Ryhurst loses claim scheme scrapped over Grenfell

Aaron Morby 3 years ago

Rydon’s development arm Ryhust has lost a High Court battle for damages after claiming a £300m North London development scheme was scrapped because of its connection to the Grenfell disaster.

North London's Whittington Health NHS Trust abandoned public private partnership development scheme
North London's Whittington Health NHS Trust abandoned public private partnership development scheme

North London’s Whittington Health NHS Trust abandoned a procurement exercise for a 10-year strategic estates partnership contract, after previously deciding to award the contract to Ryhurst.

The firm was named preferred bidder for the strategic estate partnership just two weeks before Grenfell.

Ryhurst claimed that the central reason for later abandoning the procurement in June 2018 came from political pressure upon the Trust from local MPs, including Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and shadow frontbencher Emily Thornberry, as well as the Trust’s regulator, NHS Improvement.

The firm argued this was primarily because it was part of the Rydon group, responsible for the refurbishment of the Grenfell Tower.

Ryhurst contended that its connection had no relevance whatsoever to this procurement exercise.

The Trust said that its decision to abandon the procurement was lawful and was taken for a number of proper reasons.

It accepted that one of these reasons was the risk that some stakeholders would not engage in or support plans developed with Ryhurst.

It also accepted that one of the reasons which motivated those stakeholders was the connection, real or perceived, between Ryhurst and with Grenfell but it denied that this was the sole or indeed the primary reason for its decision.

The trust also argued that its plan to fund improvements to the hospital’s buildings through housing developments on the land had changed after a decision to sell Whittington land to Camden and Islington NHS Foundation Trust, which it wanted to build a new mental health hospital, was agreed.

The sale for £22m reduced the urgency to sell off its surrounding estate to developers.

Judge Stephen Davies, said: “Having considered the evidence and the arguments my decision is that Ryhurst has not succeeded in making out its case on liability so that its claim must fail.

“Had I found for Ryhurst on its primary case in relation to liability it would have succeeded in establishing causation and sufficiently serious breach.”

Latest news

Worker killed on £683m waste power plant site

Fatal collision involving heavy good vehicle on giant north London site
2 hours ago

Go-ahead for £200m lithium refinery on Teesside

Work to start next year on Europe's first lithium hydroxide processing plant
17 hours ago

HS2 agency workers paid the wrong wages

Payroll software problems leave workers out of pocket
17 hours ago

Electric car whizz joins O’Rourke

Contractor looking to learn tech lessons from other sectors
17 hours ago

Electrical contractors still confident despite staff shortages

Order books healthy but worries grow over margins
15 hours ago

BAM to deliver £44m Yeovil College campus build

BAM will submit a planning application next month to start work later next year
18 hours ago

Bouygues starts London 700-home council estate rebuild

Developer Linkcity seals financial close on Old Kent Road Tustin Estate job
18 hours ago

Construction’s “Leading Lights” recognised

Full details of latest winners of Considerate Constructor Scheme's latest awards
18 hours ago

ISG wins £600m Hertfordshire Hollywood film studio job

Holywood studio Sunset awards pre-construction contract for 90-acre studio complex in Broxbourne
4 days ago

NAO calls for road programme cuts as costs soar

Public spending watchdog calls for roads programme review amid project delays and cost overruns
4 days ago

Kier hires Laing O’Rourke veteran for London office push

Gus Wright takes up new London regional director role in January
4 days ago

VolkerFitzpatrick lands starring role on £174m film studios

Contractor to start main works on Eastbrook Studios in Dagenham
5 days ago

Wates poaches Balfour director to lead North West operation

Sarah Cooke to lead Wates Construction in the North West
4 days ago

£3.4bn Sellafield infrastructure race delayed to New Year

Contest to start in January for four partners in infrastructure delivery shake-up
4 days ago

Rebuilt TBM launches into second HS2 tunnel drive

Balfour Beatty Vinci TBM Dorothy starts second Long Itchingwood HS2 drive
5 days ago

Materials lead times back to pre-pandemic levels

Pinch points around gas boilers to persist until mid-2023 because of shortages of semiconductors
5 days ago

Bond strength helps TClarke towards £500m turnover target

Building services giant predicting a record year in 2023
5 days ago

All-clear for £125m Guildford Debenhams redevelopment

Native Land's St. Mary’s Wharf will comprise 185 homes
5 days ago

Thompsons brings down historic Redcar blast furnace – video

Redcar demolition clears the way for new net zero future
5 days ago

Wolverhampton picks McLaughlin & Harvey for £50m learning campus

Main construction to start next spring on City Learning Quarter
6 days ago

Michelmersh buys offsite brick cladding and chimney maker

Pre-built brick products producer Fabspeed sold for over £6m
5 days ago

Pagabo acquires mental health monitoring business

Framework giant makes move after Moodbeam goes into liquidation
5 days ago

Green light for London timber office block

Construction to start next year on six-storey cross-laminated timber block
6 days ago

Government pushes ahead with £3bn building safety levy plan

Affordable homes projects and small schemes developed by SMEs will be exempted
6 days ago

Rejigged £340m Museum of London plan approved

McAlpine tipped to take £340m job for new museum at Smithfield market
6 days ago

Ex-construction minister joins cladding repair firm

Intelligent FS appoints Lord Richard Harrington after government contracts send turnover surging
6 days ago

Willmott Dixon limbers up for £18m Rainham sports centre

Work to start in April on New Splashes Sports Centre in Rainham
6 days ago

Plans in for BBC’s new home in Birmingham

Project will be one of the first net zero carbon in construction office buildings
6 days ago

McLaughlin & Harvey wins Lowestoft harbour design

Lowestoft Eastern Energy Facility is expected to cost around £25m to build
7 days ago

Van Elle first-half revenue hits record £81m

Piling specialist upgrades full-year profit forecast after strong first-half trading
7 days ago

Contractor services