasgow student job

£100m funding deal paves way for 591-bed student tower
20 hours ago

Fly-tippers to get their vehicles crushed

Drones will be used to identify cowboy construction waste operators
20 hours ago

Green light for £150m West End office revamp

Shaftesbury Avenue office retrofit retains 75% of original building
2 days ago

Morgan Sindall lands £20m Brunswick Wharf scheme in Bideford

North Devon waterside project will provide 100 flats
1 day ago

Former Keltbray managers jailed after corruption trial

Jail sentences following bribery probe on jobs including Battersea Power Station
2 days ago

Lidl pumps £500m into store and logistics expansion

Discounter plans 40 new stores this year as expansion ramps up
2 days ago

JJ Rhatigan UK profit jumps as turnover tops £150m

Irish contractor's expansion in England gathers pace
2 days ago

Driverless digger to be used on Taylor Woodrow site

Autonomous excavator to work at Manchester Airport after successful trial
2 days ago

MCS Build lands Basingstoke warehouse scheme

Construction starts this month after £26m funding deal
2 days ago

Leeds United unveil stadium revamp design

Club has still to set a timeframe for staged Elland Road upgrade
2 days ago

Bowmer & Kirkland boosts margins as profits surge to £69m

Revenue nudges up towards £1.3bn in year of expansion
3 days ago

Offshore construction starts on £4bn windfarm

Foundations for first of 95 turbines installed: Watch video
3 days ago

AECOM buys civils consultant Allen Gordon

Global giant acquires Scottish water and energy specialist
3 days ago

Plans in for £1bn Northern Gateway site in Manchester

Plan for 500-acre manufacturing and logistic park advance
3 days ago

RED wins £31m London Shoreditch student digs job

Two extra floors will be added to Willen House scheme
3 days ago

Deconstruct handed £12m Grenfell demolition

Firm maintaining building awarded job without bid race to speed process
3 days ago

Sizewell site workers get made to measure PPE

Bespoke fitting service on offer at new Bryson branch
3 days ago

Comment: Gateway is acting like a barricade

Contractors left banging their heads on an (unbuilt) brick wall
6 days ago

Final phase of £1.5bn Elephant and Castle revamp hits planning

Get Living submits revised plan for 500 homes and 450-bed student block
7 days ago

Ealing backs final phase of £1.3bn estate rebuild

Friary Park estate rebuild in Acton reaches end stage
6 days ago

Green light for scaled-down Nottingham student tower

Glasshouse Street scheme will deliver 247 student rooms
6 days ago

Contractor services