Grenfell Tower firms accused of merry-go-round of buck passing

Aaron Morby 6 years ago
Share

The professional team and key contractors involved in the Grenfell Tower refurbishment have been accused of passing the buck on who was responsible for the disaster.

On the opening day of of the second phase of the inquiry into the blaze that killed 72 people, Richard Millett QC, the inquiry’s chief lawyer, said that each firm critically involved in the project had attempted to shift the blame.

He said that the “sole exception” was the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea building control department, which accepted its failure in ensuring building work is carried out in accordance with regulations.

Statements from architect Studio E, main contractor Rydon Maintenance and cladding subcontractor Harley Facades revealed each was pointing the finger at the other about who had responsibility for choosing the flammable cladding system.

The Inquiry heard that both the architect, client and facade contractor had discussed using the aluminium cladding system before Rydon was engaged as the design and build contractor.

But Harley Facades claimed it could not be held responsible for choosing the cladding system only its installation contending that Studio E had the task of checking the suitability of the Reynobond panel and Celotex insulation system.

Rydon accepted it was contractually responsible as design and build contractor, but had inherited the design agreed originally between the client Kensington and Chelsea tenant management organisation and Studio E.

It said that under its contracts it had delegated responsibilities for cladding design to Studio E and subcontractor Harley Facades.

Rydon’s legal representative said the matter of what exactly was delegated and when should be “considered carefully by the inquiry”.

The Inquiry was also told that the Reynobond polyethylene-filled panel supplier Arconic was aware the panels being used on the tower were unsuitable and had performed worse in fire tests than declared on safety certificates.

Both Rydon and Harley also criticised PIR board supplier Celotex for making misleading claims about the suitability of its RS5000 insulation board on high rises building, again when it had become clear that there were issues with fire spread.

Harley Facades called on the Inquiry to bring in a cladding expert to set out accepted industry practice on where design responsibility lay between cladding installation contractors and architects.

Its legal representative added that there “was nothing unusual about the external facade system, which was widely used through the cladding design industry.”

Both Studio E and Harley also highlighted the systemic use of the cladding system across the industry, arguing that the specification had become an accepted system with 436 buildings found to be unsafe in the wake of Grenfell.

But the firms giving evidence on the first day were accused of trying to duck responsibility.

Millett said: “Not a single-core participant involved in the primary refurbishment of Grenfell Tower has felt able to make an unqualified submission against its own interests.

“Any member of the public reading those statements and taking them all at face value would be forced to conclude that… nobody made any serious or causative mistakes.

“In every case, what happened was, as each of them would have it, someone else’s fault.”

The inquiry continues today with statements from the cladding system manufacturers and suppliers.

Latest news

Eurotunnel fined £2.25m after surveyor hit by lighting

115kg lighting carriage fell during winching operation
26 minutes ago

Bovis swings back to profit after Atlas takeover reset

£35m provision cover drives turnaround following carve-out from Lendlease
6 hours ago

McAvoy go-ahead for £65m Bradford hospital overhaul

Modular specialist to start Lynfield Mount mental health hospital rebuild
2 hours ago

Vistry promotes from within to succeed Greg Fitzgerald

Adam Daniels to lead house builder
7 hours ago

Renaker profit climbs after bumper year of tower completions

Manchester tower builder completes 2,796 beds and flats in record handover year
6 hours ago

Rolls Royce signs small nuclear plants contract

Deal inked to deliver next generation of Small Modular Reactors
6 hours ago

MPB builds £160m pipeline as public sector pivot pays off

Cash and margins up as private market exposure cut
7 hours ago

Downing Construction sinks deeper into loss

Liverpool contractor hit by falling workload and mounting Building Safety Act provisions
6 hours ago

Mace tops March contracts league after big office win

London South Bank office project lifts firm to pole position
3 days ago

Barratt Redrow and PfP team up for 8,500-home garden town

JV lines up six-village garden town at Gilston in Hertfordshire
4 days ago

Government gives £380m grant to Agratas gigafactory

Public money towards construction of UK’s largest electric vehicle battery manufacturing facility
3 days ago

Guildmore hires United Living retrofit chief

Ben Whiterod joins London builder to drive growth in housing decarbonisation
3 days ago

Plans go in for first phase of 1.6m sq ft Mix Manchester

First submission at UK’s first airport-based science, innovation, and manufacturing campus
4 days ago

Strabag swoops to buy piling specialist Van Elle for £59m

Board of Van Elle backs takeover offer at 59% premium to share price
4 days ago

Red revamps group structure in push for growth

New London and East divisions plus luxury hotel business
5 days ago

Plans in for 814-home Salford waterfront scheme

Manchester developer Forshaw lodges triple resi tower Irwell plan
4 days ago

Guildmore in line for £60m London leisure and flats job

Bromley builder beats Morgan Sindall to deliver Tower Hamlets rebuild
4 days ago

Building safety regulator moves to unblock cladding fix backlog

New taskforce and lower caseloads aim to speed delayed high-rise remediation approvals
5 days ago

Erith lifts turnover as staff bonus pool tops £6.4m since 2017

Employee-owned demolition firm balances growth with margin squeeze
5 days ago

Manchester tower deal finally unlocked after four-year stall

£860m public-private fund steps in to kickstart 107-flat Ferrous scheme
5 days ago

Buyers report construction cost surge

Output down and material costs up shows latest survey
5 days ago

United Infrastructure exits housing with MBO of homes arm

Group severs long-standing house building link to double down on energy and infrastructure
5 days ago

VINCI bags landmark £100m Morecambe Eden job

Firm beats rival Kier to take landmark seafront attraction
5 days ago

HSE targets construction with tougher incident reporting shake-up

New RIDDOR rules set to widen reporting net on plant, tunnelling and site safety risks
5 days ago

JP Morgan clears flight path hurdle for Canary Wharf’s tallest tower

Bank set to submit plans for 265m, £3bn HQ after deal with London City Airport
5 days ago

£12bn developer framework set for October launch

Procure Partnerships opens market engagement to shape lots
5 days ago

Strabag buys structural steelwork specialist Crofton

European giant boosts offering with acquisition
6 days ago

CITB to spend £300,000 on ‘mystery shoppers’

Contract up for grabs for surprise checks on training and test centres
6 days ago

HMRC broadens CIS fraud powers beyond direct offenders

New ‘should have known’ rule shifts penalty risk onto main contractors
6 days ago

Race starts for £30m mega container store at London Gateway

12-storey steel-heavy build planned inside live port terminal
6 days ago